when kaeya said the "god of fate", the cryo and anemo symbols were facing the camera. this might mean nothing on its own until you remember what nicole said in the same patch:
additionally, icy winds (寒风) is the same power that boreas got from a god, who was probably the first angel, aka the dawn star. (unrelated but kaeya's title is frostwind (寒风) swordsman). I HATE THESE TWO SO MUCH!!
or, every connection between Nicole and Kaeya that I collected over the years before HYV inevitably crushes our hopes and dreams.
As all things do, it started with Kaeya.
Veluriyam Mirage
Kaeya stars as his grandfather in a play written by Zosimos. Idyia remarks Zosimos always wanted to write a story based on rumors he heard about a thief and a mage, suggesting there is some truth to it.
Idyia: *sigh* Zosimos has always wanted to write an epic story about a thief and a mage. Apparently, he got the idea from some rumors that were swirling around.
There are much deeper layers to this story, though. Kaeya's grandpa seems to be from Khaenri'ah, judging by the soundtrack title that accompanied the play: Towers of Afrasiab. The name of the cave where the door of Khaenri'ah is situated is "Hangeh Afrasiyab". The thief lived in a dark realm which matches Khaenri'ah's subterranean environment.
Furthermore, in CN, Kaeya's grandfather is called his 'paternal grandfather' (爷爷), which increases the likelihood that he's an Alberich.
Then who is the mage supposed to be? Alice? Could be, but it's not that simple. The play combines TWO stories; that of Idyia/Alice and the thief/mage. So we have to remove the excess backstory and dig a little deeper.
How was the mage portrayed? As a star zipping through the sky. In the book The Tale of Qoyllor and Ukuku, it's implied the titular character Qoyllor is a fallen angel. She is the daughter of the sun (the Heavenly Principles?), gets compared to a fallen star and has starry eyes. Nicole Reeyn also has star shaped pupils (even though Zibai, another angel, does not) and manifests as a star when she can't physically be there.
(Another hint is the real Princess Fischl; she is compared to a star and is most likely an angel as well, (corroborated by the fact that Nicole and a Seelie wrote the books together)).
Who played the starmage? Idyia, who is an oceanid, often equated to fairies or the descendants of angels. Who wrote the play? Zosimos, named after the alchemist who said fallen angels taught humans the art of metallurgy/forbidden knowledge...
The story is a mixture of The Fisherman and the Jinni and Aladdin and the Wonderful Lamp from One Thousand and One Nights. This is evident by the fact that Kaeya references the in-game book The Shepherd and the Magic Bottle. The Jinn are descendants of Nabu Malikata, who was another angel survivor.
All this points to one simple conclusion: the mage was an angel. Currently, we can count on one hand the amount of angelmages in this game.
The most important takeaways from this play are:
Kaeya's pirate grandfather was from Khaenri'ah
The mage who met the thief was an angel (or perhaps an angel descendant like a Jinni)
The next logical step is to look for an angel who was in Khaenri'ah.
The omniscient sage
Yeah listen, I'm not going to drag this out, it's Nicole. It's literally just Nicole.
Direidyth: There was once a sage who passed through my village. People got the sense that she was truly omniscient. The sage said that... doomsday was coming, but as that day approached, a Savior would reveal themselves to us.
In the quest A Space and Time for You, we learn there was a female "sage" who passed through Direidyth's village in Khaenri'ah, spreading word of Khaenri'ah's destruction. We later hear this same sage speak the prophecy in a shared flashback/dream with Direidyth. While the speaker isn't named, the voice belongs to NICOLE.
In Durin's SQ, there's a flashback in which the Hexenzirkel discuss the witches who are absent. This conversation took place shortly after the cataclysm.
Seer-Witch: Then how about [Nicole]? Does she still walk the mortal realm?
Merry-Witch: Yes... She has that secret mission of hers to accomplish, so she couldn't make it to our gathering. But, she doesn't seem to regret her choice, so naturally, it's not my place to pry.
Awfully suspicious if you ask me! Perhaps this concerns the travelers whose fate she inadvertently meddled in, or maybe, just maybe, a certain Knight Marshal who was desperately searching for a way to save Khaenri'ah.
Look at it this way: what does a pirate want? Treasure. What does an angel do? Guide people to treasure. I've cracked the code!
Ever since it was revealed Zibai led the survivors of Lang-Gan east, I have been wondering whether Nicole did the same for Khaenri'ahn survivors. Perhaps this was even the secret mission Alice spoke of. It would line up with the assumption from Paimon that Kaeya grew up in place cut off from the world (i.e. hidden from the gods' gaze):
Dainsleif: I suspect she is descended from pure-blood Khaenri'ahns afflicted with the curse of immortality. They must have re-settled somewhere remote, cut off from the rest of the world. That would explain how her people retained their ancient beliefs, including the myth of the golden-haired Savior
Paimon: Ah! Paimon gets it now! So, a bit like Kaeya? Except she grew up somewhere more isolated?
I don't think this would've been possible without a little divine intervention.
Since Nicole is the mastermind behind princess Fischl, it's worth noting she namedrops king "Irmin" in Legend of the Shattered Halberd, and references "(Mi)Mir", another important figure from norse mythology. Fischl's soundtrack album also contains a reference to the Norse goddess Freyja (Das Folkwanglied), suggesting she's her equivalent. As we all know, Norse mythology is most prominently incorporated in Khaenri'ah. Perhaps she was inspired by her visit there.
Another option is the woman named Angelica from the book Perinheri, using the most inconspicuous alias since Nicola Coco. The authors claim this book is based on a story that was "famous" throughout Khaenri'ah, suggesting there might be some truth to this one as well. Angelica arrived in Khaenri'ah under false pretences using a fake backstory, so it's possible she was actually a poorly disguised Nicole all along. Nicole is an imaginative writer who likes to improvise stories so it wouldn't be too out of character for her to lie.
Perinheri
"Njord, who walks with the Darksprites, Alf, the greatest warrior in the Universitas Magistrorum, Alberich, commander of half the knights, and Perinheri the undefeated." Angelica spoke thus of the mightiest figures in the Kingdom as she saw them.
Angelica also conveniently namedrops a commander named Alberich as one of the four strongest individuals in Khaenri'ah, likely referencing the Four Pillars.
Perinheri
And when he glanced back at Angelica, he saw that she was neither a beautiful woman from Liyue nor a wicked witch.
"I am freedom, that which has broken free of fate. This is what Hleobrant sought in agony, but that which is now yours for the taking."
