to no one’s surprise, irl Takeda was a gay disaster
so i was poking around the JP Shinsengumi wikipedia article, as I do, and I was looking at one of the more fascinating sections which is the /checks notes
“the five beauties of the Shinsengumi“
this always interested me for obvious reasons. Mostly the fact that all other sections are things like “commanding officers” and “accounting” and then suddenly there’s a group of men sectioned out for being hot.
This obviously relates to how homosexuality was common at the time. Not necessarily “accepted” as far as long-term partnerships, but it was understood that sometimes a guy is just that hot and it’s no big deal.
That much is obvious by the fact that Shinsengumi memoirs have pointed out how hot these particular guys are. There are a lot of interesting tidbits in here, but for the moment I’m gonna focus on the third one down, Magoshi Saburou.
According to the author Shimozawa Kan, Magoshi was, “Troubled by the incessant affections of known homosexual, Takeda Kanryuusai”, which immediately stopped my in my tracks once I read it since, so far, I still find scarcely any mention of said casual homosexuality in the Shinsengumi sources I’ve read so far, so it’s refreshing. However, this particular point may have in fact been Shimozawa’s creation, unfortunately.
However, what appears to be more solid is that Magoshi was allowed to have an easy retirement, after he was involved in the assassination of one former troop member...Takeda Kanryuusai.
Magoshi was said to have been the one that gave intel on Takeda which lead to him finally being assassinated after he left the troop on bad terms. Takeda was seen at the Satsuma manor by Magoshi, who immediately reported this to Kondou. They assumed that Takeda was leaking information about the Shinsengumi to Satsuma and arranged to have him taken out(by Saitou probably).
Afterwhich, Magoshi was regarded as a traitor, and someone who sold out their brethren. Which is said to have prompted Hijikata to give Magoshi severance and allow him to leave the Shinsengumi.
Other fun details include that, when he didn’t have patrol duty, he often walked around in a purple Kimono, with a bright smile that was “just like that of a beautiful young woman”.
but honestly the thing that entertains me the most is that absolutely none of this surprises me with what I know about Takeda from the game(i’m in the middle of Iba’s route)
Takeda is overall pretty interesting to I might do more posts about him since I suspect that he will go the way of Sannan which is, not actually touch on his interesting historical stuff and instead replace it with vampire demon nonsense.
but in the end this is just me venting my frustrations about how hakuouki insists on sidestepping all the gay stuff, despite Miki finally actually mentioning it in this game. But who knows, maybe this delicious saga of Takeda being in love with Magoshi so hard that it gets him killed will find adaptation some day! We can only hope
















