choose violence ask game! 1 for pirates smp? (yes this is an invitation to yap abt pirates characters i miss them too)
1. the character everyone gets wrong [ask game]
This one's actually kind of tough for me to answer because I'm the one who practically wrote the fans' manual for Pirates that many others follow and the fandom is small enough for me to not see that many bad takes or mischaracterization as a major issue.
That said, if I had to pick a character, I might just say p!Kyle. He's supremely underrated. I know he's a bit of a meme because of the whole "straight man" flirting/shipping debacle, but that shouldn't be what defines him in this fandom, and his lore, albeit sparse, shouldn't be overlooked IMO.
Because he's a whole lot of things! There's so much trauma you can fit into one man: wanting to live up to a legacy apart distinct from your dead father (and going against your mother(?)'s wishes to live a risky life on the Faction Isles), the implications of possibly watching your workaholic/neglectful father die (re: cursed gold), the whole dropped "do you hear the music?" hallucination arc… And he's bitter about being overtaken by p!Acho in riches! But he's also a bit silly; most of his streams are titled something relating to "tomfoolery" and the like! He's learning to cook and he's a musician who's skirting the faction lines to make friends with Herons! He's considering opening a museum out of Iris' temple in the north!
It's less everyone gets him as a character wrong but more he's overlooked as a character because him as a creator got overshadowed by this one social media incident at the start of the SMP. Or maybe it's just that he streams at a later time than most of the creators and went a bit dormant towards the second half of the SMP, so most people don't know him as well.