I was kneeling in the dirt, my hands clasped together with my cross pressed between my palms, when Private Weber came stumbling out of the trees. I spun around, rifle aimed, thinking he was an enemy soldier, nearly getting one of our heads blown off.
“Flash,” I said in a sharp whisper, my eye against my rifle and aimed at his chest.
“Jesus Christ, O’Connell. Thunder. Thunder!” he said and removed his hand from his holstered pistol. “It’s just me, ya jumpy bastard.”
“Sorry,” I replied, and lowered my rifle. My cross dangled at my shirt, caught behind a button like a child hiding behind a parent’s leg.
“Any sign of Bravo?” he asked, looking around in the dark.
I shook my head, tucked my cross back into my shirt.
“You don’t happen to have any goddamn idea where we are, do ya?” he said, kneeling down next to me—I was just about to stand.
He looked off, muttered “Fuck,” and spit.
“Well, hell,” he said. “At least we got each other. Two targets will give them pause to decide which one to shoot first, yeah?”
He smacked my arm with the back of his hand, winked at me, and stood. I took a moment to roll my eyes without rolling my eyes and got up as well. Guy was a bit of a nut.
We needed to meet up with our company so we headed in the direction we both did our best to figure was east. Thought the company might be east of our position, but I was so catawampus from the jump I don’t think I’d’ve found my way around my childhood home. It certainly didn’t help that it was so dark out, but moving in any direction was better than just sitting there waiting for Germans to stumble upon us.
“I thought there was supposed to be a creek around here,” Weber said. I didn’t respond, though I was thinking the same thing.
It was cool out, and the smell of gun powder was a stench as prevalent as air. Gun shots and the occasional blast were sounding off in the distance. It reminded me of something my father once told me. Said that when war wasn’t war, it was music. I had never really known what to make of that, but I think I was beginning to get an inkling.
“It’s almost like ‘em bugs in the south,” I said, stepping through twigs and leaves.
“What’s that now?” Weber replied.
I looked around the trees ahead of us. Didn’t see much but trees, rocks and the like, so I elaborated.
“Y’ever been to the south, Weber?”
“Can’t say I have, Patrick. Can’t say that I have.”
“Well, at night,” I continued, “There’re these bugs, right? Just chirping away like they’re an orchestra or something. ‘ery night. You can just take a step outside and listen to the music they make. It’s kinda like that here, but instead of ‘em grasshoppers chirping, it’s machine guns and rifles and mortars what make the music.” I chuckled to myself for an unannounced moment of strange humor. “I almost feel like if there wasn’t gun fire in the background, I wouldn’t even feel like we was in France.”
Weber laughed. It was a kind of consolation laugh, like he wasn’t exactly paying attention but knew by the intonation of my voice, that I had said something humorous.
“What happened to your rifle?” I asked—I don’t know why I was being so talkative.
Weber suddenly stopped, and his immediacy made me think we was about to get ambushed. I gripped my rifle tighter, crouched and quickly looked around. The look on his face, however—placid and a little ashamed—calmed me back down. He opened his mouth to explain, but then just shook his head, shrugged and said he was goddamn thankful that he had swiped the pistol from a German officer.
“Captain Dieter von Schulmacher,” he said, holding the Luger up.
“That was his name?” I asked as we continued on our haphazard path.
“Fuck if I know,” he replied, and holstered the pistol. “No, that wasn’t his name, but it sure sounds like it could be. Am I right? Hell, Dieter’s probably to Germans what Patrick is to the Irish.”
He chuckled and I could feel him grinning at me with that stupid grin of his. I smiled, though I didn’t exactly find it humorous enough to make any audible affirmation.
“Let me ask you something, Patrick.”
He paused and, as the sound of our feet on crunchy twigs and leaves became the prevalent, proximal sound, I began to wonder if he was waiting for me to give him permission or something.
“Who were you praying to?” he finally asked.
“Yeah, when I came upon ya, just now. You were all prostrate and had your cross there in your hands.”
“Weber, I’m Irish with a cross around my neck. Who the hell you think I was praying to?”
Weber laughed, of his own volition and wholeheartedly.
