Lies- Yimir x Gn reader
Pronouns used- They/Them
Tw- none just cheating
A/N- This is my first oneshot so hope you like it
AU btw this came to mind after listing to was it ever really love. Coming September 9th by Natalie
Most of your closest friends called you two a power couple, buy only if they knew the truth. You met Yimir fist day of collage.
At first it was fun jokingly flirting with each other through class. But suddenly it wasn't a joke, meeting up in a empty classrooms to make out.
Between the time of that and dating Yimir, you caught feelings. You couldn't really fit the line between feelings and just loving having the attention. Everyone loved the power couple energy you gave off.
Armin was very curious on how you two worked out. Armin, Eren, and Mikasa were there sense you were a kid. You practicely told them everything.
All the problems started when Yimir introduced you to her friend Historia four months in. Lingering touches that would seem normal if you weren't paying attention. Whispering in each others ears, red cheeks soon followed after.
For a while you convinced yourself you were seeing things. Yimir would never do such a thing...
You kept questioning until you broke and decided to ask her yourself "Is there something between you and Historia?"
The scratches against the paper stopped, turning in her chair Yimir stared at you then let out a loud laugh "Oh, you got to be joking." Sighing Yimir rubbed her temple. "Look sweetie there is nothing going on between me at Historia."
Stumbling out an "Oh. alright then" Feeling a burning sensation I'm your chest, you turned around facing back towards your paper.
Hearing a groan you glanced towards Yimir who was currently walking towards you. squatting right next you Yimir grabbed your chin and forced you too look at her. Taking a long breath Yimir stroked her hand in your hair. "Look sweetie, your the only one I have eyes for. You don't need to worry about Historia."
Glancing at the floor you whispered "I know im sorry I doubted you."
Yimir lifted your chin up again to meet her brown eyes with yours "Tell you what I will stop talking to Historia for a while, if that makes you feel better."
Your heart fluttered but you felt bad for forcing her into this position. Slightly smiling you answered "If you are comfortable with that, sure".
Kissing your forehead she dragged you to the bed to cuddle for a while.
True to her word you didn't see Historia for a couple of weeks, but when she came back it seemed to get worse, at this point they didn't really try to hide it.
You hated that you still craved that validation to be loved by someone, even though watching them flirt with someone else left a burning sensation in your heart and throat.
You first confided in Armin and Mikasa who begged you to get out of the situation "(y/n) you need to leave that situation it's not good for you."
"I know Armin but I still love her" You looked at both of them desperately. "I just don't want to leave her"
Mikasa took your hands in hers staring you straight in the face "You need to let her go or your going to end up hurting yourself even more."
You at first took their words into consideration but finally made up your mind. Staying was the best option thinking that you'll hurt more if you if you left her.
Eren tried to convince you to no avail "Comon (Y/n) you can't keep doing this to yourself. She clearly doesn't love you like she's says."
Turning around to face him your voice echoing "Yes she does!" Your eyes started to swell up with tears. "she does." Your voice quieter then before.
Eren tried going after you when you turned around and left but Mikasa held him back shaking her head. They all hated seeing you this way but at this point they knew they couldn't do anything to stop you.
You Became Numb to the pain trying to enjoy every moment of affection you got from Yimir.
You would usually find yourself at a Cafe looking at an empty chair across from you. Usually something to do with Historia needing help. While scrolling through your phone a man sat down across from you. Looking at him he looked decent. Handsome, stuble beard, with chopped blond hair he was handsome. "Do you mind if I sit here?"
He looked at you curiously "I don't mind" You replied shrugging.
You were going to go back to your phone when he asked "Umm what's your name?"
"(Y/N)" Answering cousiouly. "You"
He nodded "Reiner. Nice to meet you." He stretched his hand out. You shook hands after a moment hesitation from your.
Deciding to go on with the conversation "what are you hear for today."
