Kandra survives Cesar challenge ... and the Foot Fault
R2: Raphael Kandra (Ger) 3-1 Cesar Salazar (Mex) 11-8, 11-6, 8-11, 11-9 (51m)
It was ‘only’ 51 minutes, but this was the match of the tournament so far, finishing with the winner slumped on the floor, declining his opponent’s offer to help him up as he needed more time to recover from an astonishing final rally that left the large court 9 crowd applauding wildly - they would have loved a fifth.
There was a bit of controversy too, with Cesar being penalised three times for foot faulting, combined with a conduct stroke on the first of those.
Explanation : Referee Nathan Turnbull called a foot fault fairly early in the first game - “it was blatant,” he said, “I’ll always call those but the marginal ones are difficult.” [apparently someone sent in a video still and Cesar was almost over the centre line when he hit the ball].
But of course he didn’t say “Foot Fault” as all service faults - serving out, serving down, foot faulting and all the other illegal serves, are now called simply “Fault”.
Naturally the player then asks what the problem was and the Ref will say “foot fault” - begging the question of why don’t they just call “foot fault” in the first place (and for that matter, out is out, not a fault, but don’t get me started on that one #oopstoolate) .
On Court 9 the refs are seated a few rows back, and it’s genuinely difficult to hear sometimes. Nathan says he told Cesar it was a foot fault but Cesar didn’t hear it, so approached the door so that he could better hear the explanation.
He then opened the door - to be fair he was warned not to, can’t remember by who - to hear Nathan declare “your foot was out of the box”. Meanwhile Raphael was doing a bit of stirring, pointing and saying “he opened the door!”.
Of course, opening the door is a capital offence these days, so Nathan duly added on the conduct stroke to the faulty service and Cesar was two points worse off.
Two controversial matters in one then - personally, I don’t know anyone who thinks calling just “fault” is a good idea when “foot fault” and “out” are so obvious and simple, and the consensus I pick up is that the “don’t open the door” conduct stroke is excessive when the player is simply trying, in a non-aggressive manner, to find out what’s going on.
Anyway, enough of that - it was a very good match, Cesar got called for two more foot faults, and if you can wind the replay to the final rally you’ll definitely enjoy it!