You're Still Beautiful to Me (Sarah Sanderson x reader)
Description: you had prepared for Sarah to be upset when you told her you were a guy, but her reaction ends up being the complete opposite to what you'd thought it'd be
A/n: I know a lot of the queer girlies have been writing some wlw fics with Sarah, and while I love those I've been feeling kind of dysphoric lately so I've decided to write one where the reader is a trans guy coming out to her instead. Enjoy 😌✌
Warnings: modern au where the sisters were brought back but didn't die (also they don't eat the souls of children anymore btw if you liked them better when they did then I'm sorry), transmasc reader, coming out insecurities, Sarah is pretty heavily implied to be on the bisexual spectrum (and she might also be slightly out of character since I've never written for her before)
Today was the day. You were finally going to do it. You were going to tell your girlfriend you were trans.
Of course, since she was from another century, you'd most likely have to word it more in a way she'd understand, but that was besides the point.
When you arrived at the small cottage she live in with her sisters, you found that she was outside, frolicking in the grass.
"Amok, amok, amok, amok, amok," she said to herself over and over again, dancing about as she did so.
"Hey, Sarah," you called out, greeting her.
Her face immediately lit up the moment she heard your voice, and she traipsed over to where you were, wearing the biggest grin while she did so.
"Hi, sweetie!" Sarah waved at you, giving you a hug before she began happily bouncing around the yard.
You watched her with a smile, having to mentally remind yourself why you were there in the first place.
"Sarah, I have something important I need to tell you."
"What is it?" She only paused her excited jumping momentarily, letting you know you had caught her attention before she started bouncing around again. "What is it?" She repeated. "Tell me, tell me, pleaseee."
You let out a somewhat nervous laugh at her silly shenanigans before continuing. "It's about... it's about me, and who I am."
"Oh?" She looked at you quizzically while tilting her head.
"I, um, I don't think I'm a girl anymore, actually. I think I'm a guy. I hope you're okay with that." You closed your eyes tightly, bracing yourself for her reaction. It was quiet for a second, before you heard her give out a very loud exclamation of joy.
"Yippee!"
You opened your eyes to see Sarah doing cartwheels all around you.
"Wait, you're- you're okay with it?"
"Of course I'm okay with it, silly!" She insisted, stopping in front of you. "This just means that now instead of having a super awesome girlfriend, I have a super awesome boyfriend!" She giggled. "Either way, you're still beautiful to me."
You gave her a heartfelt smile. "Aw, thanks, hun."
She squealed again before wrapping you in the biggest bear hug ever. "I love the twenty first century! We never got the chance to change our genders back in the olden times!"
Laughing, you hugged her back. "I'm just glad you accept me for who I am, unlike some people."
She let go of you, looking at you with a somewhat serious expression on her face, which was incredibly rare for her. "What people? What kind of people don't accept you? Just tell me who they are, and then I can go get Winnie and Mary to help me deal with them for you."
"Sarah, no. We've talked about this, you can't just use your magic on every single person who upsets you," you gently scolded her.
"Sarah, yes," she grinned, a glint of mischief in her eyes.
"Sarah, no."
"Aw, but- it's fun," she pouted at you in an attempt to get you to change your mind.
You simply shook your head at her in disbelief. "What are earth am I going to do with you?" You playfully asked.
"Love me to bits," she responded before giving you a sloppy kiss on the cheek.
And indeed, you did.
~
{Divider by @silkholland}
Main masterlist | Hocus Pocus masterlist | wanna be added to my taglist?
