IT'S BRIGHTER NOW: An MSR Playlist ⤷ Part 7 of 10: Elsewhere ✧ based on this playlist by @laurencem
You were my best friend before you were my best guess at the future.
playlist / songs ↘
ELSEWHERE by Sarah McLachlan / "I believe this is heaven to no one else but me and I'll defend it as long as I can be left here to linger in silence if I choose to. Would you try to understand?" GAH the idea of pairing this song with "All Things" while Scully questions all her life choices... okay, fine, that's fine. Also knowing that both her parents questioned her decision to join the FBI and the lyric "Mother, can't you see I've got to live my life the way I feel is right for me?" Cool. The theme of this playlist is basically If/Then (choices), with a little bit of "I believe this is heaven" thrown in there as well.
ALL MY MISTAKES by The Avett Brothers / When I first read what Yeti wrote about "Elsewhere" and saw that she paired it with "All Things," this song was the first song I thought about. Admittedly, I don't listen to this version—I like Katie Rose Clarke's cover of the song, but I can't put that on the playlist, so I included this version. I think so much of "All Things" is Scully realizing that not all the things she worried were mistakes are actually mistakes, but at the same time—what if they are? Does that change anything? "I can't go back and I don't want to, 'cause all my mistakes—they brought me to you."
KING OF THE LOST BOYS by Sara Bareilles / I thought of this song because of this line: "don't you worry about the 'why,' those answers come in time, so leave your heart to wander." I think in this episode Scully finally understands the why, and it brings her so much peace. I like this line for her as well: "The monsters circle 'round, eyes upon you. Raise your head and let them hear your heart's choice." I think this episode brings her to a place where she can truly do just that.
BEST GUESS by Lucy Dacus / I was considering this song for three different playlists and couldn't decide. My instinct was for it to go with "All Things," which @libbytxf agreed with and helped me decide. I love the idea of pairing it with a Scully episode because she doesn't like to guess. She wants evidence, she wants rationale, she wants to know. And I think Mulder presents something particularly daunting for her because she really does know without knowing; he's her best guess. I love "I love your body, I love your mind. They will change, so will mine, but you are my best guess at the future" in the context of the revival as well, knowing Scully has doubts about some of the ways she has changed. And my favorite lines are so them: "You are my favorite place, you were my best friend before you were my best guess at the future."
WHAT IF? (REPRISE) by Idina Menzel / Listen, I can't have an episode like "All Things" and not include something from If/Then, and this has one of my favorite lines: "where will it lead—who can know? but you learn how to love the not-knowing, so here I go." And I was really excited to put it after "Best Guess," to go from her guessing to her embracing the unknown.
SIT HERE AND LOVE ME by Caroline Spence / I love the lyrics of this song, and I chose to put it on this playlist because it's exactly what's happening. He sits there, he listens, he loves her, and she feels so safe that she falls asleep. "I know you hate to see me cry, don't want to look you in the eye, I just need you to sit here and love me" is very Scully (and makes me think of "Irresistible"). I also really love this line: "please recognize my shadow; this is the same place from where I love you deeply."
ORDINARY by Amber Ais / I love when the chorus starts and the song becomes so joyous. Besides the idea of choices, the other thing I was thinking about while I made this playlist was "this is heaven to no one else but me," and I think a lot about Scully and how much she loves both Mulder and the x-files. "You are the beauty in the ordinary." She and Mulder are always looking for extraordinary things, and his enthusiasm and passion help her learn to see the magic in every day. I also think this song works for Mulder—he's searching so hard for the extraordinary, but then he meets Scully, and she is the most beautiful, wonderful, extraordinary thing to him.
THE MOST BEAUTIFUL THINGS by Tenille Townes / This one is also connected to the "heaven to no one else" line. I liked that there's the mention of prayer, but I also like that the idea is "maybe the most beautiful things in this life are felt but never seen" and the episode being "All Things." This tender moment of him tucking her hair behind her ear while she sleeps is something she doesn't see or necessarily know, but she feels it. And this show is so much about what it means to have faith, what it means to believe, and I love this line for them: "The only way I know any of this might even be true is the love I feel for you."
DAYLIGHT by Taylor Swift / This is a song I actually associate more with Mulder, but the "heaven" lyric and the idea of choice made me want to use it for this playlist. "I don't want to look at anything else now that I saw you. I don't want to think of anything else now that I've thought of you. I've been sleeping so long in a twenty-year dark night, but now I see daylight; I only see daylight." I apparently took Scully falling asleep very seriously because I do like the mention of her sleeping in a twenty-year dark night, but more than that, the first lines of the chorus are about choice. This is all she wants now that she knows it's there for her to choose, and it's all she sees. I also really love "I once believed love would be black and white, but it's golden" and "I once believed love would be burning red, but it's golden, like daylight" for Scully because I feel like both of those things could apply to her. She likes the black and white, clear-cut answers, and I can imagine her assuming that this is what it'd be like when she found her person—some sort of irrefutable evidence that allows her to know that this is the right choice. I also think that Mulder is very much red for some time (and Red could be a Mulder album, but that's a conversation for another day), but as they settle into each other and their relationship, it becomes golden (and I picture the scenes of them outside the unremarkable house, the way that feels golden).








