Above: the front page of the Daily News on July 8, 1931. Photo: Barnes & Noble.
The murder of Vivian Gordon on February 25, 1931, set off a chain of events that ended in the resignation of Mayor Jimmy Walker and the disintegration of the Tammany Hall machine.
Gordon had been convicted of prostitution in 1923 on shaky grounds. She was certainly no saint: the diaries mentioned in the headline above contained the names of over 300 men, including nearly every major gangland figure and many prominent businessmen and politicians, whom she either bankrolled or blackmailed. But the endemic corruption in city politics and the police force was responsible for her arrest and conviction. Not only did she fail to pay the accustomed bribe to get off, but when she was sentenced to a reformatory, her ex-husband was granted custody of their daughter. Gordon always maintained that that was the real reason behind the alleged set-up.
Above: Vivian Gordon. Photo: Bettmann Archive/Getty Images/NY Post
Before her death, Gordon had been in touch with Samuel Seabury, a former judge so unimpeachably honest he was dubbed "the bishop" by the tabloids. Seabury was investigating corruption in the judiciary, including the conspiracy among cops, prosecutors, defense attorneys, and judges to frame innocent women for prostitution. The possibility that Gordon had been murdered to keep her from further contact with Seabury led Governor Franklin D. Roosevelt to tell "the bishop" to expand his investigation to include the Manhattan D.A., the entire police force, and the upper echelon of Tammany Hall—including Mayor Walker.
After Walker resigned, evidence of Tammany's corruption came to light: they had put a price on every city service, from permits to political patronage. After a couple of interim mayors, the reformer and Tammany foe Fiorello LaGuardia became mayor on January 1, 1934. During his first term, Tammany membership dropped by 70%.
Vivian Gordon's alleged killers were acquitted due to the timely appearance of witnesses who provided them with alibis. But the identity of the true killers, and the mysteries surrounding the killing, still linger. “There are still more frames than there are pictures,” Walker once quipped.
"Gentleman Jimmy" Walker, the 97th mayor of New York, entering the courthouse to be examined on corruption charges in 1932. Photo: Associated Press via NY Magazine















