Little Book Review: Child of Faerie, Child of Earth
Premise: Graciosa, the emotionally neglected daughter of a lord in twelfth-century France, finds a friend in Percinet, the half-human son of a Faerie queen. She needs a friend, too, because her cold father is under the thrall of the evil Duchess Eglatine, who is wildly jealous of Graciosa’s beauty and just might have to kill her about it.
Thoughts: “Graciosa and Percinet” was one of my favorite fairy tales in Andrew Lang’s The Red Fairy Book, which I devoured when I was eleven or so. Written by Madame d’Aulnoy in 1697, it’s not one of the better-known fairy tales, but it’ll probably feel familiar to anyone who’s read enough fairy tales or Greco-Roman myths. It’s essentially a mash-up of “Snow White” (a beautiful young girl is dispossessed/mistreated by a jealous stepmother) and “Cupid and Psyche” (a girl is separated from her true love and forced to perform a bunch of seemingly impossible tasks by a woman who hates her). What’s always charmed me about it, though, is the delicacy of the romance and the emotionally realistic obstacles that keep the protagonists from getting together until the end. Percinet loves Graciosa from the beginning, and is always trying to help her out; Graciosa loves Percinet back, but she’s afraid of acting on it because she’s afraid he’ll tired of her eventually, plus she’s reluctant to leave her father despite his lack of affection for her. Those are some real problems!
Josepha Sherman unfortunately doesn’t add much in her retelling. It only differs from the original in a handful of details, which creates a kind of literary uncanny valley effect (like when I had a dream about Glee back in 2011, and it was the same as normal Glee except they tried to introduce a new character who liked science, didn’t believe in God, and was boring). Worse, few of the details add much. To wit:
Graciosa has a pretty bad home life even before her father remarries, as she’s expected to run his estate with little help but constantly gets criticized for being incompetent. This is one of the few interesting changes; it made me sympathize with her immediately, and it ties in well with her reluctance to let go of an always-distant father.
Duchess Eglantine has captured a Faerie and uses them to do evil magic. This was enjoyably creepy, but underutilized.
Graciosa is wary of Percinet primarily because she’s afraid she’ll go to hell or get executed for heresy if she gets involved with Faeries or magic. Given that the historical setting is never strongly developed and nothing comes of Graciosa’s fears, this element felt half-baked. I’m not sure whether it checks out historically, either.
Graciosa and Percinet split up mid-story not just because she has trust issues and wants to be there for her father, but because she catches Percinet kissing a Faerie girl. He doesn’t really get it because Faerie mores are different, plus he and Graciosa aren’t together-together. Unlike some readers, I don’t think this ruins Percinet’s character, but it does turn their nuanced separation into something a lot more crude and petty.
Overall, I’d just suggest reading the original. Almost everything good in this novel is in the original, too.
Hot Goodreads Take: The language is foul (the characters sometimes say “damn”) and Percinet’s mom isn’t enough of a MILF in the illustrations.