Siemens feeling the pressure of ewom
This post is part of a series on the book 'Marketing to China's Netizens, Persuaders of the World's Biggest Market'. For a book preview go to fluidnations.com.
A first look at Luo Yonghao and you see an unassuming English teacher, who works very hard to support his middle class lifestyle. So far one of hundreds of million in China. This teacher is upset because he has bought a brand new refrigerator with a malfunctioning door from an expensive international brand. By opting out of a Chinese make, he thought he paid for quality on all levels. German durability and reliability. Jawohl!
Putting myself in Mr Luo's shoes I see his point pretty easily. What good is a refrigerator when it doesn't shut properly. Surely this is an easy one for the complaints department! By the way, this wasn't the first time Mr Luo had had a problem with white goods from the same brand. He was a loyal customer who got disappointed too many times. Lessons from the past (Best Buy) teach us, that a disappointed customer who is then well served, is more likely to remain loyal than a customer who never had a problem in the first place. Siemens had a chance to WOW a customer into loving the brand, but chose a different tactic.
Siemens customer service department in China seemed better at keeping the customers out than dealing with the problems at hand. So when Mr Luo was repeatedly ignored, belittled or at the very least made to feel under-served by the German brand's customer service department, Mr Luo had finally had enough and sent a little tweet into China's Digital Landscape [incidentally, home to a mere 500 million netizens and China's most affluent and best educated consumers - see Chapter 1, Debunking China's Myths].
Now, for context, it helps to know that Luo Yonghao is a special kind of teacher who, through the gift of the gab and his humorous lectures, is wildly popular among his students. His following is no longer limited to a Beijing class room either. Thanks to the passionate re-tweeting of his funny quotes, his students have helped him gain a following of well over 1.3 million fans on China's microblogging platform Weibo (http://www.weibo.com/laoluoyonghao).
So Mr. Luo is what you could call an Efluencer in China, someone who has the power of persuasion through a wide digital social reach [Chapter 2, The Persuasive Powers of Netizens]. Unsurprisingly, China's Electronic World of Mouth did the job for Mr Luo's tweet. The voice of one quickly became the voice of thousands. The painful climax came when Luo Yonghao and 7 other disgruntled customers brought their refrigerators to Siemens China Head Quarters in Beijing and proceeded to smash them to pieces. A refrigerator with a malfunctioning door, from a brand that refuses to listen, might as well be no refrigerator at all!
It may seem a mystery why Siemens was caught off guard by the persuasive power of China's Netizens, but in fact few international brands are savvy participants on China's web. One reason is that the local digital landscape is a complex and quickly changing playing field. Another reason may be that digital marketing is not high enough on the strategic agenda of multinationals in general.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bAW2LPRn0vQ
After the smashing incident, Siemens refused to take responsibility still but when negative sentiment mounted further it had to back turn on its stubborn position. "Siemens Gate" ended on December 5th, when the president of Siemens China himself, Roland Gerke, had to bite the dust and make a public apology, true Chinese style. Gerke said that Siemens will take three measures to address the refrigerator door problems.
1. The German brand will open a Weibo page to resolve customer complaints and handle maintenance request [ed. Weibo is a twitter like platform, which will be used by Siemens as a retention tool; see CMO Guide to China's Digital Landscape in Chapter 3].
2. Siemens will provide door-to-door testing services to purchasers who are experiencing the problem.
3. Siemens will install a device to fix the problem at no cost if the problem persists.
It's hard to stop the bleeding when you've arrived too late on the scene. Siemens China may have learned a painful lesson and smartened up. Or it has introduced a short term solution to address the embarrassing problem at hand. If so, all we have to do is wait for the next public apology, because the power of persuasion remains in the hands of netizens. And Siemens' reputation will remain at peril.
In conclusion, to grow business in China, brands need to design a structure that engages Chinese consumers ongoingly in the domain where they feel most at ease to express themselves; in China's digital landscape. A framework in Chapter 2, China's Dragon of Persuasion explains how brands can go through 7 steps to strategically embrace China's netizens for a more sustainable brand position.