HEY I NOTICED pointing out that they whimper/moan during sex
TW!! - NSFW mentions, GN!reader but I'm most talking about the creeps, no girls bc they are confident in their moans fight me, sex noises, requested by anon💕
JEFF
"no the fuck I dont."
He does btw, when hes close to cumming and hell cover it up with degradation
But anyway
Refuses to admit to you of all people that you may have some sort of effect on him
It'd take a few weeks but he'll reluctantly end up with "yeah I do, so what? You moan like a bitch in heat when you-"
yeah he's deeeeeeep in denial
TOBY
Oh he's completely aware, a little embarrassed actually because he can get quite...loud
Especially considering the walls of the mansion are thin and he constantly feels the need to vocalize what you're doing to his body that very moment
But yeah he knows, both embaressed and proud that you can make him feel that good
EJ
I see him more as a growler, but if you catch him in a desperate bend of his heat—you might actually catch a whimper or two
"...I don't recall that."
He does actually, and he is rather glad that you bring such pleasure to him hit its still just a little humiliating when you're supposed to be the composed one
wilk probably go as far as making you moan in return if you keep teasing him about it
BEN
Embarrassed at first but quickly warms up to it, gets very cocky yet relaxed
"So what? God forbid I like you bouncing on it jeez-"
he's just a little loud, not really
Mostly whines into your neck when he's close or high out of his mind
HELEN
"I think it'd be concerning if I didn't make noises, my love."
A bit shy about it but he won't deny it, he'll brush it off as something normal
Also keeps his sounds quiet not because he's ashamed—but rather he wants to hear yours more clearly
After you're flustered enough from him describing your own sounds in detail, he'll give you a small smile—checkmate.
BRIAN
Great way to end up face down ass up tbh
He's not going to deny it per se, but he's definitely not confirming it either
Lengthens his dirty talk to prove a point
You wanted to hear him so bad, he might as well make it easier by whispering filthy things in your ear
It's a win win situation really
He gets to keep his strange pride and you get an orgasm soooooo
TIM
"so you don't like it?" / "Didn't know it was that big of a deal"
Gaslighting 3000 I tell you
Tries to make you feel bad for commenting on it
Like oh so 'you must hate him and never want him to touch you again? Gotcha' vibes
You have to make it up to him with head btw
CODY
Another one in denial, just less snarky about it
"Okay and? You're louder"
So quick to flip it back on you
Like yeah he whimpers when he finishes but you came untouched so beat that
Queue moaning wars for the next time you have sex: who's louder than who
LJ
"I didn't think you'd notice with all the moaning you do yourself sweetie!"
kinda happy you found out, very full of himself because he knows he sounds pretty
Not one inch of insecure, just horny and proud
SLENDER
The most you're getting from him is like a subliminal, low vibration growl that makes your bones feel funny
But this is fiction so let's mess with it
When you initially bring it up he's rather interested, and asks you to prove your points (where, when, how loud)
And of course right then a thick static blankets your thoughts and you almost forget why you're standing in front of the Eldritch being in the first place
Characters: Jeff the Killer, Ticci Toby, BEN Drowned, Eyeless Jack, X Virus, Tim/Masky, Brian/Hoodie
Literally nobody requested this I just wanted to do it LMAO
NSFW below the cut!
Jeff
☠︎︎ Jeff is always teasing you like the smug little asshole he is
☠︎︎ this time it involved taking your weapon
☠︎︎ cue very cliche flirting while holding it out of your reach
☠︎︎ except you weren’t having it all
☠︎︎ so you tackled him
☠︎︎ once you were both on the ground the situation really just devolved from there
☠︎︎ you managed to pin him down and straddle him, but he was still holding it as far away as he could
☠︎︎ so you ended up doing a little bounce motion while trying to reach for it without getting off of him
☠︎︎ Jeff immediately notices this and drops the weapon
☠︎︎ his hands fly to your hips and grinds you down hard
☠︎︎ “if you wanted to ride me you should’ve just said so”
☠︎︎ you’re absolutely mortified and try to get away but he grips your arms and pulls you down onto him even more
☠︎︎ you’re not going anywhere now
Toby
✘ Toby is so fucking feral for dry humping noooo
✘ like especially missionary dry humping
✘ he just loves to hold you down, get in between your legs and grind himself against you
✘ He does this in any situation where he can’t fuck you right then
✘ like if you guys are on the way back from a mission and you move in such a way (unintentionally) that gets him riled up it’s over
✘ he’s pushing you to the ground in the woods
✘ and truly, if he had it his way he’d fuck you right then and there but when you whine and protest he relents
✘ but not fully
✘ god he would be so desperate and lowkey almost whiny
✘ like just grinding himself into you and picturing you all exposed and spread open for him
✘“Fuck, I wanna be inside you so fucking bad, mein Mädchen.”