“Okay, okay. So that was a doughy question. Let me have another go at it.” He had another invocative pause that I didn’t take him up on, and said, “What were you praying for?”
I stopped to look back at him, expecting to see a dumb looks on his face, and he used the opportunity to step past me and take the lead.
“What was I praying for?”
“Yeah,” he said, surveying the path in front of us.
“I was praying for the Sox to win the World Series, the hell do you think I was praying for?”
“What, for us? For the war, for America and England and all us bastards?”
I stared at the back of his head for a long while.
“Yeah, I was praying for us, you moron. What’re you thick?”
“Hey, easy now, Patrick, I’m just trying to have a conversation here.” He turned to me. “It’s enough we gotta be out here in this fucking mess. What’s so bad about having a goddamn civilized conversation every once and a while?”
I looked at him, trying to figure out if he was, in fact, a moron; if he thought that we were having a conversation.
“You asked me a question and I gave you its obvious answer. That ain’t a conversation, Weber.”
“No, it ain’t a fucking conversation, O’Connell.” He said my name with this warbled affectation that made me think—along with his persistence of calling everyone by their first name—that he had a strong, fundamental aversion to any sort of nicknamery. “But I’m trying to get one going.”
I decided—not because I was angry or against the idea of a conversation or anything, but just because—to take the lead, and I continued us on our way.
“So, you were praying to God for us?”
“For our side? For our side to win against the Germans?”
“Yes, Weber. What do you pray for when you pray?”
“I don’t know that I ever have prayed.”
Never had I been so surprised that I was surprised.
“Alright, then. I guess maybe that begins to explain your curiosity.”
“No, no, no, no, Patrick. No, you got me all wrong. I know all about praying. I was just curious about whether or not you prayed to God for our safety, for us to win against the Germans, all that bullshit.”
I stopped, turned, and took a step toward him.
“Pardon me,” he said, holding up a hand. “I don’t mean to call your beliefs bullshit. We’re having a conversation here. A discourse, or the like.”
I scoffed, but it came out less humorously that I meant it. I looked around at the trees. Just trees everywhere. Trees and darkness. I really had no idea where we were.
“Yeah. Right,” I said and continued walking. I was beginning to grow tired of all of this talk of having a conversation without actually having one.
“Do you think praying to God is going to help us win the war?”
I planted my feet again, said, “What are you on about, Weber?”
He took a few steps toward me.
“I’m asking you if you believe praying to God, to your Catholic Jesus Christ, will help us win the war.”
“Yeah, Weber. That’s why I’m doing it. The hell else would I be doing it for? It’s not as if praying is like whistling a song from the radio to pass the time.”
“Jesus, Patrick, I understand what praying is for. I’m just asking you if you believe it.”
“I just said I did, didn’t I?”
I was beginning to hope even for a troop of German soldiers to come upon us. The immediate threat of death would at least shut Weber up.
“No you didn’t, you just explained to me what praying was.”
I shook my head and turned back toward our assumed path. There was silence for a moment, silence apart from the noises of our footsteps and the background orchestra of war, but it was silence by default. Then, Weber continued.
“Did you know that in Greek mythology people would pray to certain gods during wars and certain gods with take sides?”
“Yeah, I think I remember something like that,” I replied, surprised in myself that I was continuing to humor him and not tell him to shut the hell up.
“I mean, for instance, the Greeks had Athena on their side, in the Trojan War. And Athena, shit, she was the goddess of war. And she was siding with the Greeks.”
“Here I thought Athena was the goddess of wisdom.”
“Yeah, she was that too. But then, the Trojans had Ares, the goddamn godof war, on their side. And, shit, they lost.”
A blast shook the forest around us, lighting it up like a flash of daylight. Webber and I dove to the ground as a tree exploded off to our left, a good twenty-five, thirty feet away. I landed on my stomach knocking a little of the wind out from my lungs, but I managed to maintain my composure. There was another explosion and another flash of light and for a split second I thought I could see the way. The smoke cleared and we looked at each other, Weber grinning like an idiot.
“I guess your guardian angel was looking out for us on that one,” he said.