Nicole: Fate is always ineffable, and yet... I still hope I can guide those I meet towards a happy ending to their tale. That applies to characters in my stories as well.
Nicole says she wants to help people overcome their fate and give them a happier ending, which is exactly what Angelica did for Perinheri (if you ignore his best friend turning into a Hilichurl).
That being said, the name Angelica literally translates to "angel like" so perhaps she wasn't an angel but rather someone like an angel, like a Jinni perhaps.
Princess Fischl
It's genuinely unreal how important princess Fischl is to the overarching story. Even more ridiculous how she always seemed to be connected to Kaeya long before we knew Nicole authored her. She might be an allegory for the first angel, she might be Nicole, or a mixture of both. truth is, we don't know.
What I do know is that Fischl has several references to Midsummer Night's Dream, the play that famously stars Oberon and Titania, the king and queen of the fairies.
Hmmm. In DnD they are even king and queen of the Seelie. Fun fact: Oberon is actually derived from Alberich, which aptly means "elf king". Funfun fact: Oberon and Titania adopted an Indian prince who they constantly fought over. As of now, we can count on one hand the amount of brown princes in this game.
Midsummer Courtyard
With the fall of the ancient lost civilization, the once prosperous and magnificent Sommernachtgarten was also buried underground, leaving only its ancient trees and stones to remember its past glory.
Fischl's Sommernachtgarten (Summer Night Garden) is referenced in Mond's artifact domain, Midsummer Courtyard. The garden was part of Mondstadt's ancient civilization, which we now know is likely to be ARCADIA, the place where Kaeya's grandpa allegedly hid his sword. Because Nicole came up with these books, the garden could have belonged to Nicole/the real Fischl or another angel. Interestingly enough, Nicole's meeting point is the "Witch's Garden" and she even says she has made several gardens/homes to increase the chances of people stumbling in.
Lucky Coin
When Nicole buffs the other characters, her skill shows a double triquetra that's similar to the shape on the Mora coin. As you might already have guessed, Kaeya's passive talent "Glacial Heart" also shows a double triquetra...
But what really grinds my gears is that for some reason, Kaeya owns a "lucky" coin that does whatever he tells it to do. Because coincidentally, the word Seelie actually means "lucky/fortunate"!
Traveler: How do you control it, anyway?
Kaeya: Mm, a better question to ask might be, what do I do to make this coin happy to work with me, and show me whichever side I wish? My answer would be that I tell the coin a joke every time I toss it into the air. If it finds my joke funny, then it cooperates with me. Of course, this whole arrangement hinges on a preexisting amount of trust between the two of us. I can't just get any strange coins to listen to me.
You might think he was joking, but usually when Kaeya jokes, the traveler will express skepticism; this time however, it's played completely straight. If the coin is truly "lucky", maybe it was blessed by some kind of deity. For example, in Norse mythology, there are guardian spirits called hamingja who help their chosen person with matters regarding fate and happiness.
This symbol is also the shape of the Cecilia flower which was once cultivated in Mond's ancient civilization.
Kaeya: Some say, the god of fate calls the outcome of every dice roll before it's even made. And that's why, the secret to winning a lot of games is having that god on your side.
Klee: Hehe, your luck is amazing, Kaeya!
In Durin's SQ, Kaeya ominously says the god of fate decides every outcome before it's made. Kaeya then procedes to win the match after which Klee remarks his luck is "amazing".
If you pay close attention to everything Kaeya says, you'll notice he will OFTEN say something is "fortunate", "lucky" or the will of "fate" etc.
Other connections/similarities
Nicole's star-shaped pupils might be a hint towards the ancestry of Khaenri'ahns. It's long suspected Khaenri'ahns might be nephilim, the descendants of angels and humans, hence why their pupils are also stars, albeit bigger and more diamond shaped. It should be noted Kaeya's pupil in-game is extremely bizarre. If you zoom in on his model, there's actually a tinier star inside his pupil.
(There is of course another possibility regarding Khaenri'ah's origins: the Voyager with star-like pupils who married the first angel. However, it's unclear if the pupils belong to the original Voyager or the body of the boy they possessed. Surtalogi seems to know about them since he told Skirk to look for traces of the Voyager.)
After it was revealed Nicole and Mr. Nine wrote the Fischl saga I've been thinking about what other novels they might have written together. Kaeya's Adventures of ANGELos book immediately came to mind. Based on its CN title, this book is likely a reference to The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes, suggesting the titular "Angelos" is a detective. An angel detective sounds completely on brand for Nicole's rich inner world*. But even if it turns out it was written by someone else, it's still eyebrow-raising that Kaeya carries around a book with this title.
*Update (6.4): an angel detective really was in character for Nicole!
Nicole: I even thought of having a Seelie detective. An angel who, longing to become a detective, became a Seelie, and by some twist of fate, ended up as a detective's assistant.
Bad news is that it doesn't sound like Nicole has novelized this story yet, which would make it impossible for Adventures of Angelos to be penned by her. (Unless this book is from the future somehow...)
It's a bit nothingburger compared to everything else but the spiral pattern on Nicole's dress is eerily similar to the icicles in Kaeya's burst. Interestingly enough, the Seelie husks also have a spiral pattern on their body, though their spirals are more rounded.
Nicole has two earrings that have the colorscheme of Kaeya's earring though the shape is different 💔.
I do think it's funny that these tiny earrings are completely hidden behind her hair as if we're not allowed to see them.
Well, I see you Nicole. I know what you've done... until you decide to break your silence, I am watching you.
trying to figure out what khaenri'ahns are like. WELL, they have star shaped pupils so clearly they're descended from the voyager. this could explain why people like pierro, vedr and kaeya's dad etc have eyeballs that can travel long distance and why surtalogi told skirk to find voyager in order to understand the source of his power. HOWEVER, the eclipse dynasty is heavily associated with black serpents/dragons and the title of vinster king belonged to nibelung, so they may be dragons instead. since there were multiple vinster kings throughout khaenri'ah's history, perhaps nibelung body hopped from king to king until he eventually turned into irmin. and YET, nibelung was very dead by the time khaenri'ah was founded so it's unclear if he could have tinkered with their physiology. therefore, we have to look for someone else who was alive, available and out for revenge: the voyager. since the angels who gave up their mind for power turned into dragons and nabu malikata's fragment manifested as a snake, (as well as khaenri'ahns having some undisclosed connection to angels), it opens the possibility that khaenri'ahns are actually the surviving group of angels who fled into the shadows. maybe voyager gave them their blood to keep them sane, giving rise to the khaenri'ahns... (even if nicole claimed those dragons were hunted to near extinction). and also. ALSO!! none of this explains why kaeya exists
another odd thing about kaeya's sq is that no one seems to have heard of "arcadia", not even the branch master of the adventurer's guild, cyrus. but through mary-ann (who is 500 years old) and the new artifact sets we know it DID exist, so the question is WHY does kaeya know about this place when even seasoned adventurers don't!????
