From the Archives: Julie Andrews with Petula Clark and Robert Beatty at BBC Studios for Music, Music, Music! (29 May 1954)
In the summer of 1954, 18-year-old Julie Andrews found herself biding time. Her first — and only — attempt at “straight” theatre, Mountain Fire, had been cancelled during its out-of-town tryout, but the young star had already signed on to sail for America to headline the Broadway production of The Boy Friend — and with it, a whole new world of opportunity.
Julie didn’t, however, spend the summer idle. Instead, she took on a string of radio and television appearances, including the one captured here.
Described as “a musical battle of wits,” Music, Music, Music! was the first of eight TV game show pilots the BBC trialled that summer, with the aim of selecting one for a regular run (The Scanners, 1954, p. 16). The program pitted two teams of celebrities — captained by Julie and Petula Clark respectively — against each other in a series of novelty musical questions and games.
By most accounts, it was not a success. Reported the Daily Herald:
Angry viewers telephoned the BBC last night to complain about TV’s new parlour game, “Music, Music, Music.” I don’t blame them. For a few moments during this 30-minute show there was chaos. The rest of the time was only near-chaos. Chaos came when a tuba, a motor-horn, a drum and a celeste were all played together with the panel members… shrieking and the chairman, David Jacobs, shouting for order… Heaven help us (Phillips, 1954, p. 3).
“Abysmal,” scowled the critic for the News Chronicle, though he did offer some grace to Julie:
My Bouquet... of the Week would go to Miss Julie Andrews – for knowing nothing so nicely. Just go on being your own charming self, Miss Andrews, and don't worry. There was nothing in “Music, Music, Music” worth knowing, anyway (Brittenden, 1954, p. 6).
Not surprisingly, Music, Music, Music! didn’t make the cut, and the BBC opted to greenlight one of the other game show pilots, Tall Story Club (Aynsley, 1954, p. 3). But for fans of Julie’s early career, this fleeting and chaotic TV experiment remains a fascinating curio — a reminder that real talent shines through, even in the noisiest of settings.
Sources:
Aynsley, C. (1954, 28 August). TV chooses new panel game. Daily Express, p. 3.
Brittenden, A. (1954, 2 July). This week it's all games and military might. News Chronicle, p. 6.
Phillips, P. (1954, 30 June). They're annoyed with the BBC. Daily Herald, p. 3.
The Scanners (1954, 25 June). Parade of parlour games. Radio Times, p. 15.
© 2025, Brett Farmer. All Rights Reserved.










