mabith replied to your post “Like I have always hated the idea of a live action Dumbo movie, and...”
I really don't understand the live action remake fad, especially when they're SO similar to the original. Plus part of the joy of Dumbo is you don't see people's faces. Why live action these movies that will require so much computer shit?
Yeah, I get annoyed with the quantity of remakes, in general. It’s like...have they run out of stories? Because that’s what it feels like.
And, yeah, one of my first (rational) thoughts about it was “what, they added people?” In the original, the story centers around the animal characters and people are just sort of peripheral at best. So they just added a bunch of human characters? It seems like it would shift the story really weirdly.
The other thing I don’t like about live action remakes is that it feels almost dismissive of traditional animation. Like they’re upgrading their old films, because technology now is better. And while there’s a lot of really good computer animation and CGI or whatever, I just enjoy traditional animation. I think it’s cool, it takes a huge amount of skill, and it’s a lot more flexible as far as style.