I have already talked about this before, many, many times, but I wanted to gather all my jumbled thoughts from the past few months into one proper post along with some new revelations that further support the theory.
I just want to clarify first that I don't like abandoning the narrative in favor of a theory. I wouldn't be constantly trying to push for this if I wasn't at least 80% sure.
Kaeya is my favorite character in the whole game, but I am well aware of the limitations being put on his character…
…Unless 5-star Kaeya comes through for us, that is.
*UPDATE: added a section on Arlecchino 🥳 (4.6)
**added more info about Nicole (4.7)
***we now have verbal confirmation Seelie are angels! (5.1)
****huge possibility Khaenri'ahns are descended from the Voyager (5.5)
Apologies for the long read but I had to make it as thorough as possible, you understand.
INDEX
1. Seelie = Angels
2. Connections to Seelie and the Jinn
3. Midsummer Night's Dream
4. Nicole Reeyn
5. Arlecchino
6. Visual Similarities and Characteristics
7. Perinheri
THE VOYAGER AND THE FIRST ANGEL
Important update! Please read this first. The artifact set Finale of the Deep Galleries that came out in 5.5 has given us new information about the Voyager from afar and the First Angel. I urge you to read the entire lore of the set since I will only write down what's relevant to the theory.
Before the Moon Sisters fell, a Voyager from afar who had befriended Nibelung, visited Teyvat by casting their mind into the body of a youth. At this point in time, the Heavenly Principles had conquered Teyvat and defeated Nibelung, which prompted the Voyager to venture deep underground to meet with the First Angel.
The two fell in love and vowed to create a place where gods and humans could co-exist. To facilitate this, the Angel passed on forbidden knowledge about the secrets of creation. This obviously wasn't received well by the Powers That Be and the Angels were cursed to lose their form and intelligence if they ever gave the love that was meant for all to one person.
The artifact set does not say what happened to the Voyager, though according to legend, they were stripped of their memories, too.
The interesting part here is that the Voyager, in the body of the youth, has star-like pupils, which implies they're connected to Khaenri'ah:
Until the first angel met an unnamed youth beneath the silver tree in the far north,
And in those star-like pupils, saw a reflection of herself she had never yet known.
It's unclear if the youth was a pre-existing person or a body shaped by the Voyager. It's also unclear if the star-shaped pupils were the result of the Voyager possessing the youth. However, there is a precedent for this when Xbalanque possessed a boy in Mavuika's SQ; changing his pupils to the trademark suns of the Pyro Archon.
What does this mean for Khaenri'ah?
Well. Either the Voyager is the sole origin of Khaenri'ah's bloodline or the Voyager and the First Angel had offspring who inherited the star-shaped pupils. According to the artifact set, a girl, who is likely Skirk, was sent to look for traces of the Voyager by her master Surtalogi. Surtalogi, of course, is one of the Five Sinners of Khaenri'ah.
Nicole Reeyn, an angel survivor, has tiny star-shaped pupils, that are notably solid and look similar to Pierro's. Perhaps this is another hint that Khaenri'ahns are the descendants of angels.
Keep this in the back of your mind as you read the rest of the post.
SEELIE = ANGELS
Yohualtecuhtin, Lord of the Night: The people of Natlan worship me, and call me their "lord"... In the ancient past, before we died out, we were also known by a different name... "Angels."
Yohualtecuhtin, Lord of the Night: But, adventurers like you are probably more familiar with our devolved form... Seelies.
Traveler: So, Seelies are angels...
Note: 5.1's Archon Quest has finally verbally confirmed Seelie are angels but I will leave my old reasoning here to show you that it has always been foreshadowed.
Seelie are equated to angels in the game. The floating eyeball versions are even modeled after a type of sea slug called Sea Angels. In case you need more evidence than that:
Nabu Malikata is a Seelie survivor. Her last name Malikata can be derived from malayikata ملائكة which means angels/messengers in Arabic.
The Jinn were created from Nabu Malikata's blood, they are referred to as the "descendants of Seelie" in the world quest "The Falcon's Hunt".
Seelie were heavenly envoys who would deliver messages from Celestia to humans. Nabu Malikata even refers to them as the "fallen envoys of heaven", after they were cast down.
So, if you ever happen to spot the phrase "heavenly/divine envoys", they are actually referring to the Seelie.
As for what they may have looked like, the Mural Room in Dragonspine features a depiction of an envoy with wings and what looks like horns or a crown on its head. Translated from Latin, the text next to it is as follows:
Fidelis angeli iuvant
The angels help the faithful
Seelie are guides who reward humans with treasure after they lead them back to their Seelie courts. Simply put, they are returning a favor. Who else do we know of who is obsessed with favors?
ANGELS GEORG
The Seelie
Kaeya has a bunch of notable connections to angels, the more you start to look for them the more you notice.
According to Kaeya's character story A List, he owns a book called The Adventures of Angelos, in which he keeps a list of names. Angelos, of course, means angel.
Between the pages of "The Adventures of Angelos," you find a list of names written on a sheet of official Knights of Favonius letterhead paper.
Kaeya's favorite haunt is Angel's Share. The logo for Angel's Share is two angels drinking from a wine glass. Angel's Share was established by Dawn Winery, where Kaeya was left at for unknown reasons. According to Diluc's character story, Crepus told him the following:
"The world would never turn its back on the faithful."
This is reminiscent of the mural in Dragonspine: "The angels help the faithful."
Furthermore, the teacups used to represent the mage Nicole can be found in Dawn Winery. Even so, the teaset is most likely a standard set associated with the Hexenzirkel and not representative of Nicole. Nicole is known as the "guide who never gets lost". We'll get back to her later.
It's possible that Dawn Winery had some dealings with the Seelie/Hexenzirkel or that it was established by them.
Kaeya's favorite drink is Death After Noon. This is based on the real drink "Death in the Afternoon", which famously contains absinthe. In the Book of Revelation, Apsinthion, or Wormwood, is the name of an angel or star who fell to earth.
