Voluntary Surrender: How VWFS Turned My Exit Into a Credit Nightmare
Opening Hook
I thought I was making a responsible choice. Downsizing after a salary cut, balancing my dad’s medical bills, and trying to avoid default. Instead, I walked straight into a system that treats voluntary surrender like repossession and punishes you for playing by the rules.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Story
Changed jobs, took a salary cut, car payments became unsustainable.
Reached out to VWFS early in 2025 for options. No real help.
Asked again, this time clear: I wanted to sell the car but needed help with the shortfall.
VWFS offered only “voluntary surrender” under Section 127 of the National Credit Act. Warned it would mark my credit profile but no clarity on duration.
Took the hit. Got a valuation from WeBuyCars, completed the Section 127 form, sold the car to WeBuyCars.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Where It Went Wrong
VWFS treated my voluntary surrender like a repossession.
Their system reported me as “behind on payments” even though I was paying the agreed shortfall every month.
A consolidation loan application was rejected because my credit report showed “missed payments.”
VWFS admitted their system does not distinguish between repossession and voluntary surrender.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The Bigger Problem
Section 127 was designed to give consumers a structured, lawful way to exit credit agreements without repossession. But if credit providers misreport these cases, the law’s intent is undermined. Instead of protection, you get punished twice:
A voluntary surrender marker on your profile.
False arrears reporting that blocks future credit.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Why This Matters
Accuracy is the law: Section 70 of the NCA requires credit providers to report information that is accurate and not misleading.
Systemic flaw: If VWFS’s systems cannot distinguish repossession from voluntary surrender, every consumer who takes this route risks being misrepresented.
Real impact: I did the responsible thing but my credit profile tells a different story.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Closing Call
If you are considering voluntary surrender, know this: the system may not treat you fairly. And if you have already gone down this road, check your credit report because you might be carrying a false arrears record.
I have raised my case with the bureaus, but this is not just about me. It is about a system that needs fixing. Section 127 should protect consumers, not punish them twice.
On a more personal note. I have owned five Volkswagens since brand new, starting with my Citi Golf in 2003. After this experience, I have promised myself: never again a VW from VWSA and VWFS.