Violent Sports vs. Enthusiastic Geeks
Between reading Shawnee Barton’s “As a Female NFL Fan, I Want a Better Stadium Experience – Not a Pink Jersey” and watching Trekkies (1997), an individual gets two very different yet similar views of events taking place in large and public settings. These similar yet contrasting views highlight the distinction made between types of fans and leads an individual into examining how two very similar events can lead to two entirely different experiences for female fans.
The atmosphere of the convention in Trekkies was very similar to that of a football stadium during a game: filled with enthusiastic fans, people clamoring to see the game (or booths or actors, in the case of the Trekkie convention), and people showing their passion for the event. The events were extremely different – one that is considered geeky and one that is considered “manly” – and yet the fans showed their enthusiasm in similar ways by dressing up to show their support for their favorite team or actor and showcasing their knowledge of the event. At this point, though, the differences begin to show through. In Trekkies, the viewer sees people of all ages roaming the convention, not just adults, and no beer is present, or rather, beer is not explicitly shown on screen if it is present. Also not seen are adults yelling insults or curses at each other as can be seen at a football, or any sporting, event. In her article, Barton very specifically describes the beer and violence, either physical or verbal, present at the football stadium in her experience. When Barton went to her last football game, “a 20-something guy standing directly in front of [her] in line beat two older men to a point in which an ambulance was called” (Barton) due to fighting over their places in the beer line. This sort of physical violence is not present, or not explicitly shown, at the Trekkie convention in Trekkies. This stark contrast in environments leads viewers of both the article and the movie to the conclusion that sporting events, such as football games, are not suitable for children whereas geeky conventions are fitting for families because sports fans are more concerned with beer and physicality than geeky fans.
One aspect in which the sports stadium and the Trekkies convention are similar in, however, is the sexualization of females. Both events have very different attire for females when compared to men. In the movie, the females are wearing costumes, if they are in costume, that emphasize cleavage and their figure, more so than the costumes of the males. Barton infers that “the [NFL’s] efforts to market logo-ed lingerie and pink gear to women” (Barton) is furthering the negative stigma against female sports fans. The overly feminine coloring and shaping of newer NFL merchandise is leading to female sports fans being discriminated against or judged in different ways than the male sports fans. The stigma against females is different in both environments. In the context of the sports atmosphere, the females are taken less seriously than the males because they choose to wear girly clothing whereas in the context of the geeky convention atmosphere, the females are just seen as regular fans. There really did not seem to be a negative connotation to females in overly feminine or sexual clothing when compared to what Barton described.
While both environments have similarities, there are enough differences that females might feel comfortable in one atmosphere over the other. Barton clearly describes how females might feel threatened or unsafe in a sports atmosphere but Trekkies lacks this conclusion, in a way. The movie showcases fans enjoying a high-energy atmosphere and bonding over a shared interest whereas Barton describes an environment where females might not be comfortable being due to the stigma against females in that area.
"Trekkies (1997)." IMDb. IMDb.com. Web. 15 Feb. 2016.
Barton, Shawnee. 2013. “As a Female NFL Fan, I Want a Better Stadium Experience – Not a Pink Jersey.” The Atlantic, September 25. http://www.theatlantic.com/entertainment/archive/2013/09/as-a-female-nfl-fan-i-want-a-better-stadium-experience-not-a-pink-jersey/279915/.