The Abyss Mages chant in Enochian which is the language of the angels. They use this language when they regenerate their shields and to control the Hilichurls. The Abyss Order mostly consists of former Khaenri'ahns.
When Kaeya spots the Abyss Mage back in the Temple of the Wolf, it speaks to him in Enochian. They even added a subtitle to highlight its importance.
Kaeya: There's no way hilichurls organized an ambush like this themselves — not with their limited mental capacity…
(A Hydro Abyss Mage reveals itself)
Kaeya: Thus YOU were behind this.
Hydro Abyss Mage: Gohus, Chiso Vonph.
Kaeya claims he's blessed with certain linguistic powers when Paimon asks him how he gathered information about the Abyss Twin.
Paimon: What exactly did you have to do to find this out!?
Kaeya: Heh… Let's just say I'm blessed with certain linguistic powers.
In the manga, it was implied Kaeya was able to read an unfamiliar script that not even Lisa, the Akademiya's best student in two hundred years, could understand.
We don't know where Kaeya lived beforehand but he might have lived in the Dark Sea. The Dark Sea is not a literal sea but any place outside of the rule of the Seven. Think Enkanomiya and possibly Khaenri'ah.
Kaeya: But, as you can see, this is but a deserted land. Based on previous experience, I decided that it would be best to wait for contact.
In the Midsummer Island event, Kaeya says he's been stranded on an island before, and in typical Kaeya fashion does not elaborate. (This might be connected to the Nameless Island, which Kaeya visited on his birthday.) Venti alludes Kaeya might have come from the Dark Sea, by the poem he gives him:
Venti: "Majestic waves cresting, surf roaring its tale, none but the ocean to hear as I sing."
Venti: "The stars in my eyes as I chart toward the horizon, that into one day, from the endless dome of night I shall spring."
Palaces of the Seelie can be found in one particular ruin of the Dark Sea: Drunkard's Tale, where the Seelie maiden was situated.
This wasteland is said to be a land beyond the dominion of the deities, inhabited only by the grotesque ghostly remains of fallen gods, where the former palaces of the Seelie now stand empty.
In the Veluriyam Mirage event, Kaeya starred in a play written by Zosimos. According to Idyia, Zosimos based the play on a rumor he heard about a thief and a mage, meaning there might be some truth to it. He then combined the story with Idyia's backstory.
Kaeya's character, the unnamed dagger bandit, follows a shooting star, which turns out to be a woman. The dagger bandit is most likely meant to be Pirate Grandpa or someone closely related to Kaeya, since he hailed from a dark realm and his vision is modified to look like an 8-pointed star (as per Zosimos's design). The dark realm could very well be Khaenri'ah.
As it turns out, Zosimos's namesake Zosimos the alchemist, claimed fallen angels were the ones who taught humans the art of metallurgy.
The ancient and divine writings say that the angels became enamoured of women; and, descending, taught them all the works of nature. From them, therefore, is the first tradition, chema, concerning these arts; for they called this book chema and hence the science of chemistry takes its name.
…Yeah, I don't think it's a coincidence the play Kaeya starred in was written by this specific guy 😮💨.
Maybe we're meant to equate the fallen star with a fallen angel. Whoever this fallen star and dagger bandit are, is unknown, but I think we can safely assume it has something to do with Kaeya's family and/or Khaenri'ah's deeper lore.
Kaeya's constellation is a peacock. Peacock feathers have countless eyes just like how angels are popularly depicted. In Renaissance art, angels are even portrayed with peacock wings.
The description of Kaeya's friendship namecard in CN implies he has many Augen. 👁
孔雀漂亮尾羽上的花纹很像是永不闭上的眼睛。所以凯亚并非少了一只眼睛、而是···
The patterns on the beautiful tail feathers of a peacock resemble eyes that never close. So Kaeya isn’t missing an eye, but…
And then it just trails off. I think it’s meant to say: "Kaeya isn’t missing an eye, rather he has many of them."
Perhaps they were being literal.
The Jinn
In his hangout, Kaeya gifts the Traveler a lamp said to have housed a powerful Jinni. As said before Jinn are descendants of the Seelie.
The people turned against each other, and the Jinn scattered across the lands… Broken souls became fuel to a titanic machine, and the mindless descendants of the Seelie were degraded into slaves of infinite power…
In comparison to other companion gifts, who are connected to their item in some way, Kaeya's gift stands out as an outlier… unless it is a surprise tool that can help us understand him later.
He is also familiar with the tale of the in-game book Shepard and the Magic Bottle, although he changes the ending of the story as he recounts it to Klee. This book is about a Jinni who gets freed from a bottle...
From his hangout, we learn Kaeya owns a lucky coin that can allegedly do anything he wishes from it. He then goes on to say there's a pre-existing arrangement between them. Perhaps this coin has a Jinni fragment inside of it similar to Benben, Jeht's companion.
That would be the simple explanation… but nothing is ever simple with Kaeya.
MIDSUMMER NIGHT'S DREAM
Now onto the most damning piece of evidence. Kaeya himself is based on the changeling baby from Midsummer Night's Dream. Oberon is the Fairy King, whose name is the French derivative of Alberich.
This checks out as Oberon was also an important figure from the Merovingian Dynasty that included names such as Chlothar and Caribert.
Titania is the Fairy Queen, who adopted her scion's baby after she died in childbirth. This baby was the son of an Indian king, in other words, an Indian prince.
In today's popular culture, Titania is the Queen of the Summer Court, also known as the Seelie Court.
Most literature, folklore, and pop-culture interpretations of faerie depict Titania as the actual leader of the Seelie Fey, she often rules the Summer Court.
Princess Fischl is also connected to this play, as she had created a Sommernachtgarten, or Summer Night Garden, that now lies in ruins in the domain Midsummer Courtyard.
Suddenly Kaeya and Fischl being featured in the Midsummer Island events start to make sense. I wouldn't be surprised if Fischl showed up again in this year's summer event.
How Kaeya and Princess Fischl are connected is still unclear but the possibility of them being related keeps growing. Whatever the case, the Indian prince's (adoptive) mom being a Seelie Queen is pretty straightforward.
"But isn't he adopted? That means he isn't a Seelie!" Yes, but remember Oberon, Titania's husband, is Alberich who Kaeya IS related to.
