timetravelbypen replied to your post “Having watched, in part, both The Fellowship of the Rings and Parks...”
I have heard from some SUPER hardcore Tolkien nerds that the movies lose a lot from the books/the changes don't make sense? Personally LotR is that rarest of movies where I think it improves on the books, but that's just me...
It makes sense to me that gargantuan tomes would lose something in translation, and I literally remember neither what I read when I read them nor what I thought about the movies having read the books first.
kyrieanne replied to your post
My head canon is that Ben didn't agree for the nuances lost in the Jackson version that Tolkien did through world building through the less glamorous characters in the LOTR characters - the bits gained in the songs sung in pubs and poetry he wrote in the text and characters more in the vein of Gollum than the elves. I'm just making that up - not canon evidence to support my theory. I just think Ben is enough of a nerd to resent the gloss of the Jackson production.
This is a good theory, especially for a person who has a LotR pen pal persona. Ben is probably someone who loooooooooves all the little tiny detail that wouldn’t make it into a film, and has probably read all the ancillary/auxiliary material he can get his hands on. I wonder what he’ll think of the Amazon series.
camillavirgil replied to your post
Probably Faramir lol. While a lot of changes were made from the books, the Faramir storyline is the most obvious and (probably the most) egregious departure. Jackson essentially gives Faramir’s rejection of the ring to Aragorn and then makes Faramir a much more passive/easily swayed character. Jackson and all had their reasons for this - increasing dramatic tension, emphasizing the ring’s power, etc.. But film!Faramir is nowhere close to book!Faramir in terms of characterization/personality.
See, I don’t remember this! But I love this answer! After I posted this last night I was poking around the internet and learned the line from Ben was an ad-lib, but IT STILL WORKS BASED IN ACTUAL FAN REACTIONS. If I ever make it through my tbr list of books I’ve bought and then not started, I’m going back and rereading these books for stuff like this. Thank you! ALL OF YOU.