I don’t have NH yet, but I’m trying to come up with a town name and I’m absolutely struggling 😫
That was the biggest mood for me too. I know a lot of bloggers made name generators and word lists that helped them choose (which is usually my go to route as a writer because I’m usually terrible at coming up with that stuff on the fly. My New Leaf town: Aquarine came out of nowhere. Like: “what if you said aquarium, but made it more fancy.”)
I named my island after the Anne of Green Gables series, where she lives in the fictitious community of Avonlea on Prince Edward Island. I love it, but I’ve also seen others who also chose the same name, which kind of frustrates me a little (but I knew what to expect). My other choice was Skallywag, after my first childhood dog. I guess my advice would be writing down some names you like and narrowing down a choice based on what you want the aesthetic of the island to be. I wanted mine to be cottagecore/country and that’s why Avonlea beat Skallywag.
That’s what I have to say on the matter, however, I also named my Wild World town Florida, so I wouldn’t trust my advice.