It's hard to tell what direction they're going in, but I have no doubt Kaeya is half-something, because the other character he is based on is Hagen, who is always half-Human, with the other part being either dwarf or elf.
With all the angel/Seelie/Jinn connections, I think we can guess what Kaeya's other half is.
Before I forget: Oberon and Titania fought over the child; Oberon wanted the boy to become a knight, his henchman, but Titania refused as she felt obligated to raise him in his mother's stead. Unfortunately, Oberon succeeded in getting Titania to hand over the child, as he had trapped her in a dream-like state...
Another fun thing I discovered is that the title of the trailer Winter Night's Lazzo is a reference to Midsummer Night's Dream as well.
An explanation for this could be that aside from the aforementioned Seelie, there exist a darker counterpart, the Unseelie, which has its roots in Scottish folklore.
The most common courts from traditional legends are the Seelie or Summer Court, and the Unseelie or Winter Court.
In popular culture, the Unseelie Court is the Winter Court ruled by the Queen of Air and Darkness: the sister of Titania. This Winter Queen seems to be unnamed but I've found some call her Mab, another reference to one of Shakespeare's plays.
Did you know they probably named Snezhnaya after the fairy tale of the Snow Queen, which is Snezhnaya Koroleva in Russian? Snow Queen, Winter Queen, Tsaritsa... The shoe fits 🤷🏽♀️
In Genshin, there is no mention of any Unseelie yet, but if the Seelie are like angels, then the Unseelie might be the equivalent of fallen angels or demons. Well, we shall see how that plays out.
Back to Titania, she was a fairy who adopted her friend's son after she passed away. Is there is a character who could fulfill this role for Kaeya, acting as some kind of guardian angel?
NICOLE REEYN
Nicole is a witch of the Hexenzirkel, known as Mage "N". She is a powerful prophet capable of divining the fate of the world.
And as of Luna III, she has finally confirmed she's an angel 🎉. As before, I will leave some of my old reasoning here.
Alice says Nicole is the guide who never gets lost and that she is obsessed with guiding people. That's literally Seelie 101!
Alice: The "guide who will never get lost" is N, otherwise known as Nicole. You may have not encountered her yet, but she is a truly extraordinary woman who has made this world's direction and order her subject of study.
Alice: Some of you may be fortunate enough to have already heard her voice. Like a prophetess, she will only speak to guide people toward the truth when a change has occurred in the world.
Alice: She has a tendency to… suddenly speak in someone's mind without any warning.
New dialogue from Wolfy, the stuffed toy from Imaginarium Theater, pretty much confirms Nicole is a Seelie. He talks about a "Boar" Tribe, where the "boars" did bad things and were punished by their Master.
Wolfy: The master took out a rusted set of scales, and told the boars to stack their own things on both sides. If the scales tipped to one side, they could leave.
The boars who gave up their heads turned into animals like wolves, snakes and lizards and the boars who gave up their muscle became rabbits, instinctively guiding people to treasure. Guiding people to treasure is the number one job of the Seelie husks.
Loading Screen
Now you see them; now you don't. Once a mighty race that lived to guide mankind, now the most Seelie offer is a little treasure to willing followers.
However, there was one boar who placed their head and muscle evenly on both sides of the scale, which caused it to break in the middle. This "boar" is Nicole.
Wolfy: And so she became a mute person — for she had placed her voice upon the scales as well.
Wolfy: She is also a friend of Madame Mage, and I hear she likes to speak in people's heads!
Furthermore, Nicole losing her voice, or perhaps giving it up, is reminiscent of the fairy tale The Little Mermaid, written by Hans Christian Anderson, Anderdottir's inspiration. In the book, the mermaid sacrifices her voice to become human. However she fails to uphold the condition and dies, which turns her into an air spirit.
Kaeya conveniently has several references to the wind.
He is dubbed the Frostwind Swordsman, his outfit is called Icy Featherflight, his OTHER outfit is Sailwind Shadow, his sixth constellation is Glacial Whirlwind, and he has a passive that decreases stamina consumption…
Noelle even describes him as someone who comes and goes with the wind.
As mentioned in the previous section, Kaeya was stranded on a deserted island, this might be referring to the Nameless Island, which, according to an old blog post on the official CN website, Kaeya visited on his birthday. Where this island came from is unclear but it is shrouded in mist and invisible on the map.
The Nameless Island has a sun-or moondial associated with the God of Time. The weathered transcription is as follows:
Ravaged Carving: "Stories brought on the wind will bloom into legends in due time."
You can also hear this faint voice speaking when you do the quest related to the island:
Faint Voice: "An ancient tale comes whisked in the wind…"
Faint Voice: "In time, it will grow and sprout once again…"
In the same blog post, Kaeya says the following:
我还有很多故事…还有很多时间。
I have plenty of stories… and plenty of time.
😮💨
When Kaeya casts his burst you even see him pull the wind towards himself, towards that eight-pointed star.
Furthermore, he came to Mondstadt during a LATE SUMMER NIGHT'S STORM, contradicting the fact that there hasn't been a single storm in Mondstadt since Venti gave them his protection.
Kaeya's Character Story
"If Master Crepus hadn't taken me in, I doubt I'd have made it through the storm that night."
Vind: Since Lord Barbatos began protecting Mondstadt, we have not seen a single storm, and the watchtowers have slowly fallen into disrepair.
He probably wasn't lying about this since Varka could have easily fact-checked this with Diluc or Dawn Winery.
Perhaps Nicole was responsible for this odd contradiction if she was the one who guided Kaeya and his father to Dawn Winery. Coincidentally, the Jinni Liloupar was able to command sandstorms at her will.
Liloupar once had the immense power to command sandstorms at her will. The howling gale that lashes the desert used to be the blade and shield at her disposal.
Since the Jinn are descendants of the Seelie, perhaps Nicole could have a similar power. (Or maybe she became a giant wind turbine, who even knows anymore.)
"But why would a witch go through all this trouble for just one guy?" If Titania took care of her friend's baby after she died, then maybe Nicole was friends with Kaeya's mom and decided to offer her protection.
Let's just get this out of the way first: No, Nicole is not Diluc's mom, the pattern on the teacups can be found within the architecture of Dawn Winery, which means the teaset is probably just a product of the winery. But perhaps a witch or an angel was involved in its founding; Angel's Share is named as such for a reason.
Diluc does not possess any Seelie/fairy/angel/witch connections other than Angel's Share so I don't think she's related to him. Kaeya on the other hand 🤷🏽♀️
Nicole is not Kaeya's mom/grandma either, at least not in the biological sense, but something interesting is that Nicole's name means "Victory of the people", while the first character in Kaeya's name means victory as well.
