#1789: “Before 1845, the bases on a baseball field were arranged in U-shape. Posts or stakes were used instead of bases as we know them, runs were called "aces," and the first team to reach a score of 21 won the game. Even by 1860 baseball was more a social event than a competitive sport. Tea was served during the many "intermissions," and the pitcher threw the ball where the batter asked him to. Bunting was considered a breach of taste.”
False. False. True. Kind of true. Plausible?
Up until the 1870s, base ball was more of a “gentleman’s sport,” played as friendly competition, so some of this may be plausible. Runs were called aces.
I found an article detailing a letter from Dr. Adam Ford, who witnessed a baseball game in Canada in 1838. He wrote that the infield was in a square shape (predecessor to today’s diamond? Definitely not a U-shape!) and bags were used for the bases, called byes. Bases were then the lines between the byes. When Ford watched the game, players agreed on how many innings to play- usually between 5 and 9. He spoke to some older men there, who played eighteenth-century era baseball, and they said in their day, they played to whichever team got 18 or 21 first. So the form of baseball described here may be from eighteenth-century Canada. This letter is the oldest-known testimony about early baseball, and there’s evidence baseball was known in Ontario at that time. For what it’s worth, some people are suspicious of this letter because Dr. Ford was seven when he watched this game and was reporting fifty-year-old memories.
The material the ball was made of also changed. In the game Dr. Ford watched, the baseball was made of yarn and wrapped in calfskin. He also wrote of a game in New York State using a baseball of India rubber that had the ball flying extremely far.