I think I'll forever be bitter that the Erins almost entirely removed all concepts of unique aspects of clan life to make almost every clan a Thunderclan version but wearing a different hat
Like, I'm pretty certain it's mentioned in the first arc that Shadowclan lurks in the shadows and isn't seen much during the day, I KNOW theres mention of Shadowclan cats wearing the shade like a second pelt. I'm also like. 90% sure it's fully canon that Shadowclan were night hunters, and the tail motions leaders use to communicate before entering to attend a gathering WAS developed by Shadowclan for night hunting tactics. That and I wish the fact that they lived on a marsh was used more. I want Shadowclan cats to have remnants of webbing between their toes, for their paws to be broad so they don't sink as much, and their legs shorter, but stocky. Their faces big and round and their ears small and wide set, their eyes wide and almost always dilated because they hunt at night. They look scary to other clans, and turn into spooky stories that Thunderclan and Windclan apprentices whisper about at night, and sometimes if they're unlucky and sneak out in the night, they catch a glimpse of big eyes shining in the darkness at them.
On one hand it could be said that when Tigerstar took over, he imposed Thunderclan sleep habits upon Shadowclan cats, being a Thunderclan born cat and all. He would've likely forced Shadowclan to work during the day and reform their sleep schedules around HIS desires, erasing that part of their clan life and identity, and to some extent perhaps even their culture as a whole.
Windclan, of course, lost the two unique roles they had in clan of moor runners and tunnelers, and while it's for good reason of the tunnels collapsing too often and killing/injuring cats, I wish they'd stayed. Or that Tallstar had reimposed them, with no stigma or habit for bloodlines to ONLY be a tunneler or moor runner, so no cat would be pulled in two directions, or be expected to do one thing and one thing alone.
Skyclan is.. Yknow. Skyclan. I wish they kept daylight warriors as a role, I wish they'd used more TREE hunting than anything else. I think it'd be interesting if Skyclan primarily hunted birds and squirrels in trees, that their territories have always been those thick forests where the branches twine together and there's no crown shyness to be seen, where touching the ground is almost unheard of except to get water, herbs or to go to the bathroom. I think it'd be interesting to have cats come to Skyclan, and have to scale a tree just to see a skyclan cat.
Riverclan seems to have suffered the least from the Thunderclan But With A New Hat and I think it's because Riverclan is harder to impose Thunderclan stuff onto. They hunt fish, they swim, they're constantly described as big, long furred, or beautiful, their territory has the second least amount of trees now that Shadowclan is primarily in pines over marsh.












