I finished the MSQ for Dawntrail last night, and I've got thoughts. Possibly unpopular ones.
1) I really like Wuk Lamat, and I think her character has potential. If I had ANY quibble it's that sometimes she's a little too wholesome for my tastes. But I'm fully prepared for that to change in a later expansion. She's sweet and naive, and that's a big change from where we were in ShB and EW, so I understand why it's so jarring.
2) This feels like ARR:2, and I think that's a good thing. We're setting the scene for the next big adventure, and I enjoyed the tease about more reflections. (Tbh all this did was accelerate Y'shtola's plans lol.) I'm excited to see where we go next... Hopefully someday Meracydia lol.
3) the fact that Cahciua didn't have an accent will continue to puzzle me. That said, her relationship with Erenville - and her goodbye in particular - hits way different when you've got kids.
4) I was moved by the last leg of the MSQ, and the story of the Endless. As much as EW? No, but where this lacked narrative weight it made up for it with relatability. If you've lost someone you wish you could talk to again, it hits. (Though obligatory ymmv on that I guess.)
5) The zones were beautiful, but I didn't care for most of the music. Some of it (like Lost in the Deep) really resonated and I felt fit the mood. But others... Yeah, sorry, I'm a Smile hater. And I really disliked the ending music. I was concerned about that as early as the trailer, and sad to see I was right. But that's a preference thing. ShB was more my speed.
6) Holy shit the difficulty level ramped up on the dungeons/trials. I couldn't keep up with the mechanics a lot of the time, though I'm admittedly rusty. But again, I think that's a positive.
7) I see what people are saying about the voice acting, but it's really not that bad. (Yes, including the "Sphene! Listen to me!" bit.) If anything I had the hardest time with Gulool Ja Ja, but even then... Not the end of the world. Again, I'm taking it as ARR:2.
I think that's all I've got for now as I'm still kinda processing. But yeah. Overall have a mid-positive feeling toward it. I enjoyed the ending. Thought the lead up was some cool world building. Happy to see where we go.