Thanks to those of you who have brought me some ideas on how to re-work the blog-off to try and turn it away from being a popularity contest! It’s very much appreciated.
After some thinking, these are the possible changes that may take place:
OPTION A: USER-VOTED TOURNAMENT, WITH DIVISIONS
This would mean we keep the same 1v1 match up structure, only the blogs would be divided into divisions according to how many followers they have on entry. Divisions would likely be 0-100 followers, 100-200 followers, and 200+ followers. Only a first prize will be awarded, $10 in gems for the winner of each division.
PROS:
Voters will still have to vote in all categories. They won’t be able to ignore voting for the little guys.
Less chance of smaller blogs being knocked out in favour of more popular blogs, a better chance of exposure for everyone.
Blog owners may lie about number of followers (no way to verify).
Divisions aren’t likely to be even in number--some divisions will go on much longer in voting than others. Blogs in one division may have more chance of winning than blogs in a larger division.
OPTION B: FEATURED BLOGS WITH MONTHLY LOTTERY
This would be you guys submitting a description of your blog to GW2Notes, similar to how you do for compliments to other people. Depending on how many submissions we get, these posts will be queued and posted to the blog to signal boost your awesome GW2 blog, and the things you’d like from it (more asks, more followers, or even commission requests). This would be open to all GW2 based blogs, even those that aren’t strictly IC.
Again, depending on how many submissions we get, admins may visit the blogs and add their own notes on what they found and what they enjoyed. Once a month, the names of all the blogs that were featured will be placed into a randomiser and the winner awarded a prize.
Not just restricted to IC blogs. Those of you with art, or just general GW2 blogs would also be encouraged to submit.
All blogs will get some time in the spotlight. Users will be able to request the sort of things they want, and showcase any art, writing, or other tags.
Allows for a much more in-depth description of the blog written by the blog owner.
Is a much more long-term, ongoing venture that can showcase all blogs as they are created. May be expanded to include Character of the X, or to showcase guilds, etc, depending on how it is received.
Admins may review the blogs personally, depending on demand.
First-submit, first-post and lottery nature of reward means everything is entirely fair and completely avoids a popularity contest.
Heavily relies on everyone to reblog and signal boost the blogs outside of GW2Notes posting.
Funding for rewards could be difficult long-term.
Less of a competition than Option A. Less fun? Unsure there.
As always, I need your input as to which of these two options you think would be better. Please answer to this post, reblog, or send us a note!
We’re listening! What do you want to see done?