Nicole = from νίκη (níkē, “victory”) + λαός (laós, “people”).
Kaeya = 凯亚, 凯 = music of triumph; paean; triumph; victory
The AQ A Space and Time for You revealed a "sage" went to Direidyth's village to give them the prophecy of Khaenri'ah's destruction. This sage was actually Nicole! Nicole Reeyn was in Khaenri'ah approximately 500 years ago! Anfortas Alberich was alive during this time, so them knowing each other is not impossible. (Alice notes Nicole was on a "secret mission" approximately 500 years ago that she has "no regrets" about.)
Another important lore drop is that Nicole is the mastermind behind our beloved Princess Fischl all along! She co-authored the books with her fallen Seelie friend. According to Mr Nine, the story is 90% fiction and 10% real as Nicole's version was too dangerous to be told in its uncensored form. Nothing has been confirmed yet but it's possible Princess Fischl is an allegory for the First Angel.
While the post I'm about to link to is a bit outdated, Kaeya does have some serious connections to Princess Fischl, (who I previously speculated was as a fallen angel and a witch! Turns out, it was because of Nicole Reeyn!). With hints at him being a Prince continuing to persist, we can assume he's definitely not some random guy. Whether he's aware of this or not is debatable.
He's called "our last hope", by his father, which like everything pertaining to Kaeya, is never explained. However, the Aranara Aranaga describes hope as a dream that never dissipates… which I thought was pretty poetic.
Aranaga: There are dreams because there is memory. Memory is nourished, so there is life. So, it can grow, the thing to repel Marana (forbidden knowledge).
Traveler: I'm guessing you mean "hope"?
Aranaga: Yeah, right you are, Golden Nara (Traveler). The thing that flows, cannot be seen, cannot be touched… Hope. Like the wind… But it never dissipates, like a dream.
Nabu Malikata
Nicole has some fascinating similarities with Nabu Malikata that I will briefly list here:
Nabu Malikata last name can mean angels but it can also mean queen. Nicole Reeyn's last name is derived from reine which also means queen.
"Nabu" means prophet in Akkadian and she was able to predict her own death, Nicole is a prophetess too.
After Nabu Malikata disappeared, Deshret dreamed of her feeling her way through a crystalline maze. The inside of Irminsul is a crystalline maze. Nicole is part of the Hexenzirkel who travel to the Irminsul to study it.
Nabu Malikata is the Mistress of the Orchard and Wine, Nicole could have ties to Dawn Winery, a wine orchard.
Nabu Malikata is also a dream-mother, capable of giving humans dreams. According to Furina's character blurb, Nicole left a fabel inside someone's dream.
They're not the same person but this is one of those things that will keep haunting you once you uncover it. And now they will haunt you.
ARLECCHINO
Enter "Father".
What we know of her so far is that she is the last surviving descendant of Khaenri'ah's Crimson Moon clan. Arlecchino's blood is cursed, yet unlike the other curse-bearers we know like Dainsleif and Chlothar, she still ages visibly. Before we get ahead of ourselves, it's specifically stated in her boss description that she IS the Crimson Moon's SOLE scion, so Kaeya is likely not part of that bloodline.
Someday, the hearth-fire's faint radiance shall burn the old world away, incinerating the final scion of the baleful moon as well.
I think we all know by now that Arlecchino has some angelic features.
Like Kaeya, she is associated with an animal with many eyes: a spider. And like Kaeya, she wears one prominent wing on her back but only when she is in battle. This wing is actually crafted by her from spider silk, so it's not actually an "organic" wing.
Arlecchino shares boss theme lyrics with the most famous one-winged angel in recent history: Sephiroth (FF7). They are both in turn inspired by Abezethibou, a fallen angel with one red wing. The interesting thing about Sephiroth is that he was born from an experiment, where they injected cells from an alien "calamity" into him when he was still a fetus. This led him to develop the iconic one black wing.
Furthermore, the title of Arlecchino can be traced back to the Erlking, an evil elf who could kill children with just one touch. Arlecchino does seem to be somewhat inspired by him as seen in this comparison.
Erlking means Elf King which just so happens to be the meaning of Alberich (Elf King). 🤨 There's even a dude straight up called Alf (elf) in the Perinheri book.
In the Romance-speaking world, beings comparable to elves are widely known by words derived from Latin fata ('fate'), which came into English as fairy. This word became partly synonymous with elf by the early modern period.
😑…
Since the Balemoon Bloodfire that runs through Arlecchino's veins originates from the long-dead Crimson Moon, it's possible that the moons are some kind of angelic construct. According to the artifact Finale of the Deep Galleries, the angels were descended from light itself... But at the time of writing, it's still unclear what exactly the moons are.
To further complicate things, Mona's astrolabe uses the names of 4 Archangels.
(From the Wiki)
Mona's astrolabe (Outer ring): GBL URL MKL RPL
The archangels Gabriel, Uriel, Michael, and Raphael.
…It is unknown who they are referring to but since she is using her astrolabe to divine someone's fate they could either be the names of the three Moon Sisters + the Sun or the Four Shades.
Arlecchino has another weird ability: her blood can create afterimages or shadows which appear like this around her in her boss fight:
These look awfully similar to the Pari in-game, and Pari just so happen to be like fairies in Persian mythology. Arlecchino's nickname was even Perrie, which is probably a pun on Peri, the inspiration behind the Pari.
In the game, the Pari are sentient beings of Khvarena, which in turn was separated from Nabu Malikata's body. As it happens, Khvarena can also dwell inside humans, these people are called the scions of Khvarena. (More on that here where I proposed Kaeya's mom might have been one of these scions.)
Stamen of Khvarena's Origin
Nabu Malikata: "And so I separated you (Khvarena) from my body, and I ask you now to prevent that nightmare's coming."
No doubt about it: Arlecchino is carrying the bloodline of a (dead) moon angel…thing. Maybe all Khaenri'ahns are descendants of angels, but it's hard to say for now if they inherited it through normal means, or if the Crimson Moon clan used a ritual to transmute their blood. According to the book Perinheri, the Crimson Moon dynasty was deeply involved with alchemy, though it fell off by the time of the Eclipse Dynasty.
(Perhaps they even used the Moon's remains (ashes) to achieve this. Maybe that's why Arlecchino glitches: she was "re-born" from the "afterimage" (ashes) of the Crimson Moon.)