We got up and continued on. There was an increase in nearby gunfire and I held my rifle up, aimed in front of me. Nothing but unarmed trees.
“So the Trojans had Ares and the Greeks had Athena and the Greeks won. Where is this conversation taking us, Weber?”
“Where it’s taking us is the Greeks and the Trojans had gods to pray to and those gods heard those prayers and either acted on them or didn’t. They chose sides with the ones they felt the most appeased by or just the ones they rooted for. So what I’m asking you is do you think that God will answer your prayers to help us defeat the Germans?”
I stopped and crouched—we had come to the top of a hill—aiming my gun around the surrounding area, just to be certain there weren’t any enemy soldiers in our immediate proximity. Once I was sure of this, I had the opportunity to shift and turn around and look Weber in the eye.
“Look, Weber,” I said. “The Iliad is a fucking story, alright? You think that Zeus and Athena and Ares and all those incestuous morons were real? Were real gods?”
“Look, man. I’m not trying to say Zeus is real, or the Bible is bullshit or anything like that.”
“Watch it,” I said, giving him a hard look.
“I said I was saying it wasn’t bullshit,” he said holding his palms up in defense. “I’m not trying to make an argument for or against the existence of God or Buddha or Ra or any goddamn deity. I’m just curious what you, Patrick O’Connell, believe. That interests me.”
The guy might not have been a skilled conversationalist, fine, but he sure as shit was trying. I had to give him that.
“Yes. Alright? I’m praying because we have God on our side, and I believe that with his help we will defeat the Germans. Ya happy, Weber?”
I looked around the area again.
“Well, don’t you think some of the Germans might be praying to God too? I mean, they’re a fairly Christian nation.”
“The fuck do I care what the Germans do when they put their hands together? And what the hell are you on about?”
“I mean, if you’re praying to God, and Captain Dieter von Whateverhausen is praying to God, who’s He going to answer? You’re both His children, ‘m I right?”
I studied him for a long moment, kind of hoping to make him uncomfortable and trying to be certain if I could determine whether he was, in fact, an imbecile.
“Don’t the fact that you have the German’s Luger at your side tell you who God sided with? Or maybe it has something to do with the fact that we haven’t taken it upon ourselves to eradicate the Jews.”
He sighed and furrowed his brow. He seemed almost disappointed by this actualization. The hell did I care though? Frankly, I felt like slapping the shit out of him.
“Okay, so let’s say, for the sake of conversation, that…”
“For the sake of conversation,” I said, somewhat sarcastically at this point.
“Yeah, for the sake of fucking conversation, that you and all the other believers in the whole U.S. of fucking A. prayed to God for the protection of our soldiers and the guidance of our military in this war, and for us to defeat the no good fucking Germans, and…” he paused and held up a finger. “And God answered our prayers. That would mean God is on our side, yeah?”
I stood and started walking again. Weber followed me.
“Okay,” he said. “Okay, okay. But here’s a little glitch in the argument.”
“I can’t wait for this,” I said with an involuntary roll of the eyes.
I looked back at Weber and he nodded with high-risen eyebrows.
“What, Jack Stevens? In first platoon?”
“Yeah, fucking Jack Stevens in first platoon.”
I stopped and turned to him. Oddly enough, he had piqued my curiosity with this left-turn exhibit.
“What does Stevens have to do with any of this…conversation?”
“Tell me, Patrick. What do you think of Sergeant Jack Stevens in first platoon? I mean, really. What do you think of the guy?”
I stared at Weber for a long while, contemplating my answer. I didn’t particularly like telling anyone in the company how I felt about anyone else in the company unless I thought they were the most upstanding person I had ever met, or at least the next couple in line. Any such otherwise honesty wouldn’t do anybody no good. But just me and Weber—the lunatic he is—lost in the middle of Nowhere, France:
“I hate the fucking son of a bitch,” I said. “Regardless of what I think about him. So. What.”
“So that’s my point,” he shrugged. “Well, that’s the iceberg tip of my point.” He cleared his throat like someone stepping up to a podium to give a speech. “My point is there are people in our army, in our company, maybe sitting in the foxhole next to ya, that are lousy people. People I hate. That other people hate. Just lousy goddamn people. Shit, I’m sure some folks hate me. Fine. So what? Let them. And I’m sure, there are people that, if He ever exercises such a feeling, there are people in our army, or at least in our country, that God hates.”
