Exercise: The History of Illustration - E. H. Shepard and Dave McKean
E. H. Shepard (1879 - 1976) began his career illustrating editions of Aesop’s Fables, David Copperfield by Charles Dickens and Tom Brown’s School Days before drawing cartoons for Punch, a popular satirical and comic magazine. During the First World War, in his thirties, he served in the trenches and for military intelligence, recording enemy positions with his illustration skills. After the war, Shepard continued to work for Punch, for a time as Head Cartoonist, before being removed by the new manager in 1953.
Whilst at Punch, E. H. Shepard was introduced to A. A. Milne by a colleague and established a productive working relationship, E. H. Shepard providing the iconic illustrations for the Winnie-the-Pooh series, which were used as a basis for the classic Disney movie. Shepard also illustrated Kenneth Grahame’s The Wind in the Willows. For the purposes of this exercise I’ll focus on E. H. Shepard’s Winnie-the-Pooh illustrations, as they are the best known of his work and there’s a large pool of work there to analyse.
Dave McKean (1963 - ) is an artist, illustrator, photographer, musician and filmmaker. His career began in 1986 when he met author Neil Gaiman, and the pair published several smaller comics together before the highly successful The Sandman series was released, which brought McKean and Gaiman properly into the public eye. McKean also illustrated DC’s Arkham Asylum. Since then he’s published numerous comics,illustrated several more Neil Gaiman works including Coraline and The Day I Swapped My Dad For Two Goldfish, illustrated books by S.F. Said, David Almond, Steven King, Ray Bradbury, Richard Dawkins and many more. He’s designed album covers and promotional artwork, produced concept artwork for major feature films and directed MirrorMask, written with Neil Gaiman from 1998 and released in 2005.
Did the work of the illustrator you chose seem old fashioned? How?
Shepard’s illustrations for Winnie the Pooh have a classic, literary feeling, reminding me of the pen and ink style I’ve seen in illustrations for Sherlock Holmes or The Secret Garden, however with a bit more of a sweetness and cosy humour, a bit more playful and cartoonish than those more representational images. I feel like Shepard’s style fits the books and characters very well, with their reassuring combination of more grown up thoughtful-ness/ character observation and gentle humour reflected by the “classic” pen and ink style and “cartoonish-ness” where the lines become less representational and more humourous. When I read the books growing up, the illustration style made me feel like they were somewhat serious and mature books for me to read, which made me feel accomplished. They feel quietly enticing like doodles in the author’s notebook, as if you were being read the stories directly by the paternal voice of A. A. Milne and being given an inside look. The landscape of the Hundred Akre Wood is relatively realistic, somewhat sparse and scrubby, so feel more relatable and familiar than a big colourful jungle - you could meet the characters in the trees at the bottom of your garden.
“I was able to draw many of the places with the comfortable feeling of - it really happened here-” E. H. Shepard on creating studies from life at Ashdown forest to consolidate into the finished Winnie the Pooh illustrations.
What attracted you to the work of your chosen contemporary artist?
Dave McKean’s artwork is highly textural, feels cinematic, can feel both bleak and stark or warm and intimate through specific lighting and colour choices. I love his combinations of rich colour and texture with deep black shadows or scratchy black lines, this is something I love producing in my own artwork. His illustration work and faces feel very sculptural and influenced by his 3D work, like masks but also sensual. There’s an off-putting, distant feeling by the mask-like nature, but intimacy from warm skin tones and fleshy shapes. Cinematic feeling from almost theatrical lighting and texture, cartoony feeling where the text requires more comedy with the scratchy lines and wacky shapes and expressions.
I picked McKean’s illustrations of Neil Gaiman’s The Wolves in the Walls to focus on for this exercise because I thought the comparison with E. H. Shepard’s work would be interesting. Both works feature anthropomorphic animals and relatable childhood experiences (playing with soft toys, being scared of monsters hidden in your house) but the nature of the animals is far darker and chaotic in The Wolves in the Walls, and I feel like the multifaceted, abstracted mixed media artwork reflects this mood.
Sometimes the wolves are completely abstract; mad and dark shapes, they warp and twist, especially when Lucy is at the bottom of the garden worrying about what the wolves will do to her puppet pig. When she enters the house to save her pig, the wolf she sees in reality is white and hairy, a living, sleeping, solid animal instead of a twisted demon. Having faced the reality of her fear she feels braver and encourages her family to take back their house from the wolves. Something I think is really clever is that the wolves don’t lose all their character and become docile cute and fluffy, they are more realistically drawn/more grounded than before and white instead of black but still wacky and scratchy and cartoonish, just the nature of that abstraction has changed. Now having taken over the house, they’re more force of mad chaos instead of a dark ominous threat and feel more comical and cathartic than terrifying.
How did each artist produce their illustrations, what tools and materials did they use?
E. H. Shepard began his illustrations by making pencil studies from life in the countryside of Ashdown Forest, the basis for The Hundred Acre Wood. He’d then take these home, make thumbnail sketches to develop his ideas, then trace from his studies to compose his final images. He would “drop in” the characters on top of these scenes, drawn from imagination but originally based off the real life Christopher Robin and his toys, along with Shepard’s son’s bear Growler as the eponymous Winnie-the-Pooh. Then Shepard would ink over his pencil lines with a nib pen, later adding simple and bright watercolour washes when the books were later published with colour illustrations.
Images from The Art of Winnie the Pooh by James Campbell
In keeping with the technological advances of illustration since Shepard’s days, Dave McKean uses a more technologically based approach to create his illustrations, and uses a wide selection of media. On his website FAQ he writes “I use whatever is appropriate for the job. If the story needs close storytelling and a light, simple style of narrative, then probably pen and ink, or brushpen, or pencil would be best. If the story needs a more symbolic approach then maybe collage, or paint, or digital. It all comes down to the emotion and atmosphere you want to convey.” For The Wolves in the Walls he uses a mixture of traditional and digital painting for the humans, scratchy, powerful traditional ink lines for the feral wolves, and photography and found textures to construct objects such as the puppet pig, father’s tuba, mother’s jam and walls and fabrics of the house. Natural forms like plants and fire are totally digitally painted; little abstract elemental flourishes occasionally dotted in. All these parts are compiled and layered together digitally in Photoshop, reminiscent of Shepard’s method of compiling several sketches into one piece by tracing.