So, you basically want Alastor to be like a scarier Discord or cartoonish Raymond Reddington? I can get behind that. (This is about your post saying you want Alastor to still be evil but the main cast is the exception thing.
Idk Raymond Reddington and it's been years since I watched MLP but yeah basically!
I just don't want him to be defanged completely. It's fun that he's kind of terrifying! If he does get nicer I think it would be fun if he kept some of that dangerous, chaotic energy. YES he is here because he likes you guys, YES he is now sincerely trying to encourage people to seek redemption, NO he is not safe.
It's like having an old pet tiger. Yes they don't attack you, yes they spend most of their time sleeping in the sun these days, but that doesn't mean there's not the potential for anything horrible still.
I could see Charlie being like why don't we try a different solution that's not eating someone first and he's just like sighs. if you insist, my dear. he likes her genuinely now but he's still a fucked up little freak