He looked into my eyes and I could see a strong-fisted intensity in his.
“And if there are people in America who are lowlife pieces of shit, hell-bent, sick sons of bitches that should rot in fiery hell, then, by that standard, there are some Germans that aren’t half bad.”
“Are you fucking nuts?” I said. “I mean, are ya?”
This seemed to anger Weber and he took a few wayward steps in the opposite direction we’d been heading. It was like he was pacing in a study or something.
“Look, you think there aren’t a couple of German soldiers out there that aren’t half bad guys? I’m sure there’s a few Svens and Bjorns and whatever the fuck their names are, that I wouldn’t mind having a beer with.”
“You’ve lost your damn mind. Why are you following me? Why don’t you head on over to Berlin and buy a round for the boys?”
“Jesus, Patrick. Listen to me, will ya? Okay, fine, so I ain’t too straight-lined at getting right to the point, but part of the fun is in the undressing, isn’t it? You don’t want to just jump right to getting sexy.”
I shook my head at him. He was beginning to sound crazy, even for his standards.
“Okay, I’m getting my metaphors all mixed up and sounding like a goddam nut. Humblest of apologies.” He slapped the side of his head and snapped in his ear. I wasn’t feeling too comfortable being his sole babysitter.
“But for saying you want to hang out with the fucking Nazis and play drinking games with ‘em…?”
“Don’t get me wrong, Patrick. I hate the fucking Nazis. I do. I hope they all burn like unoccupied casseroles in hell. I’m talking about the Germans.” He pointed off in the direction we had come from. “You think all of them hate Jews? Hell, I bet Stevens hates the goddamn Jews. The Germans don’t all hate Jews. Okay, take it easy, Patrick. Sure, most of them do, yeah, but some of them are just following orders, right? Haven’t you ever had some back-asswards order you didn’t want to carry out? Hell, some of them probably just got drafted like you and I, only they were ordered to kill Jews while we were ordered to kill Germans.”
“Weber, if you’re trying to get me to sympathize with the goddamn Germans, exercise your lungs somewhere else.” I shook my head and nearly took the Lord’s name. Weber didn’t take my suggestion, just stood there. I was suddenly thirsty, so I took out my canteen and unscrewed the cap.
“And what does your love for all things Deustch have to do with me praying to God?” Boy, was he a nut.
I took a refreshing swig of water and offered some to Weber. He shook his head, remaining silent—maybe he was trying to figure out how his mess of yarn could be made into a ball.
“Sorry, I lost my train of thought,” he said. “It’s difficult, trying to grasp God and all of that shit.”
I sighed. I could see the guy was earnestly trying to have a conversation, to unravel a knot in his mind, and, in that peculiar moment, I felt something like empathy for the crazy son of a bitch.
I sighed and said, “Where is it you’re from, Weber?”
“Colorado Springs. You grew up in, what, Texas, right?”
“I figured you’d be a Baptist boy, being from Texas and all.”
“We ain’t all Baptists in Texas, Weber.”
A light seemed to go on in his eyes, but I jumped in before he could do anything about it.
“So, Weber. Where’s all this religious curiosity and ying-yang, this ‘there’s got to be a little good in every German’ bullshit coming from? Didn’t your parents ever make you go to Sunday school? Or are you just one of ‘em bona fide atheists?”
“No, no. I’m not an atheist. Why would I want to be a lonely goddamned atheist?” He looked off. “I’m just curious, is all. What different people believe in, or how different people believe in the same thing, I find that all sorts of interesting.”
We started walking again, and I felt comfortable having the reigns of the conversation. I was also beginning to wonder about the stability of Weber’s mind, if maybe being out here was making him all jittery and the like. I mean, the guy had a propensity for just going off the rails with his mouth and then never knowing where he was coming from. Edwards told me he once blathered about the damn newspaper industry for an entire breathless hour. Hell, we could be laying down fire, German artillery blasting the shit out of us, and he’d probably be telling some poor sap in his foxhole about how twisted them ad fatsos in New York were.
