Joseph & Aesop with a shy S/O
You had developed huge feelings for both Joseph and Aesop while you were at the manor.
And somehow, the hunter you got paired with the most was Joseph.
Which only escalated your feelings somehow, you weren’t really sure how as he was the *hunter* and his job was to capture you guys,
But that didn’t matter to you. One thing Joseph liked was taunting you and chasing you around rather than just hitting you straight up.
I mean, you both knew he could get you in an instant if he wanted to, but he didn’t seem to want to. He always used to try to get you last, too.
Naturally, you being shy, you were intimidated of him a little bit. It wasn’t fear, per se, but damn did he look scary chasing after you.
And it didn’t help that he always seemed to target Aesop alot in rounds you were paired up with the both of them in a match.
After time, you started to notice both of them being a bit weird, usually around you. Not weird as in obvious i like you weird,
But more of they knew the other liked you. You were clueless, though. Joseph always seemed to target him first, and Aesop seemed fed up with it.
See, the thing was, they actually both confessed to liking you at the same time one day after a match after a slight argument.
You were surprised as all hell. I mean… *Both* of them??? You ended up confessing too on a whim.
Then they asked you which one you’d choose. You said that you didn’t have to necessarily choose just one.
They were confused, and then you explained Polyamory and how it could work out. They agreed somehow.
I mean, it was a little weird for the both of them, considering they’ve never been in such a situation before,
But you guys made it work. In a duos hunter match, Joseph always makes sure the other hunter *KNOWS* not to touch you.
Aesop always follows you around in matches to make sure you’re never hurt or taken. He always chooses to save you with the rebirth ability he has so that if you’re ever caught, you won’t die with him around.
Joseph still targets Aesop though, but it’s more of just a for fun thing rather than an out of spite thing.
Once your guys’ relationship becomes a little bit more intimate, (not *THAT* way, i’m speaking affection wise) You get matching shirts for you three.
They’re a bit confused, and hesitate at first but they still occasionally wear them whenever you want to because if you’re happy, they’re happy.
Aesop isn’t really a petname type of guy, so he’ll rarely ever call you pet names. Usually just nicknames if he wants to. However, Joseph on the other hand…
‘Mi amor’, ‘Love’, ‘Dear’, ‘Darling’, ‘Dearest’, ‘My love’, anything like that, he’ll call you. It always makes your heart melt, and he loves to see your expression once called that. He finds your shyness adorable.
For your first date with Joseph, he takes you to an empty map in the red church, and you don’t know how, but he gets Antonio to play the violin there, too. He kind of spoils you, to be honest.
However, Aesop is content with going to darker places and just hang out with you there. He’d definitely take you out to one of the maps at night if he wanted to, maybe bring a few snacks, but he’s not really a dinner & candle type of guy.
I mean if you really want it, he’ll definitely do it, but he also just likes being there with you in places in general.
Aesop has a HUGE soft spot for you, as does Joseph, but Aesop is more expressive with it.
Neither are really a cuddle type, but if you fall asleep on one of them they won’t move you or complain.
Infact, since the three of you are together so much, sometimes that happens. They usually talk about you if that happens.
Aesop really loves your hair. Like, he’ll definitely play with it if you allow him to.
Joseph often kisses your hand whenever he sees you. It’s really adorable and all that, but he usually does it just to see you blush.
Joseph. spoils. you. I said it once, and I *will* say it again. He spoils you. He brings you constant stuff from the manors side or anything fancy he can find for you.
Like if he sees a ring, he’s gonna buy you one. Not necessarily for marriage, but just as a gift in general.
Even though you guys are dating, you’re still kind of shy around them. They try to encourage you and reassure you that you can be whoever you want to around them, as they won’t judge you.
Honestly? You weren’t expecting them to like you back at all. but at the end of the day,
You knew you wouldn’t trade it for the world, and neither would they.