An angel loses its wings everytime someone discredits Lizzie Youngs mental illness and trauma by saying it's unrealistic or that it was just for her redemption and INTENTIONALLY misses the point and diminishes what she’s been through and how that’s affected her
i’m convinced that the people who HATE her (not dislike, you’re obviously allowed to not like or favor a charecter) didn’t even try to understand her in r10 and let their prejudice take over. You’re allowed to dislike her. That’s okay. The point of the book was not for you to like her but to understand where her choices were coming from and why she acted the way she did.
And yes, what happened to her 100% justifies her actions and yes she does have ALOT of apologizing to do to both gibs and Katie and they're also justified if they do not forgive her.