Which subtitle fonts do you think looks the best? All of them look similar I know, but they're styled differently from each other. What would your top picks be?

seen from United States
seen from United States

seen from Germany
seen from Romania

seen from United States
seen from China

seen from United Kingdom
seen from Italy
seen from China

seen from Philippines
seen from Ireland

seen from United States
seen from Malaysia
seen from United States
seen from China
seen from Pakistan

seen from Australia
seen from United States
seen from China

seen from United Kingdom
Which subtitle fonts do you think looks the best? All of them look similar I know, but they're styled differently from each other. What would your top picks be?
heated rivalry gifset is awesome! Would you please consider a tutorial for the second gif blending and coloring.
https://www.tumblr.com/imtheiliad/805404684120653824/so-hard-to-believe-i-have-to-grow-up-this-way
hi! thank you so much <3 so I don't have the PSDs for that set anymore so the examples might look slightly different just like placement, exact frames, and colors. I use Photoshop 2026 to edit and will assume basic giffing (with video timeline) and sharpening/coloring knowledge, but if you need more details, I use this action pack + high pass as described here for sharpening and a tweaked version of this tutorial for my base coloring. Everything under the cut!
hello! I just found your blog via your recent titanic gifset with hozier lyrics and it truly is the most gorgeous thing I have seen on this site in recent times... so so amazing! could you talk about the fonts you used and a bit about the coloring/blending process? thanks so much and hope you have a wonderful week. - A
hello! this is such a sweet ask— thank you so much! i'm so thrilled to hear that you love my silly little titanic gifset 🤍
i spent,,,,,, way too much time on it as a way to try and distract myself from a) politics and b) the bomb cyclone. we live in a time.
anyway! it's probably the most labor-intensive set i've ever made: lots of frame by frame coloring, layer masks, etc., and honestly i would love to talk about it!
all of the gifs were challenging to some degree, but i'd be here for another two weeks if i went through the whole set, so i'm going to narrow the focus to just the second gif. info on how i made this guy below the cut!
So what’s everyone using to screencap these days? KMplayer is hella annoying now.......
i learned how to gif under my current method from a tutorial by user @cvmpbell-deactivated20200616 and um, well, as the mention says, they’ve deactivated. that said, i thought i’d share the information here for anyone who’d like to learn. i’m on photoshop cc 2020 for mac, but tbh as long as you have the timeline function you’re fine.
you will not require any screencaps or any software other than photoshop for this. (while i personally run my footage through iMovie first to cut out anything i don’t want this is very much not necessary to this process, it just may take longer to get through stuff if you have a huge video file. let’s get started!
just a warning this has a lot of large images in it, you are forewarned.
hey there, thanks for all you do for the community. i was wondering if you’d be so kind to post a tutorial on how you making your theme preview gifs?
hello !! thank you so much for your kind words !! 💌 i’m sure there’s an easier way to go around this , but i personally like to make a preview gif out of screenshots rather than screenrecording ! click the read more for a tutorial with pictures 🍯
I really the colouring for those gifset 💛 would you please teach me how did you do the colouring for the third gif.
https://www.tumblr.com/imtheiliad/790368548831838208/juliet-ohara-psych-2006-2014-pscentral-event?source=share
Happy to share! i have never done a tutorial before so sorry if this is rough. I don't even know if the way I executed this is the best or most efficient.
I use Photoshop 2025 to edit and will assume basic giffing (with video timeline) and sharpening/coloring knowledge, but if you need more details I use this action pack + high pass as described here for sharpening and a tweaked version of this tutorial for my base coloring. (shout out to @eddiediaaz who has been my go to for giffing advice and tutorials<3)
Everything under the cut, let me know if you need anything cleared up!
a while ago I saw someone say that we didn’t have to make the middle gif in sets of three gifs in a row 178px anymore (because tumblr had fixed that, according to them). and today I saw a tutorial mentioning a different width for big gifs (bigger than 540px). thanks for answering!!
ah okay! i haven't heard anything about sets of three changing, but i haven't made one recently, so i can't speak to that. however, i can confirm for you that 540px is still the recommended width, per tumblr:
you can absolutely make wider gifs, but the larger dimensions will only be displayed correctly when the individual gifs are clicked on. i've never posted anything wider than 540px so i can't say for sure, but you might run into quality/loading issues. i'd actually say that's pretty likely, given that tumblr is a) held together with duct tape and b) actively warning against going beyond 540px
UPDATE: some other gifmakers chimed in down in the replies (thank you @madeline-kahn and @withered-rose-with-thorns!) and while it appears tumblr will add a 1px column of padding to the right side of your post if you upload three 177px gifs in a single row, it will also make one of the gifs blurry. i'd recommend sticking with 177 x 178 x 177 to make sure everything is as crisp and clear as possible
good luck with your giffing ✨