✘he doesn’t stop until a) he’s so frustrated himself that the only option is rushing you back home so he can bury himself inside you or b) he comes in his pants
Ben
⚠︎ Ben uses sex as a weapon LMAO
⚠︎ so he’s really only dry humping to tease you, to deny you of what you really want
⚠︎ what did you do to deserve it? Nothing really, he just likes to deprive you
⚠︎ but he won’t just let you sit and grind for a bit
⚠︎ no, Ben makes you do it for hours
⚠︎ he’ll have you straddle him and force you to keep your hands on his chest
⚠︎ “Yeah, that’s it. Move those hips. Show me how bad you want it.”
⚠︎ and at this point you’re damn near sobbing because you’ve already came more times than you can count and your clit feels almost raw from the friction but you just need him inside you so bad
⚠︎ “hmmm… just give me two more and I might consider fucking you.”
Jack
𖤐Jack fucking loves dry humping
𖤐 mostly because his cock is too big and he is too strong for his own good
𖤐 so he’s always scared of hurting you
𖤐 and after a particularly rough encounter, he refused to fuck you for weeks
𖤐 not because he didn’t want to, but because he felt so bad about hurting you, and he didn’t want to mess up again
𖤐 so instead he has you straddle his lap, wearing nothing but your panties
𖤐 he’s guiding your hips with his hands and kissing your neck UGH
𖤐 “you’re doing so good baby, just like that.”
𖤐 you can feel his big bulge under you and you’re begging for him to fuck you
𖤐 but he does not give into temptation because he knows what’s best for you
𖤐 plus he really does like watching you move your hips on top of him, especially since when he fucks you it’s almost always him doing most if not all the work (completely of his own doing)
X Virus
☣︎ You knew Cody was working and it was better to not interrupt him
☣︎ but that’s no fun at all
☣︎ so you sit on his lap
☣︎ “what the hell do you think you’re doing?”
☣︎ you continue being a massive distraction, wiggling around in his lap until you can hear his breathing start to pick up
☣︎ when you decide to start grinding your ass back and forth on his clothed cock, that’s when he snaps
☣︎ suddenly you’re bent over his lab bench and his hand is gripping your hair, holding your face down
☣︎ and he’s holding your arms behind your back with his other hand
☣︎ Your skirt rode up when he bent you over and he’s so fucking hard pressed against your thinly clothed cunt
☣︎ “This is what you wanted, huh?”
☣︎ and when you’re too embarrassed to answer he starts grinding his cock against you
☣︎ “What’s wrong, slut? You wanted to be a distraction. C’mon, pull down your panties.”
Tim/Masky
꩜ lowkey, I don’t think he’d be all that into it
꩜ not a dry humping truther
꩜ he would likely only do it for a little bit as a tease and then he’s getting straight down to business
꩜ unless you really liked it then he would have you do it on top of him
꩜ he’d move your hips with his hands, making sure you don’t go too fast and keeps your movements at a steady pace
꩜ “don’t get too excited, you can keep it steady, I know you can.”
꩜ but even then he can only take it for so long
☆ Masky does the type of dry humping where he bends you over and pounds you through the clothes
☆ To the point where it kinda hurts a bit
☆ And it’s always a punishment
Brian/Hoodie
𖣐 Brian been a dry humping supporter since day 1
𖣐 loves to do it anywhere, anytime
𖣐 but especially in situations where it can get you guys in trouble unfortunately
𖣐 like you guys are watching a movie with everyone and you’re sitting in his lap
𖣐 and you feel him start to subtly grind your hips onto him
𖣐 you know better than to fight it because he will quickly make it known to you who’s in charge
𖣐“Just be a good girl for me and keep quiet.”
𖣐 And he gets you all riled up until you have to make an excuse to leave the room and then he follows after you a few minutes later
☹ Hoodie doesn’t do dry humping he’s straight up just slipping it into you while you guys are watching a movie or sitting on the couch
☹ He does not give a single fuck who’s around
☹ If anything, you might try to initiate it for a moment but even just one roll of your hips and it’s over because now you’re getting his cock inside you
Personal word vomit: idk why this one took me so long😞💔 sowwy guys ALSO THANK YOU FOR 777 followers (I kinda skipped over 666, but knock on wood!) this is so cool😛 Read Part 1 HERE
Featuring: Jeff The Killer / Jeffrey Woods, Eyeless Jack, X-Virus / Cody
CW: nsfw, fem!reader, p in v sex, established relationships, implied unprotected sex, different positions described, fingering, cunnilingus, nipple play, dirty talk, teasing/edging, not proof read, written by a non-naitive english speaker
༘⋆ Jeff
✦ "WHAT DO YOU MEAN JUST THE TIP?"
✦ Genuinely thinks you've lost your mind. Jeff has the sex drive of a horny teenager who has just discovered the glorious feeling of jacking off — Best believe he can't go two days without fucking you or at least masturbating to the thought of you in like ten different positions. Obviously, he still wouldn't overstep any boundaries and if you say "just the tip" then it also meant "just the tip". It'll be hard for him to stop himself from sinking into your pussy even deeper once he even touches you, but okay, challenge accepted.
