The major issues with the song “Gay Pirates” by Cosmo Jarvis are twofold, somewhat intertwined, and as follows: 1. gratuitous torture porn, and 2. historical inaccuracy.
Given the title of the song, we can assume that all the events take place aboard a pirate ship. So why does the pirate captain care so very much about who’s buggering who aboard his ship?
For everyone going “but wait! sodomy was illegal! that’s why he hated them!”, I would like to take a moment to remind you that THEY. ARE. PIRATES. Pirates don’t care about the law. That’s why they’re pirates.
Knowing that, we can expect pirates would probably be fairly indifferent towards two crewmen getting their mack on. But the aforementioned cursory Google search reveals something more: a little term called “matelotage.”
Matelotage is a lifelong male/male partnership practiced among Tortugan buccaneers; the participants in such a partnership are called matelots. According to Wikipedia,
Matelots shared their beds, property, food, and loot with one another. The extent to which matelotage included homosexuality is controversial. Although a few historians have claimed, with no evidence, that homosexuality was universal among the buccaneers, it is recognized by most that matelots shared women as well as their chattels, and that buccaneers were frequent and enthusiastic patrons of female prostitutes. It is nevertheless agreed that a substantial minority of buccaneer matelots were likely homosexual.
tl;dr – It looks a lot like what Queequeg and Ishmael get up to in Moby-Dick.
In short, not only do pirates have no reason to hate sodomy outright, but they even have a marriage-like system in place for male partnerships that, in some cases, involved a romantic relationship.











