I absolutely love and am devastated by the fic overreaction, but out of curiosity, and I kinda figured so I’m sorry if this is a goofy question but does the reader dump Spencer post fic? I hope she doesn’t stay, especially after the last line about him having a reasonable explanation 🤦♀️ Spencer had me fuming, lol in my reblog I was the #1 Spencer hater because even after he sees the reader he doesn’t go to her?!? I can’t even🤦♀️ This may be petty but I hope she does and not Spencer 🙈 maybe gets with Luke too just to piss Spencer off Also, I just wanted to say you’re an amazing writer!!
Hi @midnightsgetawaycar!!
I’m so so glad you liked Overreaction and some of my other work! Thank you so much for reading and this message. Side note - not a goofy question at all and I am all for questions like this!!
The thing is, I left this fic in particular open ended so you as the reader can decide what happens! Partially because I couldn’t pick which way to go - I had multiple ideas, the two biggest below. One was more angst and the other was more hopeful.
One thought was to write a second part where reader is in surgery, having flashbacks of all the moments where Spencer chose JJ or someone else over them. It would have had Spencer outside her room where she is hooked up to monitors, looking in but not going in, and then looking at the room JJ is in and debating what to say to explain himself despite knowing he can’t. Then reader would wake up in the hospital room alone, acknowledging there wouldn’t ever be a reasonable explanation they could accept.
The more hopeful thought was a second part where Spencer talks to his mother and she says something like “JJ is a fantasy to you and you use her to escape how deeply you are in love with reader because you are terrified of being seen so completely” and then goes through different scenes where Spencer chooses reader and how important they are. It would have ended with Spencer groveling to reader in the hospital, crying while they’re still unconscious and ended with reader waking up and saying “I knew you would have a reasonable explanation”.
But really, if you want reader to end things with Spencer - then they do!! The second part is not going to be written because I enjoy when some fics are open for interpretation. (Also, your idea of Luke Alvez?? Phew, yes please.)