By LemonLuvGirl87 Rated E for future content. Card #1 Prompt Heartbroken
Summary:
For my dear friend Horny Anon, without you I never would have pushed myself to imagine a world like this. Because what could be better than Peeta Mellark I asked when you sent your smut request to my tumblr inbox. Two Peeta Mellarks you answered. And thus this fic was born. (Also wanted to submit this for the Everlark holiday bingo challenge under the square Heartbroken) @promptsinpanem
Katniss Hawthorne signed her married name for the last time on the bottom of her divorce decree. Just like that she was no longer married. No longer Gale’s wife. No longer Mrs. Hawthorne. Just in time for the holiday season.
After this she would officially be Katniss Everdeen again.
Merry Christmas to me, Katniss thought sarcastically, with a wounded undertone that smacked of bitterness.
She looked up at Piers Mellark, her divorce attorney and gave him a weak smile, before handing the document back to him. He grinned enthusiastically and gave her a thumbs up. That handsome smile would have weakened her knees if she had been standing. But luckily they were seated at a small out of the way booth in his brother’s bakery to finish signing the necessary papers to finalize her divorce. It was a Tuesday, mid-afternoon and the bakery was quiet with very few customers.
“Ok, you’re officially free Sweetheart.” Piers told her as he filed the papers away in his briefcase and she chuckled nervously. When he looked up he adjusted his square cut wire rimmed glasses slightly and the move made Katniss’ fingers itch to reach out and trace the outline of them. They made him look intelligent and mature. She really liked it when Piers pushed them up after they slid down his face. It was cute. It was also one of the ways to tell the identical twins apart, as Peeta preferred to wear contacts since he said working in a busy kitchen was not conductive to eyewear that could easily slip off or fog up.
“So now what?” Katniss asked Piers as she folded her hands in her lap to keep from fidgeting while the soft instrumental Christmas music played in the background of Mellark’s bakery. Even after all these years his blue eyes still unnerved her. And his mischievous grin, which was so different and yet so similar to the one his gentle shy twin usually wore, still made her insides twist uncomfortably.
Pathetic. Katniss thought to herself. She was a grown woman, and she’s known Piers and his twin Peeta nearly all her life having grown up in the same small New England town. She should be used to those arresting deep blues by now. That smile should have been old news.
But today of all days, she felt just a little more vulnerable than usual. And his smile hit her in a deep way that made her feel incredibly weak and feminine and also incredibly hopeless.
She was 32, and she was now divorced. She didn’t have any romantic prospects. She didn’t have any children, which was in some ways a blessing and a curse. Good in the sense that no one was getting hurt in this divorce but her. Bad in the sense that at 32 years old, after dissolving her marriage of 5 years, she was now completely alone. No family to speak of after the accident that killed her mother, father, and sister when she was 19. Most of her friends had moved away from the small town where she grew up, in favor of going to big universities and chasing prestigious jobs and internships. Katniss was one of the rare ones that stayed and drove 2 hours to the local community college for classes when she finished highschool. She had gotten a degree in accounting and her small business did fairly well in the sleepy town of Panem.
She wasn’t rich by any stretch of the imagination. But she would be able to get by without Gale. Piers had made sure she got to keep the house she had inherited after her parents passed. And her new car she had just purchased at the beginning of the year, which was all she really cared about. Gale got to keep his truck, the antique collection of hunting rifles that he loved, and his new girlfriend that was 5 months pregnant.
Katniss should have known something was up the minute he stopped pressuring her to have kids. But she never thought Gale would actually cheat on her. Especially not with his blond, barely legal secretary.
Her sister Prim had often accused her of being blind to matters of the heart back when she was alive. And Katniss’ friend Johanna had nicknamed her Brainless during the time they had classes together in community college when it came to dating and relationships. That was before Johanna moved away to start her new job in the big city.
Suffice to say, any idiot would have seen it coming. Looking back there were so many signs. But she had been oblivious to the affair until Gale had taken her out to a restaurant a week before their 5 year anniversary and broke the news to her over a bowl of her favorite lamb stew.
Kantiss had promptly poured the hot soup all over his head and fancy suit before walking out. On the drive home she had looked up local family law attorneys. The only one in town just happened to be the man sitting across from her today.
At first Katniss had worried it would be incredibly awkward to hire an old classmate to handle her divorce. But Piers had been a godsend. He was quick, efficient, hadn’t tried to squeeze her for every cent she was worth, and he was also great at using humor to diffuse tense situations. There were many a day when his self-deprecating jokes had saved her from dissolving into a puddle of tears.
He looked over at her then and Katniss realized how much she was going to miss seeing him and talking to him regularly now that this was all over. He had been more than a good divorce attorney. He had also been a really supportive friend. So had his brother. Throughout the whole ordeal.
“Piers, I just wanted to thank you. For everything. You’ve made this process as painless as possible. I would have lost my mind if it hadn't been for you, and Peeta.” Katniss told him in a quiet voice, as her eyes misted over with tears.
Piers seemed startled for a moment at the earnest and sad look in her eyes but he recovered quickly. He reached across the table and covered her small shaking hand with his large one and squeezed gently.
“None of that now Kat, you know it was purely out of self interest I helped you divorce that prick. I would help you divorce a hundred husbands if it meant hanging out with you on Tuesdays and eating my brother’s RIDICULOUSLY UNDERPRICED BAKED GOODS.” Piers called out the last words loud enough for his twin brother, Peeta to hear from where he was standing over by the counter pretending to wipe down the glassy surface that was already pristine.
