Book Review: THE TOSS OF A LEMON by Padma Viswanathan
“She had always thought of her life as a series of submissions to God. What if she has been making her own decisions all along?”
India, 1896.
Ten-year-old Sivakami is married to Hanumarathnam, a respected healer and astrologer. The marriage is a happy one, and they become parents to their beautiful daughter Thangam and ambitious son Vairum. But a shadow hangs above it all-- Hanumarathnam has long known that his horoscope foretells his own death in the tenth year of his marriage. When the worst comes true, Sivakami adapts to the traditions and customs expected of widows, save for one act of rebellion...she does not stay to live with her family, but decides to raise her children in her husband’s house. What follows is an expansive tale, unpacking several generations of Sivakami’s descendants as Indian independence and political tension looms.
I found this novel in an old book sale a few months ago, and I’m super glad I stumbled across it! A little over a decade old now, The Toss of a Lemon is Viswanathan’s debut novel. It’s an ambitious, expansive undertaking of over 600 pages; the story’s timeline spills over many decades, and has a huge cast. There’s really not a singular core storyline, which makes for an unusual (but intriguing!) reading experience. Without the traditional building action and resolution, this novel reads more like a blurred anthology of stories. I had hoped for more focus on the storyline of Muchami, one of the novel’s main characters; he is the lifelong servant of Sivakami, and his experiences as a gay man during this time-frame interested me, but were largely glossed over or merely implied. In any case, this remains an excellent case study of a large family’s episodes of love and loss in a period of immense change in India.
More of my reviews
Author’s website











