hi i want to hear your thoughts on this: ahsoka trying not to kill the clones when they were attacking her & rex on the star destroyer, vs yoda & obi-wan killing the clones outside the temple when trying to get in. i've seen people argue that bc obi & yoda did that, they never truly cared for the clones & just viewed them as soldiers, not people
[my last ask sent before i was done typing] personally i think ahsoka knew that they weren't themselves, so was trying to save them — meanwhile, obi & yoda just knew the clones turned on them and maybe thought that they willingly betrayed them & so were just acting in self defense? (i'm not entirely sure how the whole mind control & force signature thing works, does it change your force signature or-) 2/2
I heard of that argument before and frankly, that's really nitpicky. Here is the thing, their situations are extreme. Obi-Wan was shot from behind and fell from the cliff by his men then overheard how his men tying to ensure that he really died. Gree was about to shot Yoda if he didn't sense it first and act on it.
It shouldn't be even in question that they are acting in self-defense.
They don't have the luxury to stop and question why their men betray and attack them with how many things are at stake. They have to stop the signal telling Jedi to return so they could prevent more of their family dying lives are literally falling apart, stopping the sith lord that orchestrated their genocide, children live in the temple's creche (which you know when Obi-Wan and Yoda manage to get inside the temple, Obi-Wan's sad remark 'Not even the youngling survives' was they really hoping at least children lives would be spared but no.) and their men who they fought together with were literally won't hesitate shooting them. It was an extreme situation.
and I genuinely don't get why Ahsoka's action somehow means she truly cared. Did people forget before she knows the chip is a thing she literally letting Maul loose as a distraction? Then Maul literally makes a distraction that was literally just, all the same, killing the Clones without regard. That's the consequence of her actions. She put the Clones' lives in his hand. She said she wouldn't be the one who killed them after she found out about the chip but that's just a rationalization of her actions but again it was an extreme situation. Just like Yoda and Obi-wan, I won't hold it to her for making decisions that are not perfect. All of them making the best decision they could come up with the situation on hand.
But this fandom, of course, makes it about moral superiority and invalidating Jedi's care for Clones despite the various evidence. in their blind dislike for Jedi, would do anything to make sure they are always wrong. It doesn't matter for them that there is the context behind the actions if they could use anything to invalidated Jedi, they will. Forget the fact that out of the universe that ROTS was back then in 2005, when the chip is not a thing yet and the clones just mean to kill Jedi.
(Also Force SIgnature is actually a Fanon thing, not canon. They could sense things in the Force and how it feels but the concept of Force Signature itself is Fanon.)
Anyway, that take is nothing new and surprising, this fandom never stops finding things to hate on Jedi about anything they could find.