Combined with Zosimos's play implying the fallen star was a fallen angel, Khaenri'ahns could very well be descendants of fallen angels. In that case, they could be like the Nephilim, who are descendants of humans and fallen angels. Nephilim is often translated as giants or the fallen ones, which is very funny considering the meaning of Titania's name (Titan).
The name Titania for the queen of the fairies appears to have been the invention of Shakespeare, for, as Mr. Ritson remarks, she is not "so called by any other writer." Why, however, the poet designated her by this title, presents, according to Mr. Keightley, no difficulty. "It was," he says, "the belief of those days that the fairies were the same as the classic nymphs, the attendants of Diana. The Fairy Queen was therefore the same as Diana whom Ovid (Met. iii. 173) styles Titania."
Also, scholars suggest Shakespeare's Titania is ultimately referring to the moon goddess Diana, so make of that what you will. There's even a part in the play where Titania looks up at the moon and likens it to a crying eye… Another fun fact: on Tsurumi island, there's a mural from the ancient civilization ruins that references a poem about Diana by the Latin poet Catullus.
In any case, Arlecchino basically adds fuel to the theory that Khaenri'ahns might be the descendants of angels/Seelie. Though whether they inherited it naturally or through snorting up moon ashes remains to be seen. The Balemoon Bloodfire is dubbed a "noble blood" which means the Crimson Moon clan was regarded as nobility. Just another thing Arlecchino and Kaeya have in common.
This poses another conundrum for Kaeya though: if it's his Khaenri'ahn father who gave him his supposed "angel" ancestry as opposed to his mother, we're still left with the mystery of where he got his royal heritage from. Nobility ≠ royalty.
The Alberichs weren't of royal blood, we know this, yet Kaeya's prince-baiting adventure continues, same as it ever was 😮💨
BREATH OF THE FEYWILD
This is the fun part where I list similarities between Kaeya and the Seelie, from his design to his personality. Full disclosure, this is not to be taken too seriously!
Visual Design
As you know, Kaeya has a giant wing on his back with three feathers.
No one else has wings on their outfit other than Paimon and Skirk who has a tiny one on her back. Arlecchino has one wing that only appears in battle or during her charged attack. Seelie courts have a little wing emblem and that angel in the Dragonspine Mural has a stylized wing.
Kaeya has one eye and wears a fluffy boa, same as the Seelie husks we see floating around. Though Kaeya doesn't have two horns, the peacock on his namecard does have two little feathers on its head.
Also, the Seelie emblem on the domain murals look similar to the 8-pointed star on Kaeya's outfit. The downward point is elongated which could represent the cone-shaped legs the Seelie husks have.
Seelie and their beauty keep being equated to moonlight… Kaeya is called canonically good-looking in game and has unexplained light streaks in his hair.
Kaeya was left in Mondstadt (Moon City), ordered a Moonlit Alley in his hangout (with Venti present) and gifted the Traveler a Moon Pie for his most recent birthday 😒. Surely of no importance whatsoever.
Personality
I am basing this on the known Seelie we have in the game.
First of, Seelie were guides of humanity, and taught them wisdom and language.
Arama: A Seelie? In the ancient stories, Seelies were a great race with wisdom and beauty beyond the pale of this earth. They traveled with Nara (humans) and taught Nara languages and the philosophy of nature.
… In his teapot dialogue, Kaeya offers to put together a guide for the Traveler when they ask for his wisdom.
Traveler: Can I rely on your words of wisdom in the future?
Kaeya: I'm at your service. In fact… would you like me to compile a guide for you…?
Kaeya: It would contain all kinds of practical knowledge for at home and on the road, including the techniques I have developed for communicating with people from all walks of life. I'd like to share it all with you.
Kaeya acts as a teacher for Klee giving her advice on how to dodge the authorities (Jean) and whatnot.
Speaking of dodging, as stated previously, Seelie were said to be faster than a storm, and Kaeya has a passive called Hidden Strength that decreases stamina consumption. He's actually one of the fastest running characters-gameplay wise.
The loading screen description for Seelie says the following;
Now you see them, now you don't.
Finally an explanation for Kaeya's ability to teleport in his normal attacks. It's just as Noelle said, he comes and goes with the wind.
In Scottish folklore Seelie will ask humans for help and give them a reward in return. In his Story Quest, Kaeya does the same, asking the Traveler for help and gifting them a sword for their efforts. Yes, it was a trap but he did do all of that, and in his Story Quest no less! Story Quests are designed as a glimpse into the character's life….
Wait a minute, he led them into a trap. Where have I heard that before?
Angelica! The woman from the book Perinheri is very obviously an angel (HER NAME LITERALLY GIVES IT AWAY) and thus potentially a Seelie, or at least someone belonging to the angel hierarchy.
Angelica led Hleobrant on with promises and then led him into a trap, not unlike what Nabu Malikata did to Deshret. She knew she was going to die and used his feelings for her to make sure she would never be forgotten.
Furthermore, if a Seelie is insulted they will exact revenge on those who wronged them. Kaeya can be a very petty person, as stated by Adelinde.
Diluc: Yes… about Kaeya…
Diluc: I should have known he would see this as the perfect opportunity to get back at me.
Dude pulled up the Wikipedia page on Seelie 😭😭😭.
Nabu Malikata does not seem to possess human emotions which makes sense since angels operate on a higher level than humans. Does make you wonder if Kaeya's occasionally strange behavior is a result of him being half-Seelie.
While not exactly a personality trait, Kaeya repeats some of Nicole's sayings which I thought was interesting.
Nicole: History does not change easily, but human hearts can.
Kaeya: History always repeats itself.
Kaeya: Anyway, that's exactly why actors need to wake up and realize they don't have to follow the script. There's nothing to stop them from following their gut and making it up as they go along.
As for why Kaeya would know this: find out in 2026 😂 (😭)
Venti
Since fairies and air spirits are another potential branch of Kaeya's family tree we can consult the most prominent air spirit in the game: Venti.
Kaeya and Venti have a lot in common, personality wise. Both like alcohol, are mischievous, and have a very mellow attitude.
They also tend to disappear when we need lore the most.
This is very stereotypical of how fairies are portrayed. Down to their love of wine and penchant to pull pranks.
Is Venti some kind of Seelie? Well, he does have wings, and he was a single thread of the thousand winds (Istaroth) which represent freedom… Freedom, just like Angelica.
