Once You Lose Your Heart || Maggie and Penelope (chatzy)
Maggie felt a little tense, a little nervous, a little confused, a little frustrated....a lot of little things but no one large collective emotion was driving her right now. She just knew that she had to have this talk. Since her conversation with Estela she had been mulling things over, trying to explore what exactly her sentiments and feelings were. The problem was this was all entirely new to her, and confusion flooded her mind in a fog that made it very difficult for her to organise her thoughts clearly. There was one thing that was consistent however; that as much as she knew she had to talk this through with Pen, she prayed to God that no matter what happened it wouldn't change things between them. That through her own stupid confusing, well, heart, that something she truly treasured on an entirely platonic level would not in turn be sacrificed. She knocked lightly on the door, but so regular was her habit of visiting Pen, that as usual she didn't wait for an invitation before she creaked open the door and peeped around with a smile. “Just me.”
Penelope smiled up at Maggie from her desk. After the events of last night, or the astounding lack thereof, she hadn't quite been able to summon the effort to attempt happiness for anyone. At least, anyone but Maggie. The woman could get a block of stone to blush, she was sure of it. Raising her chin and forcing a little more brigtness in her demeanour than she felt, Penelope stood and waved her friend in. "It's good to see you," she said softly. She came around from her desk and greeted Maggie by slipping an arm about her and shutting the door behind them. "Where would you like to sit? And what is all of this about anyways?"
Maggie smiled and took the arm the same way she always did, and was pleased to find her recent Estela-induced revelations did not prevent her enjoying such a simple thing on the purely innocent level it was intended. It gave her hope, that no matter what, things could go back to the way they were. At least they could for Maggie...but would they for Pen? She looked at her friend and realised she had absolutely no idea how she was going to take this information, but she also realised she had no choice. She had to speak with her about it. “Anywhere that's comfy,” She replied, “Although,” She lifted the sparkling ballet flat on her foot, like Cinderella at the ball, “I have to say everything got a lot comfier after I put these on.” She let Pen lead her to her a seat as she decided how to explain the conversation, how to start it, “And well....it's...it's about, well, admittedly, it's a little confusing actually. And I'm sure you'll agree on that.”
Penelope lead her friend back to her desk and pulled the seat situated opposite over to the side. Maggie only seemed a little distressed, perhaps more things with Dani that she didn't understand or something of that nature, but there was still personel to manage, emails to be sent, reports and reviews to stort through. For her part, Penelope resumed her seat, a little more relaxed than she had been before, and listened to Maggie with her usual sympathetic ear. "Well tell me what it is, darling," she said. "I'm sure we can sort it out together."
Maggie sat in her seat and bounced a little nervously on her hands. Now that she was here she was entirely uncertain of how to begin. There wasn't really a way she could go about this that would be easy; no matter what it would difficult and complicated and, depending on Pen's reaction, slightly embarrassing. “Okay, know that this is very, very confusing and I may just be saying things as they appear in my head, so I apologise if it seems senseless or rambling or whatever. You see, I spoke with Estela the other day and she asked me about you. Or rather she said how, ah, close we were. I think, if I'm honest, she was checking up on me for your sake. She seemed very protective of you,” Maggie did not allow time for Pen to react to this statement, as she found herself unable to stop talking. She needed to get it all out at once before more silences and more thinking confused her more or made her clam up entirely, “But she seemed to misunderstand and presumed we were....presumed we were a couple,” Maggie laughed a little, still finding it funny that that had indeed been the impression the two of them had inadvertently given off at Thanksgiving, “She asked- you see she asked if we were getting married. And I asked why she would think that and she said because we were clearly in love and that we reminded her of the way she and Gen were, are and la-la-la-la” Maggie etcetera'd the rest of the sentence; she didn't feel she needed to go into more detail there. “The only thing is....I think she may have hit on something. Something I very much hadn't realised.”
Penelope went very still as Maggie spoke. Every word, every breath from the woman was filled with new revelation, new concern, new panic. Estela had asked after her? She had...investigated Maggie? To protect her? To see if the woman was fit? But why… The was only one reason why, as inexplicable as it seemed. In spite of the way they kept each other from getting too close to their darkness, Estela had become...a little devoted to her. She was deft in the way she cared, subtle in her protection. Oh, Estela, Penelope wanted to say, my dear precious girl. But the moment this thought came into her head, it was shoved aside by another: she and Maggie were like...Estela and Gen? A couple? And /clearly in love/? Penelope’s expression turned to one of complete, open confusion. But what was more unnerving than the thought that Estela had presumed that she has thrown Wesley by the wayside for Maggie, was Maggie’s own expression and frailty of composure. The woman was frantic, afraid even. Dazed, Penelope pushed her keyboard away and turned to Maggie. Her heart raced with fright. She couldn’t think it, she couldn’t dare think or suppose even. It was impossible. Something wasn’t right, the touches she and Maggie shared, the way the woman’s smile warmed her, the way the feeling of her arms holding and cradling her close saved her, how those gentle kisses excited her--it was nothing. Purely circumstantial, surely, surely there had to be another name, another place for all this. It couldn’t be what Maggie thought, not now. Paler than she had been before now, Penelope asked with quiet but unmistakable seriousness, “And...what is that, Maggie?"
