We had a headcanon elimination game on discord, and here are some of the ideas we came up with:
Killercule polycule (floreleine+scarletmay main couples, but they are all romantically together) - @floreleine - 2nd place in the game!
Scarletmay are dog people while Floreleine favour cats - @deenas-johnson
Emily figured out the librarians are all in love (one day the four of them try to explain it and after a lot of awkwardness, Emily is like oh yeah i figured it out the first day isn't this totally normal whatever) - @sarah-fiers - 6th place in the game!
The librarians all live at the library together - @floreleine
All three librarians started together - @floreleine
The two wings in the library were only furnished after Sam and Scarlet started coming more often – that’s also where they store the real books. - @verbumproxen
While Emily has already decided she wants to be a librarian, Sam would rather she take after madeleine, but a couple of her grandmas have other ideas - @bombsbaybeee
Anna May and Florence come from enemy crime families - @floreleine - 9th place in the game!
The librarians have odd sleeping habits because of their job (Madeline is an early riser, Anna May is a night owl, they don’t even know when Florence sleeps most of the time) - @sarah-fiers
Masterpost linking to all headcanons