Katniss laughed heartily, brushing at the corner of her eyes as her small frame shook with amusement. Piers always knew when to insert his own particular brand of humor into a situation to relieve the tension. One of his running jokes was how Peeta was crazy for coming back to their small town to sell his delicious goods at rock bottom rates even though he had a culinary degree and was a professional pastry chef. Peeta took his constant ribbing in good humor and usually gave as good as he got, saying that Piers was the one wasting his talents in Panem, when he could be partnering at a huge law firm in some big city. Usually the only targets of their jokes were the brothers themselves. Although in the last few months that she’d been seeing them more often, the twins had by mutual agreement taken to also making cutting remarks about her soon-to-be ex husband and his lack of intelligence or taste. Katniss knew that both men were just trying to be good supportive friends, knowing that neither man had a truly unkind bone in their strong stocky bodies.
Katniss heard Peeta’s loud steps before she saw him, and the fact that he and his brother had the same equally thunderous gait made her bite the corner of her lips to keep from bursting out laughing again. The brother’s similarities and differences always astounded her. She turned in her chair to face a disapproving Peeta who wore a festive holiday themed apron of green and red. She took in his broad shoulders, and his toned torso underneath the apron and brown sweater he was wearing with an almost lurid fascination. But his gaze was aimed at Piers not at Katniss.
“What are you shouting about now Piers? Is he being obnoxious, Katniss? Because I’ll throw him out, just say the word.” Peeta threatened as he stared his brother down with mock seriousness. Kantiss shook her head and answered in the negative as she giggled obnoxiously. But not before Piers muttered a pretty loud ‘I’d like to see you try’, quip.
“No, no. He’s fine Peeta, I promise. Piers was just trying to save me from embarrassing myself. Like always. I was about 2 seconds away from melting into a puddle like Frosty the Snowman on a summer day. Except no one will have compassion on a 30 year old divorcee crying into her cheese buns like they would for a magical snow creature.” Katniss joked but Peeta’s expression became concerned.
“Of course they would be Kantiss. Everyone in this town loves you. Gale’s an absolute idiot and he was so wrong in the way he treated you. I just heard today that Haymitch told Gale he’s upping the rent on his building space. I think the old crotchety bastard is trying to run Gale off out of spite.” Peeta told her as he placed a large hand on her shoulder and smiled down at her.
“Oh that’s great! Way to go Abernathy!” Piers commented excitedly before starting to chuckle. Peeta dipped his head in agreement as he locked eyes with his brother and some kind of unspoken amusement flickered between them, but then turned his gaze back to Katniss. She was biting her lip distractedly.
“I hope he doesn’t lose his business. The hunting goods store is all he has now to support his family with.” Katniss murmured as she looked out the window and down the street. The store in question sat at the end of the block, its sign proudly declaring the name Hawthorne’s Hunting & Wilderness Wares in green and gold. But it had seen better days. And now that Katniss wouldn’t be there to help Gale keep the books and stay on budget Katniss worried that the store might not survive long past the new year.
Katniss recalled the day she and Gale had picked out the colors of the sign together. Her favorite color and his. It seemed so long ago, a memory from an infinitely happier time that made her heart ache with longing. Not for the husband that left her. Katniss had realized during the divorce that she never should have married Gale when it was clear they wanted such different things out of life. But she mourned the loss of her best friend, her partner, and confidant.
Things would never go back to the simple way they had been, when she and Gale were young adults struggling to make it in a world with just their wits and their survival skills. For a minute Kantiss even felt she’d never be happy again at all.
So when she felt an unstoppable wave of tears coming on she did the only thing she could think of doing.
She choked out a barely audible “I’m sorry, I’m a mess right now. I need to go.” Before her metal chair was scraping loudly against the floor as she pushed up from the table and tried to flee.
Peeta and Piers' simultaneous cries of “Kat wait!” and “Katniss, where are you going?” could be heard throughout the empty bakery as she darted away.
BTW, I'm like soooo close to finishing the 2nd part of the threesome fic. Prepare yourself HA. The smut is about to blow up my dear. Hold onto your hat, and whatever other valuables you have.
Still feeling sick…and kind of sad 😢. Cheer me up with some tidbits about Piers/Peeta/Katniss’ future? Do they ever have kids?
-H.A.
p.s. I have brown eyes
Hey H.A., I’m so sorry you’re still under the weather sunshine. Ok, so here’s some juicy tidbits for P+K+P.
They will have an epilogue 1 year later where they (all 3) go to Hazelle’s Christmas Party and *gasp!* see Gale and his baby momma and baby.
Its gonna be pretty good.
Also Piers and Peeta will both move in with Katniss during the year.
People in town have suspicions about their relationship and don’t know which one of them Katniss is really dating. (I might write a small chapter about that) and the funny questions Katniss and the boys get.
We will find out more about Peeta & Piers’ family and backstory in future chapters.
Also I haven’t decided yet if they are all gonna get married in a groovy little poly amorous ceremony or if they will have kids or not. I’m still thinking about it.
darling! I miss you too and your funny asks! Sorry I've been kind of MIA lately. I'm getting two rooms in my house remodeled and gosh its been insane! It's so annoying.
Its taking forever and the entire house is in chaos. But, I digress! What's new with you? I saw your penis comment at the end there. Does that mean you are feeling extra satisfied lately or extra unsatisfied?
