So! Magus here, I ended up reading a little bit about Perenia, I must say I'm very intrigued! I indeed was going to ask a question that was solved by reading what you've already written, so that takes care of that! Basically I was going to ask about the origin of these avatars that change the seasons and how they're integrated in society (eg do they communicate with mortals or not, are they the head of a hierarchical structure etc). The oldwalker part is very interesting, and a clever way of adding a 5th "season" to the mix. Though the guy originally was, well, not exactly "good" it sounds like, I wonder if the faction nowadays still follows his ideals (seems like it, since the avatar is called Liberator by them)... and if there are Perenia-natives that joined them.
One thing to keep in mind. I believe you were lamenting the fact that if you use MtG standards, certain creatures like elves always have to be Green, aven always have to be white etc etc. It is true that this is the case in MtG, but in reality it's a veeeery flexible rule. Take humans: they can be in any color, right? But why? Just because they can learn any kind of magic? The same could be said of any species. Yes yes of course it's important to keep some distinctions between colors, Elves are Green Goblins are Red yadda yadda but in truth there's no like... 100% fact-based reason WHY a goblin MUST be red-aligned. And in fact, we DO see some divergences, once a race gets popular/big enough. Look at Tarkir, with dragons of every color (notably, with many missing Red). Look at Elves, which have become pretty much as versatile as humans in recent times (some recent examples: Delina, Ayara, Kalain, Nadier etc)... basically, don't let it be a constraint on you. You're not designing an mtg set, after all!
Thank you for your interest :D ! (And sorry for taking so long to get back to you!)
Yeah the avatars are natural phenomenons of the plane and if destroyed reform into themselves (Though that is a chaotic event and when that happened in Perenian history it took a few years for them to form and settle the cycles of the plane back to normal). The leaders of the different regions/factions take inspiration from them but yeah they do nothing to lead. I go back and forth on how I want them to interact with mortals. Part of me wants them to be so aloof they don’t even acknowledge them, part of me wants them to just behave as creatures of their type would, and part of me wants them to be very intelligent and aware of themselves, the world, and their effect on the peoples of the plane. Realistically it’s probably a mix of all three depending on the time of year.
The Oldwalker I see as a very true neutral kind of character and he definitely recruited Perenia natives to his faction (though a large faction of their starting country was indeed seeded from other planes). Nowadays his faction still follows his ideals of freedom and independence but now that the people have protection from the unpredictable and previously uncontrollable weather fluctuations they have lost a lot of, if not all of, their animosity for the four natural avatars. The other factions have more or less accepted them as a full-fledged country though the different seasons hold them with varying attitudes. The spring faction still holds a huge grudge while the winter faction has mostly forgiven them. Fall and Summer are somewhere in between.
It is true about the colors! It’s hard because part of me wants to actually make a fan-set. I even started making a bunch of cards (sadly I don’t currently have access to the computer I made them on so even though I didn’t get very far, I don’t even have what I started on Dx). But it’s true, flavor-wise I shouldn’t limit myself too much. Sometimes it will be flavor relevant, for example elves having a strong tie to green mana and that’s why they don’t live in Stillfrost or the artifact lands (uggghhh names, my bane). Most other humanoids I should try to worry less about. Mostly I’m worried about being too heavily green, but i think Perenia just leans that way (doesn’t help that it’s my favorite color….).
Thanks again for your interest and your input! And feel free to ask any more questions if you have them and I will try not to take a month to answer 😅