because im very curious: what is the difference between a regular tickling vs a punishment tickling? (with you)
OK since you're very curious and because you used that colon so nicely:
Punishment is meant to be a deterrent. It is an experience so unpleasant you don't want to go through it again. Washing your mouth out with soap. Kneeling on rice. Writing lines (handwriting the same sentence again and again hundreds of times). (I'm not commenting on the ethics of actually using these as punishments outside of a kink context, just giving examples).
Normally as a top you want to build experiences the bottom does want to have again, because you want to play with them again (obviously). So even if it's a torture scene, you'd want to construct it skillfully so it's a positive experience taken as a whole. You would want to think about things like pacing, dynamism, personal connection, building and removing intensity in a meaningful arc (having a beginning, middle, and end). Variety of technique, building expectations and either paying off or subverting them, mixing pleasure and suffering, controlling the bottom's focus. It's like you're directing a movie. And even with the most masochistic masochists you want to give them that, because it shows your skill and conscientiousness.
Punishment is not that. Take the example of writing lines. There's no payoff to writing lines, no dynamism, no connection between top and bottom, no skill being demonstrated. It's just monotonous and it hurts your hand.
The only reason a bottom would agree to be punished is if there is some meta-level benefit or meaning gained. In BDSM classically, that probably means they are submissive, and the punishment builds on a longer-term relationship between the submissive and dominant. Like: I punish you, it sucks, it makes you want to obey me more, it makes you feel more controlled, it makes you feel conditioned not to do other things, maybe it makes you feel like a child, ... and those feelings (which are feelings you want, hypothetically) are the purpose.
I'll be honest: I've received punishments as a submissive myself, but I have not given punishments. I feel experienced as a sadist/top/ler, but I don't have experience as a dominant in a longterm D/s dynamic. It's not that I don't want it. And I think I'd be good at it. But I just haven't found that in the right way with the right person at the right time.
So if I describe to you what punishment tickling would be like with me, it's something I'm imagining, within a relationship I desire.
It would need to be with a lee who is very ticklish, who finds tickling unbearable at baseline. It would be monotonous: I would find a horribly ticklish spot and repeatedly tickle that spot as long as possible without desensitizing, to just create maximum suffering over the maximum length of time. Then I'd switch to another spot and mercilessly tickle there. Then maybe I'd go back to the first spot. It would be mind-numbing, the kind of repetition where you lose track of the number of times you've returned to the same thing, which makes it feel eternal. I would not vary technique; I would relentlessly drill into the lee's worst spots in the most unpleasant way possible for them. I would not be playful. Just heartless. I would use every single tool at my disposal to make the tickling as bad as possible. I would try to make it an experience the lee never wants to have again. Truly never.
What would I get out of that? It would be hard for me too, in some ways. I myself might get bored, and I'd need to push through that in service of the D/s. My hands might get tired and I'd need to persevere. But one thing that I'd like very much would be seeing the lee have a bad experience that they hate, seeing it crush their soul as the hours drag on, watching them become a shell of a human, robotically laughing as their reflexes are exploited nonstop. Hearing them honestly beg me to stop and knowing they fully mean it and that there's not a shred of anything enjoyable in it for them. Just completely breaking them. Taking their fetish and wringing out everything they like about it. Not hot for them at all.
And I'd like them knowing this was happening because they were bad. :) I'd like to tell them they were bad, and that they deserve this. I'd like to see the effect that has on them psychologically. And I'd like to see how it changes our relationship and how they feel about me as a ler.