Reiner looked up from his hot chocolate "looking for somewhere to go to in the morning." Taking one more sip of his drink he looked at you "What about you?"
You shrugged "Same". You both stared at eachother until your faces broke out into a smile.
Soon it became custom for you to leave Yimir alone to hang out with Reiner. Every day you talked the more you felt at peace around him. Like he was home.
Yimir caught onto the pattern soon enough and blocked you before you could leave "Are you cheating on me?"
You snapped your gaze at her "Escuse me?"
Yimir aggressively took a step toward you forcing to back up "You danm right heard me. Now answer the damn question."
"No I'm not. Why would you even think that?"
"Because" snarling at you " You've been hanging out with this 'Person'" raising to quote signs in the air "More than you have with me?" Yimir raised her arms in the air slightly startling you "Hell! We haven't had breakfast together in months!"
You bit down a retort the reason we haven't had breakfast together is because you want to hang out with Historia. Choking it back you looked at her feet " I'll cancel the plans I had with my friend today."
Yimir smiled rubbing your hair "Good job seems like a reasonable choice" She walked over to the couch "You coming?"
You were having a decent day with Yimir until Historia showed up. Honestly you missed Reiner and his kind words and smiles towards you. Feeling yourself sink further into the pit you currled up on your bed and cried.
Two weeks later on your seven month anniversary Yimir pushed you to go to a party you didn't really want to go too. Fortunately for you, you found that Eren, Mikasa and Armin would be there along with Reiner.
You two only got to see each other twice a week if lucky. His engineering class never matched up with yours or Yimir held you back.
Reiner was somewhat aware of your current situation in the relationship. He wanted you to get out of it and show how your supposed to be treated.
The party was at full blast when you arrived it didn't take you long to find Armin and Mikasa. They held back Eren who was bickering with Jean. Yimir left you alone with a kiss on the cheek.
Looking around you didn't to seem to notice Reiner Sneaking up on you. "Well I seem to have found you."
Looking up your found Reiner standing above you "Looks like you have" you smiled up at him. Turning around to face him you asked "How you feeling about the party?"
He scanned the room "It's loud definitely."
Laughing you nodded "isn't always though?"
Sighing you looked around looking for you girlfriend. You smiled at Reiner "Im going to find out where my girlfriend is"
A rage flashed across his face but a polite smile replaced it quickly. "I'll talk to you later then?"
Smiling you walked past him brushing your hand against his. You felt eyes on your body and you knew who they exactly belong too. Soon enough you found your girlfriend wrapped around Historia.
You've finally snapped. Roughly grabbing Yimirs arm you tugged her along with you. She fought a little but realized it was you and let you lead her "where we going? The janitors closet? I didn't know you were that freaky?."
You turned around and snapped "I'm done"
Letting out a chuckle Yimir didn't realize you were serious "Escuse me?"
"You fucken heard me." Your hands trembled as you mustered all the strength to talk "Me and you are done"
"Like hell we are." Snarrling at you.
You laughed a bit "You now have free time to hang around your bitch."
Her eyes widen "Escuse me?" You walked past her slamming your shoulder into hers. Unfortunately for you she had one more retort something " you'll never find anyone like me."
Laughing you looked back at her "True! But that's the whole point sweet heart and I can replace you with someone better."
You left Yimir in a daze as you found Reiner. You grabbed his wrist before he could say something.
"Where are we going?"
"That's for me to know and you to found out." When you answered. You led him to the back of the building pushing him against the wall.
He was shocked as hell but loved every second of it. You looked at him right in his eyes with all the happy emotions.
"Is there a reason why your kissing me?"
You stared at him for a second "I did it. I broke up with her."
A smile reached across his lips when he realized. He shook his head happily "so we can be together?"
You smiled for the first time in a while "Not quite yet, I need the memories to be flooded away."
Reiner nodded knowing exactly what you wanted. He smiled "Let's go back to my place" Your heart raced but for once you felt whole.
