Haha what if Mothwing but Hawkfrost? Like Hawkfrost but Mothwing? Instead her name is Sunfrost tho
How She’d turn out below:
Sunfrost would be a bit morally gray and go down a evil streak, Tigerstar tells her to get close to Leaf and she works with Brambleclaw as they work to help their dad. What she slowly realizes is that she doesn’t have to be what everyone wants her to be, finding she feels most free and unburdened when she’s with Leaf. When Tigerstar tells her they have to get rid of Firestar she’s hesitant but can’t say no. She sets up the Foxtrap with Brambleclaw and continues on with the plan but when both siblings are standing over Firestar she can’t do it. She can’t let him die. As Brambleclaw goes finish the job she pushes him away, they wrestle across the shore both trying to knock out the other. That’s when Leaf steps out. Bramble gets out of her claws and tries to go for Leaf and that’s when Sun leaps over him to protect her, they latch into one another once more before Sunfrost pushes him right onto the stake. Leaf let’s her father out of the trap and they all stand over Brambeclaw’s body. His final words being betrayal by blood.
Sunfrost feels ashamed of what she almost did, completely confessing to Firestar and Leafpool about Tigerstar, their plan to get Brambleclaw into power and her as leader of Riverclan. While Firestar isn’t particularly happy about his own deputy trying to kill him he can see the earnest want to change in Sunfrost as she pleads for forgiveness. Soon after she retires from being a warrior and becomes a healer beside Leaf, being renamed to Sunfeather for how she changed, turning over new wings and trying to fly higher.
Her and Leaf are together and she is the parent of the three. Can’t not include Moth/SunLeaf :). Jayf is Lightfeather and named after Sunfeather, Holly is named Shadesnap and I think Lion would instead be Wildblaze after Firestar. More odd names bc I think their interesting.
Alternate names I also thought of: Eaglefrost/feather, Swirlfrost/Feather, Swanfrost/Feather, Silkfrost/Feather