HellooOoOo Steph! Maybe this is out of nowhere, but I've seen that you've been in this fandom for a long and I want to know your opinion on the way it ended. I mean, the creators, the actors, people from the crew seem to be very open about Johnlock, but after S3 everything changed. Do you think something happened? or everything was for the play? :/ (PD. Thank you for your amazing blog! You're doing amazing<3)
Ah, I've actually talked about this in a few posts before:
Do you think we’ll ever get an S5 (Dec. 31/19)
Do I Think S5 is still a possibility?
Do You think there will be an S5 and was it Queerbaiting? (Mini master post)
What would You like to see in S5?
What do I think about the rumours of S5? (July 2021)
Is there confirmation of S5?
Watching S4 Made me Sadder (discussion about fandom and the future of the series)
about the hiatus, do you think the show would ever return?
The long-short of it is this, and THIS IS MY OPINION, NOT FACT, just speculation based on what I see/read and gossip, so PLEASE take it with a grain of salt:
I think that Ben and Martin were led to believe, right up until TAB, that the show was going in the direction the rest of us thought it was. Martin seemed proud to be doing the series and proud to be "confirmed" a bisexual Watson. They were VERY disappointed in what they got instead. I think Martin was MORE pissed off because they essentially turfed the character he worked very hard to develop.
There was gossip post-S4 that AA had a lot to do with S4's fuckery. Word is that she wanted to be rocketed into stardom the same way the whole series did for Ben and Martin, so she got chummy with MG and SM, and that's why she features so heavily in the season even though she's "dead". I'm a bit 50/50 on this gossip, only because post-S3, she seemed really to want to be a villain that Mofftiss were setting her up to be in HLV. BUT I think there's merit in the rumour that she had a hand in Mary's death scene in T6T... At the time of filming, AA and MF were going through a then-unknown messy split, so she was basically forcing MF to mourn her and John's marriage and Mary's death. Looking at the rest of the season with this in mind, and with how much John was fucked over in S4... I can kind of believe it, but again, this was the gossip going around at the time, and NOT PROVEN.
That all said, I think EVERYONE aside for MG and SM were blindsided with S4. So I lean more heavily to MG and SM's ego fucking up S4.
Though, I do think SOMETHING corporate may have happened behind-the-scenes between TAB and S4. I believe there was a changeover at the BBC around that time, so that may have had an effect.
Another rumour that was going around was that the (supposed) holders of the remaining copyrights on the Holmes IP saw what was going on with TAB, and didn't like the implied Johnlock (this has been a back and forth discussion that's been had here in the past, and has great insight from people more educated than me and corrected me on things I erred on, so do read this post).
This is my saltiest take of the whole thing: Mofftiss were PISSED the fandom figured out TAB before it aired, despite putting ALL the clues there. Prior to TAB airing, it was well known that they kind of had a love-hate relationship with the fandom that they cultivated, but because that fandom made them money, they played into it. Because I suspect they don't think good story-telling means that the audience should be able to pick out clues to predict the ending (which is kind of the whole POINT of foreshadowing), they instead changed their story, retconned the whole series, all for the sake of multiple "twists" no one could ever predict. And without a third writer to reign them in, their egos went through the roof after TAB was critically praised and awarded. Essentially, Mofftiss got too full of themselves. It's well-known that they were doing rewrites literally a day or two before filming each episode. However, when S4 got panned from the audience they were INSTEAD trying to cater to (ie anyone BUT the multiple branches of fandom), they instead took their ball and went home and blamed the fans for it being bad, and it took months for them to finally admit to queerbaiting. AND they won't ever confirm if the series is done because Sherlock the Brand™ still gets them money (ie the Escape Room that is exclusive to people who pay them to see the additional content) Basically: Mofftiss were just big man-babies about the fandom itself..
So yeah, anyway. That's my thoughts on it all. And again, PLEASE know that it's ALL GOSSIP AND SPECULATION, and barely anything has ever been proven. Post-S4, those of us who stayed did a lot of it to try to make sense of what happened.
And don't take any of what I said the wrong way: I still love Sherlock and I still love the show, and I do still have hope for another Season. I'm just... at peace?... with if it never happens, because honestly, I love the fandom and I love what came OUT of the dumpsterfire of S4: art, meta, fanfiction, poetry and prose... I try to look on the brighter side of it all.
If anyone has anything to add, please do. I do like some gossip, LOL.