Play within a play
In Midsummer Night's Dream, the fairies toy with the humans like dolls. It's their meddling that causes all the mishaps in the play. They even call Oberon the King of Shadows, with shadows referring to the fairies as well as being Elizabethan slang for actors.
[…] even within this fictional world [Shakespeare] has created, the human characters are still treated as plot devices, pawns to be manipulated and directed across the play by the faeries.
If you've read the manga, you know where this is going.
If not:
“All the world's a stage, and all the people merely players – Kaeya Alberich”
–William Shakespeare
Kaeya has more instances where he treats people like they are fulfilling a role: in his outfit description he talks about the bandit and the knight as roles they have to fulfill. When he first meets the Traveler, he applauds like he just witnessed a performance. In Diluc's Story Quest, he breaks the fourth wall by mentioning the chapter of the Story Quest he's in.
Paimon: Kaeya!? Where did you come from?
Kaeya: I just picked a good spot to quietly sit and watch the show.
Paimon: Whaaa… You've been here this whole time!?
BECAUSE HE COMES AND GOES LIKE THE WIND KEEP UP PAIMON
And after Crepus's death he ponders on the roles he should have played: that of a son and that of a brother.
Very normal behavior…FOR A SEELIE.
You see, Deshret and Nabu Malikata created a City for the Jinn, called the City of Amphitheaters… where they had theaters 😮💨
Altar of Mirages
The Jinn once used this place as a free theater and a paradise without sorrow or care.
Princess Fischl also introduced theater to the paradise of the Immernachtreich where her people would dedicate plays to her. (Don't underestimate how connected she is to all this!)
PERINHERI
In case you're unaware, a new book released in patch 4.5 called Perinheri has given us new Khaenri'ah lore. I'll only mention the bits relevant to the theory but it's definitely worth reading if you haven't already.
In the story, a woman named Angelica visits the "Kingdom" as a supposed Princess from some defeated nation. Angelica declares she will marry the greatest knight of the Kingdom and lists several names, one of which is Alberich, leader of half of the knights.
But that's not the only interesting part.
Angelica leads Hleobrant outside the Kingdom's borders which causes him to transform into a beast. This is because he is cursed: his ancestors forsook their gods when they came to live at the Kingdom.
Angelica, however, bears no such curses as she explains:
The witch, Angelica, explained thus:
"Hleobrant is the descendant of those who forsook their god and came to the Kingdom. This is why the Kingdom's obstinately pure-blooded aristocracy persists. This is the price of betraying your own god.
As for you, Perinheri, you are one who drifted there. Thus, you bear no such curse. You may not have the nobility to shoulder a world, but you too have your own destiny.
And as for me? I betrayed no one, not for a moment, until my god died, so I too bear this curse not. But you now see who I truly am, yes?"
Look. I don't think I need to spell this out but Angelica is an angel, her name is even explained to mean "one who is as a divine emissary", which, as we established before, are Seelie. Kaeya even has that stupid book The Adventures of Angelos which is obviously a hint towards whatever the fuck he is.
Angelos, Angelica…. Need I say more? 😮💨😮💨😮💨
She also conveniently disappears at the end BECAUSE SHE COMES AND GOES LIKE THE WIND
Anyway, this could explain why Kaeya isn't cursed, his mother/grandmother was a Seelie who never forsook her god. We don't know what the bloodline of Khaenri'ahns consists of… so I can't confidently say they are all descendants of angels. Kaeya definitely is though. You're still a Seelie and that's FINAL.
Otherwise I don't know how else you could explain all of the above.
If he's not a Seelie/angel or a descendant of one, then the only explanation I can think of is that he was blessed by one and is under their protection. Perhaps he was even raised by a bunch of them like the Indian prince from Shakespeare's play.
Maybe in some kind of Sommernachtgarten ☀️🌺
Or a Winter Palace 👸🏼❄️
Frost Prince, Sun Prince, Seelie Prince, whatever Kaeya might be, I will keep updating this post as we go along for the sake of the five people reading this 🫡.
It's like Shakespeare always said, it's Kaeya's world and we're all just living in it.
i still think kaeya's pirate grandpa meeting that fallen star mage is the KEY to solving the Kaeya Curse problem. it was revealed in that play that
kaeya was playing a thief who is very obviously meant to be pirate grandpa
the story is based on rumors about a thief and a mage
the mage was portrayed as a fallen star
the play combines idyia's backstory with that of the thief meeting the mage resulting in a mishmash of two seperate plots
that mage could be the reason kaeya is able to exist normally!!
right now, there are only a few mages who double as fallen stars. mage nicole, who is a fallen angel, and potentially octavia, who seems to be an outlander like skirk (also compared to a fallen star/meteorite). another possibility, as crazy as it sounds, is the real princess "fischl" but it's currently impossible to determine who she was and in what time she existed.
with that being said! they went out of their way to emphasize a connection to the jinn, by dropping kaeya in a literal bottle, making him tell stories of the jinn, basing pirate grandpa on aladdin and gifting the traveler a jinni lamp. so perhaps the fallen mage was a jinni, who are the descendants of a fallen angel (nabu malikata) anyway.
no matter what route they take, it can all be traced back to angelic ancestry/blessing and you can pry this truth™ from my cold dead hands!
some thoughts on the four pillars because i'm tired of the constant anfortas erasure.
in the book perinheri, a wandering angel who went by the alias of angelica (nicole? zibai??), listed FOUR of the mightiest figures in khaenri'ah with one of them being "commander alberich".
through rerir's flashbacks it's revealed there IS in fact a group of people with high standing in khaenri'ah aptly named "the four pillars of khaenri'ah". (they were alluded to before but at the time it was unclear what their purpose was.)
four of the mightiest figures of khaenri'ah vs the four pillars of khaenri'ah. gonna take a wild guess and assume they are one and the same.
should be noted that though hroptatyr was one of the four pillars, he was absent from angelica's list. this can be explained by any number of reasons such as hroptatyr being their successor or hropt's last name being in there instead.
putting that aside, let's move on to who really matters: "alberich, commander of half the knights". logically this should be anfortas alberich as he was the leader of the warrior band the schwanenritter while dainsleif led the black serpent knights. IF anfortas is this "commander", then it implies he was one of the four pillars, which could explain why he was able to become regent if he was already serving massive amounts of cunt.
if anfortas is not "commander alberich" and merely their descendant, it's still a huge deal that an alberich managed to become one of the four pillars. put some respect on kaeya's family name!