“What’d your parents raise you?” I asked.
“Didn’t raise me anything, really. Went to church on Christmas with my grandma a few times.”
“That might explain why you ain’t really got a handle on God and all.”
He was silent for a while and the background music’s prevalence was again comforting.
“And let me guess,” Weber said, interrupting the symphony, “You grew up in a Catholic house, went to church, Sunday school, confessed to your priest ‘bout all the times you masturbated. All that shit.”
“Yeah, sure. I was an altar boy.”
I looked back at Weber and was surprised to see this kind of childlike look on his face. I stopped and turned to him. He sighed.
“I can see what you’re thinking of me, especially with all the questions and theories I’m putting forth, but I’m just a curious cat who ain’t afraid of death.” He looked off at the trees and smiled like they seemed surprisingly beautiful to him.
I couldn’t help but let out a little chuckle.
“A curious cat who ain’t afraid of death,” I said with a smirk, but he was still lost in the trees. I looked up there too, just in case there was something I was missing. I suppose there was; there were stars in the sky. I guess I was surprised by that. The idea of seeing something beautiful like stars in the night sky didn’t seem like something I’d see amid the carnage of Europe.
“Sometimes,” he said. “I like to think of God as a parent, but like a parent who’s sent you off to college, you got me? He still loves me, I can know that, but He’s sent me off to make a life of my own, and I don’t hear from Him. He hears about me, oh shit, does He hear about me.” We both kind of chuckled at that. “My professors send Him letters, whether I’m behaving or misbehaving, so He’s mad or He’s proud, whatever His reaction is. But, regardless of how He feels about me, I’ve really only got myself.”
I stared at him, taking this in, while he looked off into the treetops and the stars. I felt sorry for the poor bastard. He seemed so lonely but in a kind of unknowing way. Like he didn’t even know he was lonely, and for some reason, despite that it seemed he was blessed with ignorance, that seemed sadder. But there was also something about his curiosity that I could relate to. Could sympathize with. I could see a searching, a longing in his eyes. The nutcase was just misguided.
“I don’t think of Him like that at all,” I said, and Weber looked at me. “I think of Him as kind, and forgiving, loving. Stern and strict on an occasion or two, yeah, but by your side. On your side. See, Weber, here you make it out like God has abandoned you, but then I see you looking at these trees and…” A bomb went off nearby, tearing a tree into splinters but it only caused us to flinch and a pause in my sentence, a red light on our faces. “I see you looking at these trees and finding God in them. God in beauty. God in everything, if you will.”
“See, now we’re having a conversation.”
“Yeah, Weber, I guess we are.” I paused. “But God’s not in everything. Alright? There’s evil in this world. There are things what have left God’s light. That aim to destroy it. So, to take it back to your original question, to bring this conversation in full circle, I pray because there is evil all around, and I need God’s help, His guidance, to allow me to fight against it, and to win.”
He stood thinking about this and I turned and led us onward.
“So you’re saying that God is choosing sides? That he is picking us, or he’s picking you over the Germans. Over evil.”
“Yeah, Weber, I guess I am.”
“Well, I can’t believe in that. I can’t believe in that kind of blind faith.”
Again, for what I hoped was the last time before we found our company, I turned and faced Weber.
“That’s what believing in God is, Weber. Blind faith. You keep saying you understand but you don’t.”
“That idea doesn’t take into account the Germans that aren’t all bad. Lots of Germans are Christians, you know?”
“God knows what side to pick,” I said.
He suddenly took the lead and I, reluctantly at first, followed him.
“Well, then what do you believe, Weber? He just sits on the sidelines, reading the funnies? He just lets us fight it out until one is dead and the other is bruised and bloodied having fought? He just deserts us to kill each other?”
There was a strange break in the background gunfire. Like the end of a song before the next.
“The way I see it,” Weber said, stopping and turning toward me as the explosions picked back up. “God has three positions He could take on war. One, He picks a side, choosing the ones that are the most good and true and faithful, yeah? Two, He picks no sides, knowing that both sides harbor good and bad, sure? Cause both sides are man, whether they are Americans or Germans, made in his image and all. And then three. He picks both sides, for the same reasons that He picks no sides. Impartial, eh?
