I feel like a lot of the current Neopets merch is pretty hit or miss
Merchandise Neopets should make if they REALLY want my money
Printed editions of the plots.
Rerelease The Darkest Faerie on multiple systems. Maybe even a remaster or remake.
I know this one's a stretch, but: Battledome item replicas. LARP foam or NERF ones will do and fit my budget better, though actual steel replicas would be awesome.
A Curse of Maraqua deck for their new Battledome cardgame. I actually have high hopes this one will happen since there's already a Meridell one.
Posters based on each plot.
Actually release that TTRPG already. 2026: Wow, that aged badly
Replicas of the on-site character plushies, rather than just the various pets. My inner middle school kid would be thrilled to get a real life Magax plushie, and current me would be thrilled to get a Captain Scarblade plushie.
Character figurines. Kinda like these.
Real Faerie dolls.