✦ Jeff quickly changed his mind, though — If he can't properly fuck you, he'll eat you out then. He'll have you on your back and looking all pretty on his bed, lips all red and slightly swollen from making out for the past hour-or-so, while he undresses you: "Shh, don't worry, babe, let me do it," Jeff said, which was a little out of character. Usually, he'd be the lazy one, the one who'd just lie down and let you do all the work (He did love watching you ride his cock, though). His lips wrapped around your, already sensitive, nipple, flicking his tongue over it until you mewled under him. Honestly, you were enjoying the sudden princess treatment.
✦ And when he said he'll eat you out, you can be damn sure he'll do it properly. Jeff can be a munch if he wants to be, which might not be often, but when he goes down on you he'll give you the best orgasm on earth. You can't quite put your finger on what it is exactly.. Maybe it's the way his thumb rubs slow, delicious circles on your clit, putting on just the right pressure that has you purring, or the way he never fails to find your g-spot ever single time when he curls his fingers, plunging in and out of your pussy in a brutal pace. Your favorite thing is when Jeff starts making out with your wet folds, moaning and groaning and sweet talking your pussy, because she obviously also deserved princess treatment.
✦ In the end "Just the tip" wasn't even that bad. Not bad at all, even. "Enjoyed yourself?" Your boyfriend asked after kissing up your bare body once he made you cum on his face for the third time that evening. You made eye contact with his sea blue eyes, pupils blown out from the pleasure like he was pussy drunk. "Yeah... I think you've earned it now."
༘⋆ EJ
✦ Jack thought you're joking. He doesn't really get it when you're being sarcastic sometimes, so he figured this was one of those times — But no, he quickly realized you were being serious when you repeated it. "Why?" he asked you straight up, confusion etched onto his features.. since when did you want something like that? Just yesterday you were moaning and screaming for his dick, begging him to go harder, faster, harder, faster— what happened in those 24 hours?
✦ You can be sure, though, that EJ is one of the few creeps where this'll work. He has crazy self-control over his needs and wants and if his sweet girlfriend wants "just the tip" then so be it. He does think you'll probably crack in under ten seconds anyway — Not that he wants you to (He definitely wants you to), it just seems like you want to tease him and are now too deep into the joke to pull out. Haha pull out, get it?
✦ Actually, you thought just the tip of his cock was enough to get that mind-shattering, stretched out feeling you loved so much. More often than not, especially in the beginning when you guys started to sleep together, did it hurt whenever you tried to sink your pussy down on him (You immediately needed to jump his bones when seeing him shirtless for the first time... come on, who doesn't want to ride the shit out of Eyeless Jack?). Times were certainly crazy whenever EJ was so much in heat, so caught up in the moment, that he'd just start carelessly thrusting into you erratically, his tip kissing your cervix over and over and over again.. You couldn't walk for days.
✦ "Just the tip" works really well with EJ, and he didn't realize he would like it so much. He'd slot himself between your thighs, kiss you senseless all the while he'd slip his cock in and out of your pussy, occasionally bumping against your clit. It send shots of pleasure directly to your brain, making you moan and cry out for him even louder than normal. "Jack stop teasing, pleaaaaase ohmygod just fuck me already!" Ah well, he called it.
༘⋆ Cody
✦ "Uhhhh, okay!"
✦ Will probably not even overthink it. You said it immediately after watching a movie turned into Cody slipping his hand under your shirt and a heavy make-out session, just to see how he'd react. Truth is, Cody doesn't have a problem with anything like that — Maybe you're just not feeling it? He's on the softer side and is definitely more considerate than a lot of other creeps, so it was obvious that he'd just agree.
✦ Now you needed to see how long you could take this. Suprisingly, Cody took this like really seriously — You were quite touched by how careful he was being with you, like you could break if he made one wrong move. You truly are his pillow princess, all sprawled out on his bed and you deserved only the best: Long, slender fingers dragged themselves over your bare stomach, down to your, already slick, folds. Your eyes closely followed your boyfriends moves, your breathing quickening whenever his fingers ghosted right over your clit.. the more Cody teased, the more you thought this was a stupid idea.
✦ Alright shit, it seemed like he was onto you now. "Just the tip"? Haha yeah suuuuure, as if you could actually handle that. Cody leaned his forehead against your temple, eyeing your face curiously. His lips found your jaw, kissing along your hot skin while he removed his jeans: "Help me, sweetheart?" He asked in that teasing tone he always had. He absolutely knew you couldn't resist him like that.
✦ All in all, "Just the tip" could definitely work from his side... the question is if you can. Cody definitely has enough restraint, and enough respect for you, which is a huuuuge green flag. He does enjoy pounding you into the mattress though, so don't try to joke with him like that — He will drag foreplay out until you can't do it anymore, leaving you frustrated and basically aching for more.
