A Court of Thorns and Roses (A Book Review)
Summary
In a world divided by Faeries and Humans, Feyre is taken from the Human realm to Faerie territory after she killed one of their own. In this world with creatures she’s only heard terrible things about, she has to live the rest of her life away from her family. While there, the worst thing isn’t her punishment for killing a Faerie, but a blight threatening to destroy the Faerie land of her captor, Tamlin, and the Human realm. Is it possible for Feyre to save both? With love and determination, she’s going to try.
Expectation
I imagined myself loving this series and I was worried about that because I heard a lot of backlash. Yet I still wanted to read it for myself. Plenty of people swear by this book, promising an amazing read, but because I heard that this is a problematic series, I was scared of being on the side that ignored the issues. Scared that I would like the problematic stuff or be completely oblivious to it. Regardless, I expected to rave over this book and give 5 stars.
Reality
I’m not raving over this book. I feel it was great to read, but possibly for me, it was overhyped. I think the fantasy, the world, the possibilities are 5 stars, but in the beginning, even though the book wasn’t boring, I was struggling to read multiple pages which could be from a book slump or lack of enthusiasm for reading a fantasy at the time, but I managed to finish. I heard the sex scenes are graphic and thrilling, so I counted down the chapters for those. I’ve heard non-spoiler critiques of this book and I honestly didn’t see much wrong with it in the sense of it being a problematic book. I was bracing myself for rape and racism, which I now feel is the reason I would put this book down for long periods of times. I was putting holding off the possibilities of having to read these things. There was a sprinkle of rape culture, but it was never shown positively. The reader would know its negative impact on the main character right away. There was sex in this book and intimate moments, but I saw the consent. As for race, I noticed the descriptions of people of color. One character was described like bark wood or something another and I got offended because Feyre said that character wasn't beautiful and this was pretty much the first description of someone who wasn’t just pale or tan. But I moved on from it. Feyre is in no way a feminist icon, which is another critique I heard from people. Apparently Feyre does things that are unlike a true feminist. I read this book and saw a strong woman who is capable of holding her own based on no one else’s values but her own. Feyre is sexual, she’s a protector, she’s caring, smart, determined, stubborn, and knows what she wants and what she wants to do. I saw nothing incriminating of this book, which makes me believe I stressed over it for nothing and could have enjoyed the book more. Now that I think about it, I think all the bad critique was possibly for the 2nd book. I’m going to continue the series, but for the first book, I feel very comfortable giving ACOTAR 3 stars.
















