Bizarrely, this is something Jacques does better than Willis. Compare DOA-Carla to Claire. Carla has no depth of character except A) She's proudly, loudly trans, B) She likes annoying people. Aside from that, we know next to nothing about her. (1)
Claire, meanwhile, is a librarian, slightly nerdy, cares about her brother, wants to get piercings, and so much else - and we knew thus before it was established she was trans. There’s nothing wrong with having a character be proud of (2)their identity, and unapologetically vocal about it. But it’s bad storytelling when that’s where the character’s development ends. In fact, it’s almost detrimental to positive representation when all you’re doing is just aggressive representation.Hell, even Moffat understands that! He’s brought in gay, Muslim, PoC, disabled characters who actually have a stake in the story and a deeper history.Not to mention the “this is who I am, go fuck yourself” while the opponent silently, frustratedly frowns moment is a trope much more common in Chick tracts than most other media. e.
I have a homework assignment for you, and I want all of you to really try this.
Describe the following webcomics characters WITHOUT saying what they look like, their costume, and their profession/role. Describe this character as if talking to your friend who’s never read the comic. (If you don’t know the comic, you can skip). Only spend about a minute or two per character.
1. Vriska Serket (Homestuck)
2. Miko Miyazaki (Order of the Stick)
3. Isabel Guerra (Paranatural)
4. Becky MacIntyre (Dumbing of Age)
6. Carla Rutten (Dumbing of Age)
7. Zimmy (Gunnerkrigg Court)
9. Peggy Farrow (Legend of the Hare)
10. Jill Leverett (Legend of the Hare)
11. Kimiko Ross (Dark Science)
13. Artie (Narbonic and its spin-offs)
14. Suria (The Rock Cocks)
15. Penny (Lucky Penny/Johnny Wander)
16. Aranea Serket (Homestuck)
17. Claire Augustus (Questionable Content)