“But if God were to pick no sides or to pick both sides, one would be the same as the other, both sides having His support, leaving us, us humans, on our own with him or without him. Cause if God’s on our side and the enemy’s side, on account of the few good Christian Germans God ain’t gonna turn a blind eye to, we’ll say for the sake of argument, then we’d be fighting with God’s support against God’s supported.
“Now, just a minute Patrick, let me finish. If He were to pick one side, picking them based on merit, He’d have to ignore certain people, certain good people on the losing team, and He’d have to support certain evil people on the winning team. I mean, shit, I would hate to be God and have to make those kinds of decisions.”
For an instant, Weber seemed equally idiotic as I had recently—briefly—come to see him as intelligent. The paradox of his theological postulation seemed to mirror his own intellect.
“So if God is going to pull any favors for you,” he continued, “Then He just might be pulling favors for the God-fearing German that clasps his cross between his hands.”
I took in a deep breath; it felt somewhat toxic in my lungs.
“Are you trying to tell me, after the last twenty minutes or so we’ve been walking, that my prayers to God are pointless?”
Weber shifted a little as if he’d ingested a bite of undercooked meat.
“I guess so? Yeah. I mean you’re either praying to a generalizing god, or one that won’t answer your prayers.”
I felt like hitting him. I felt like planting a few of his fucking teeth in the dirt and seeing what sort of obnoxious, bent tree grew from the ground.
“Alright, Weber,” I said with finality and a nod. “Good conversation.”
I turned and stormed onward.
“Jesus, Patrick. I’m not trying to get you to apostatize your beliefs or nothing. I’m just trying to have a civilized conversation.”
“Well, go and have it with someone else. Go have it and a laugh with your kraut drinking buddies.”
“I don’t see anyone else around to have this conversation with, much less one who wears a cross around their neck.”
I decided then and there that I was just gonna ignore him. If I stopped responding to him, he’d eventually get the hint and stop talking. So I trudged on. It seemed to work. He followed in silence. Maybe he realized he’d upset me and felt bad enough for it to shut his mouth for a change.
We continued through the trees and yet, we didn’t come across our company, or anyone for that matter. The symphony of destruction actually got dimmer and I was beginning to wonder if we were even heading in the right direction.
“Alright, I’m sorry, O’Connell,” Weber said, using my last name as if it might be some kind of relatable peace-offering. “I just get a little curious and rambulatory occasionally. Is that even a word? Rambulatory? I feel like it could be. Jesus, my head is a goddamn lumpy stew in this place. Where’s my canteen?”
I stopped and looked around. Nothing but more goddamn trees like we’d been walking in circles for the last twenty, twenty-five minutes. I could hear Weber patting himself down, searching like a moron for his canteen—the damn thing could’ve been taped to his forehead and he’d still need help finding it.
“Look,” I said. “Don’t worry about it, alright?”
I turned to Weber. He had his canteen in one hand, his German pistol in the other—for God knows what reason—and looked up at me with his placid, curious eyes, right as a bullet went through his left eyebrow. It seemed to happen in an instant and an hour at once and it was sometime between the bullet striking him and his body hitting the ground was when my brain registered the sound of the shot.
I dove to the ground. More gun fire raked my ear drums. Bullets whizzed by. They tore limbs off of trees. One struck my pack. My heart pounded like its own warzone and I quickly scanned the dark for the gunman. Shot after shot after shot sounded around me. The horrid, dissonant music of war roaring over me like a lion. My mind raced in a panic and I suddenly saw the flash of a rifle firing and the starlit silhouette of a man wielding it. Then others too.
I took aim with my rifle, set it dead on the uniformed enemy and I fired.
As the butt of my gun heaved against my shoulder and the pulse of the blast concussed my ears, time turned to molasses and I felt, in that moment, what I was sure was the power of God. I was completely terrified and completely at peace as the blast from my rifle sang in my ears. I was full and I was empty, and I couldn’t exactly tell the difference.