here for if the oc review thing is still up
im honestly not too sure if this is something this blog deals with since this oc's story takes place historically but I don't know of any other blog that can answer some of these questions 😅
cw for rape/forced pregnancy/racism/intersexism
(i don't have any good drawings of the oc at the moment, sadly, but I'll try my best with descriptions)
for a bit of context, she's an oc whose story i've decided to make take place in during the 18th century, under the colonial Spanish Empire. Her mother was a Quechua woman living in colonial Peru who was raped by a white Spaniard and ended up forcibly pregnant as a result. What happens next is something I have serious doubts about and would appreciate your input in. I plan on having the mother go to Spain somehow and give birth to the oc there. Originally, I was going to have her sneak onto the ship the Spaniard had gone onto to take him back to the peninsula and had her track him down because she had no means of providing for the child (result of colonization + she was shunned for having her "honor ruined" as they said historically to rape victims :/) and out of sheer desperation sought out the man who coerced and raped her. I don't know if this is a realistic thing for her to be able to do/even want to do in the first place though, and as an alternative, I'm thinking maybe the Spaniard forcibly took her with him. It'll change a lot of things about the oc's relationship with her father but if it's something far more plausible, I'd be willing to make the change.
For the questions I have dealing with the oc's appearance and story herself:
When I first designed her, i'd envisioned her with blond hair and amber eyes while being visibly not white passing in regard to her skin tone and facial features. Scientifically I'm pretty sure it's possible, just in the extremely rare case where she inherits all the recessive alleles necessary from both parents to have blond instead of dark brown/brown hair from her mother (the Spaniard has blond hair in this case) and amber eyes. My aim for giving her these features is to juxtapose her Quechua and white features in a really racist Spanish society and explore how that affects her life living in Spain during her early years (she eventually returns to Peru). My qualm is that I know in certain portrayals of people of color with these features, the "white" traits are exalted and uplifted as the only "good" part of that person of color's appearance, which is racist. Do you have any advice as to how to steer clear of falling into that kind of writing? And is there anything I might need to change about her design?
Additionally, I'm making her intersex, specifically having PCOS. BIPOC are already overly masculinized by racists, and i'm having the symptoms of PCOS intersect with that in her story. It'll garner remarks like "do all '''Indians''' look like that?" and "wow, they weren't lying when they said '''Indian''' women were filthy, even with Spanish blood too" and "is that really a girl? she kind of looks like a man" from her Spanish contemporaries. Do you think there are any problems with writing her story like this? The awful racism and intersexism is something I definitely want to portray but I don't want to step into bigoted territory myself as I write these issues.
Your advice is much appreciated!
OC review is up. You’re the first slot.
Next time please do this off anon, as the whole point of this was sharing who made it.
Content warning, rape, forced pregnancy, racism, Intersexism
I’ll start by saying you’re in the right place. Those who know my main blog know I’m a massive fan of Assassin’s Creed and fact check their games to hell.
Please do not make your OC go to Spain, straight up.
Reasons why:
Apellido: The Spanish practice of giving the father’s surname, which vaguely descends from the Roman custom of recognizing a child through the name of the father, is linguistically rooted in systems of power and racism. For this woman to find her rapist in Spain would basically be forcing the Spaniard to admit a “fetish” for indigenous people (essentially having sex with anyone who wasn’t a white Spaniard was seen as extremely kinky and niche and wrong. Many Spaniards kept the fathering of Indigenous or Black children as an open secret so they could have fun without the moral lashing they would get from admitting they “liked” non white women.
Article (IN SPANISH): a linguist explains why we here in Spain have two surnames
Spanish “politics” and how they viewed Indigenous people: the very first western indigenous civilization Spain came across were the Taíno of what is today the Bahamas. According to the compilation available at Wikipedia (and in many of Columbus’s biographies that are worth half a drop of brain juice), Colombus’s FRIST idea, ON October 12, was to take six indigenous people as curiosity presents to the Spanish crown. An indigenous person in Spain was, from day one, a cool new attraction at the court zoo.
Wikipedia Contents directory: Columbus’s first voyage
Due to the concept of meztizado (which literally means mixing), the child is still a second-class citizen. It is realistic that the woman would end up being taken to Spain, but I’m going to add the wikipedia pages to biracial (or, the case of Colón’s “adopted” indigenous son) children of first generation colonizers so you can see exactly how much the historical record cared that these men were Indigenous. And yes, I’m saying men, to prove a point: if the men can’t even get an upper hand after being recognized by their fathers, what else would happen to an unrecognized woman?
