I'm gonna be pretend bold and say some thoughts about Roathe . Teehee or something
I think dismissing him entirely as a character as just some gross, annoying weirdo is sort of like saying you whole heartedly cannot handle any nuance or narrative reasoning for why he may exist. Even if you're like me and didn't really want more protoframes to think about. You can dislike characters, I really don't care if you do or don't, but to say he isn't fascinating is hurting my soul a little.
Roathe is, to a degree, an implied former antagonist and now he's just some de-fanged former military-flavor sadist. The devil and dealing references are very heavy handed, as well. If he's dead in the water as a character from that in terms of taking anything he says in KIM chats seriously you're sorta falling for the inversed halo effect. Just because he IS a devil doesn't mean he's always lying. It doesn't mean he always has the worst intentions... but most definitely ones that benefit him.
He wasn't an all powerful guy either. Depending how far you get in the chats the implication is pretty clear he was at his best, a high achieving fucktoy with a military title. He wanted to do the same thing the Tenno did and be rid of the Orokin, even if it was not as easily executable by him or as trustworthy.
I forced myself to not spoil myself with reading ahead with the kimulacrum but it seems to me he's being set up as a self-hating sort of guy and being given the chance at redemption. With how badly people want Entrati to come around to being a good character or not having to kill him for their own reasons, in comparison I feel like Roathe is rather small potatoes given he's just another one of Entrati's victims where the power imbalance wasn't in Roathe's favor in their society. I genuinely do think it's a good thought generator - PURELY INSIDE THE CONTEXT OF THE GAME NOT AFFECTED EXTERNAL BIAS - as why the game is prompting you to converse with Roathe. To potentially forgive him. Why Entrati picked HIM to decipher if their caste of people are forgivable. Will you forgive Roathe? Will you understand Roathe? Will you forgive Entrati, and understand him as well? Are you willing to learn and bear the weight of what it means to have the naked and horrible humanity of the people you dislike face you and measure that against their crimes? Is it making you reflect on anything else in the game or in real life? These are things worth exploring.
Anyways, I'm gonna continue enjoy this stupid blue brat and see what happens.















