What are your favorite and least favorite Hamlet adaptations and why? By the way, sorry if I end up spamming your inbox, I just really love how you always seem so into Shakespeare (more than most people I know) and willing to discuss this kind of stuff with p much anyone!
no problemo comrade, I am super into shakespeare and I will talk about it all day so by asking about it really you’re just saving my flatmates from it
okay well least favourite is so easy, the mel gibson was trash. so fucking trash. I liveblogged it when I watched it but I can’t find the post now?? but anyway omg the cuts are so fucked up and the oedipal thing is everywhere and mel gibson is so bad and horatio might as well not even be there and just oh god what a mess. I wish someone had given helena bonham carter a chance to properly play ophelia tho because she was like the only good thing about that film
best adaptation is much harder!! the gregory doran (david tennant) version was the first one I watched so obviously I’m very biased towards it. tennant is great, the cinematography is great, all the actors convey the text beautifully, and seriously peter de jersey as horatio is so much. I love him.
hamlet at elsinore is amazing, I honestly love christopher plummer as hamlet so much, tennant must have watched this version because his hamlet is very clearly drawn from plummer’s. plummer gives such a young hamlet, he’s so vibrant and his aesthetic is on point, he is almost exactly how I visualise hamlet, the closest film version anyway (apart from asta nielsen, but we’ll get to her). I love a lot of things about this version but the one I’m gonna highlight here because I’m a parody of myself is michael caine as horatio like seriously oh god I’m gonna cry just thinking about it. the tragic danish boyfriends in this version is too much for my poor heart
and the other forerunner for favourite version is the campbell scott version, which is so so so much better than an american tv film has any right to be. I really love scott’s interpretation of hamlet, it was so untheatrical and nuanced and the only hamlet I’ve seen that kept this strain of irony and princeliness from before his dad died throughout the whole play. I wrote a long post about this version when I finished it here which explains all my feelings but the tl;dr is this version is amazing
and I cannot write this post without mentioning asta nielsen’s silent interpretation of hamlet, which has nielsen playing hamlet as a woman raised and dressed as a man. it’s so interesting and the whole aesthetic is so! on! point!! hamlet should look like asta nielsen okay. also hamlet/horatio is REAL and STRONG there is this adorable seen where they meet at wittenburg and my poor trash heart cannot handle it. it’s not a straightforward version but it’s amazing please watch it