Martín Cortés the first
Thomas Rolfe
Jean-Baptiste Charbonneau
“Adoption” or “cultural exchange” cases:
Diego Colón the second
Pedro Moctezuma
José Gabriél Túpac Amaru
Étienne Brûlé
And these are just the wikipedia instances I could recall off the top of my head.
Let’s talk about the honor ruining thing for a moment. I’m a history buff, but I already said this on my main blog when it comes to disabilities. Why do so many people default to finding the most horrific existence for an OC just because life was worse in historical times?
The concept of rape being dishonor is very modern, and it directly ties back to what I said about white men trying to hide their dehumanizing attraction to non white women. If they have no incentive to come forward to their families, why would they?
Edit: thank you to @aztecspurthroatgrasshopper for clarifying that modern terminology means the former members of the Inca Empire prefer using Quechua for their ethnicity! I’ll keep that in mind in future posts, but due to the colonization discussion the original words stay here.
Anyways. For Inca women (Inca is the ethnicity, Quechua is the language), motherhood, sexuality, and the protection of these was extremely important. Here are just a few sources on why your OC’s mother would likely not be driven away for something that wasn’t a consensual decision:
Mama Killa and fertility
European Scientific Journal PDF: Maternity Practices in Native Cultures of the Chronicles of Peru
This is a tourist site, but sometimes you can only get the folklore of a place from
the people that live there. This one explicitly summarizes that rape wasn’t legal. Ticket Mcchu Picchu
So, no, there is no need to think that being raped by a spaniard, especially right after colonization in the 15 maybe even 1600s, would make others abandon your OC’s mother.
Alright, here’s where I get funny as well as facetious: you know most indigenous peoples thought blondness meant a person was really really sick, right? As much fun as I have with genetics, justifying a blond-haired, light-eyed, FIRST GENERATION Indigenous-Spaniard biracial character through Alleles ™ is taking me…not very nice places, mentally. You don’t need to juxtapose jack-shit. Just her having a slightly hooked nose, slightly darker skin, slightly narrower eyes—hell, you could even give her a narrow Spanish nose and dark eyes with curly brown hair—and the Spanish would still find a way to detect her biracialness FOR her.
Her circumstances would already make the Spanish question who this “disgustingly hot and mysterious little colony girl” is, because they did it with any spaniard who wasn’t bleach white within their own country. Using her racial appearance to tell that story is an extra layer of Super Uncomfortable.
Let’s get to the part about PCOS. Which I do have, diagnosed. However…
PCOS is not necessarily intersex. I have friends with intersex conditions that hav told me it’s ok for me to take the intersex label, but they still ask me to keep in mind that PCOS is, to many intersex people, an invitation to the intersex conversation, not a confirmation that a person is intersex.
“BIPOC are already overly masculinized by racists, and I’m having the symptoms of PCOS intersect with that in her story.” Again, I’m asking myself why people seem to research first how to make a character’s life to be as down in the dumps as possible and work up from there. If she’s already masculinized by racists, PCOS would be a way for her to try to feminize.
And wow…Super DUPER Uncomfortable unlocked with you casually dropping the old slur as a dialogue test. Do I and my indigenous friends sometimes write with that word? Yes. But we do it for a reason. Your reason is just to show off that you did some of the research, then stopped. I’m not going to add it, because I want you to work for it, but I want you to look into Indigenous beauty standards to realize that a lot of what are common traits of PCOS were accounted for in many societies and are things they thought made women hot. Therefore, her Inca blood and her PCOS wouldn’t be that much of a problem within her community…unless you really want to see your character getting slandered for being biracial?
Which brings me back to Assassin’s Creed, where my Black biracial pirate is allowed by the plot to stab his absent Spanish father. Basically, everyone learn to give your biracial colonized characters a support group or a blender to put their parents in, asap.
In summary: Ask yourself if you want to portray this stuff or if you just want to revel in the real problems of a race or ethnicity not your own.
OF COURSE, if you are Inca or live in any of the former Inca empire countries PLEASE chime in















