Having spent enough time talking with my dear girlfriend about HDG; I now know the story that could work as a good criticism of the setting. Unfortunately I don't have the Whatever to write it. It is especially frustrating because if I ever need to look something up about the setting I get upset so so fast.
Heres the deal: during the colonization of humanity/human space, some humans got on ships and ran as far and as fast as possible, avoiding domestication. They settled on a new planet and grew from there. They remember those who conquered their kin, and know to watch for and fear them. So when some humans manage to catch an affini and bring it back to Second Homeworld, they have to domesticated it for living among humans.
It is the perfect way to turn the setting on it's head without utterly disrespecting the source materials and setting. I just can't quite bring it home.