Maggie breathing became a little more erratic as she mentally forced herself to face her own conclusions, to voice them, to lay them out there for the person it concerned the most to see. She bit her nails briefly, but stopped herself almost as soon as she began, her hand returning to her lap. She tried to form words, a sentence but found her mouth opening and closing and forming numerous shapes without any sound leaving them. Get a grip, Maggie. “Pen....I'm-- I'm in love with you” She eventually managed, her tone betraying the fact she was bewildered by her own lack of self-awareness, thrown that she hadn't known her own heart before Estela had pushed her towards it. “And I had no idea.”
Penelope saw another version of this story unfolding before her eyes. She saw herself pulling Maggie into her arms, professionalism be damned, saw Maggie’s lips soft and sweet on hers, filled with so much pent up tenderness and longing as they kissed. She could almost feel them, wet, gentle, slow and mad with affection as they loved her. She saw them coming home together and laying close in one another’s arms, nothing more or less, just enjoying the almost horrific degree of comfort they gleaned from one another until sleep carried them away. The vision made her nauseous with heartbreak. It couldn’t be. She had promised herself something different. She had promised Wesley. Wesley who had only managed to properly say he loved her for the first time in weeks today, who made her eyes water and her body ache with hurt and missing. Wesley who she wasn’t even sure truly wanted her anymore--but what if he did? Suppose this was only one time, one terrible time when he went mad with impenetrable seclusion, and at the end of it all, when he was finally ready to come back, when he could hold her and comfort her and take her to Kent, to anywhere at all after what they’d been through--she wasn’t there? What if he was coming back to her side right now, weary with exhaustion, and rather than collapse in his arms as she had dreamed, she abandoned him? Penelope’s mouth trembled. “Maggie,” she whispered, reaching for the woman’s hand and squeezing it, “This is not the sort of discussion that is appropriate to be having in my office. My….Maggie my dear…” She faltered as her fingers brushed over Maggie’s hands. They were lovely hands indeed, and Maggie...God in heaven why had Maggie felt the need to make herself so terribly beautiful today? She bowed her head, trying to compose herself before she frightened Maggie away or cried. “Will you take a walk with me somewhere? Please…?”
Maggie heart jumped as Pen took her hand and squeezed it in the sign of solidarity and support they so often showed one another and she felt herself physically give an internal sign of relief at the fact Penelope had not pulled back from her confession, had not retreated and left her to sit there alone and vulnerable with her heart more visible to her than usual. Physical contact had still been permitted, was still offered and Maggie took it gratefully. She blinked furiously to prevent any tears that might be threatening and when she looked Pen in the eyes she had a smile on her face, a watery smile, a best-effort smile perhaps but a smile nonetheless. “Of course.”
Penelope's hand flew to Maggie’s cheek automatically as she saw her blinking away moisture. It was her habit to wipe away her tears, it was her designation to keep Maggie bright and shining and radiant. A designation she loved and treasured and guarded with such stupid ferocity. But she was not brave enough to complete her task now. The gesture was left as only a tender caress, limited and pointless. She bit her lip and allowed herself one more touch before rising and ushering Maggie out of the office. She lead them down the stairs, not the elevator. If she was still, if she had time to catch up with herself, something would happen. Maggie would hear her heart beating with terror, would catch note of her quivering breath, or worse, Penelope would have time to ponder this new ache filling her body. She would try to catch hold of it, to name it or make sense of it. It would be the end of everything. Her hand was still tight and protective around Maggie’s as they left the building. London was quiet at this hour. Nothing but low gray skies limp with moisture, leering pigeons, and the odd motor car sliding away down the street towards its destination. There was a park in Mayfair, near a hotel. She had thought to ask Wesley to meet her there, but then things had gone worse for them, and she’d become too afraid to try. As they walked, Penelope slipped her free arm abound Maggie’s shoulders, keeping her close to they could talk quietly. “How long have you known?” she asked.
Maggie was relieved that the question was actually a simple one, that she had a simple answer for. “Since speaking to Estela the other day. I mean....I thought about things and made sense of things properly, of course, but since...since then, really” Maggie sniffled a little and squinted off into the distance as they walked, more tears threatening as that heavy yet fluttering feeling pulled at the pit of her stomach. A feeling she hadn't had since Ben had courted her, since she had first realised her feelings for him. Oh God, what a dreadful comparison given the circumstances, but it was an apposite one nonetheless. “And I know it's completely I mean, it's not- I'm not /gay/ or....you're the sole exception to the rule. And I mean there's not any real point discussing it because you're not, you won't be interested,” No matter how desperately Maggie found herself wishing she would be, that she would reciprocate, she wished it more than she had consciously realised, but she forced her own feelings and wishes aside to better express her wishes she had for Pen, who really was the most important person in the situation. She was the one caught, she hadn't asked for this, for Maggie to complicate her life. “And even on the small chance you possibly, might- on the small chance you /were/, you're with and....” More tears to blink back. She decided to give up all pretence and pulled her handkerchief out of her pocket, the navy blue M embroidered on the corner, and dabbed at her eyes, “and I just want you to have whatever makes you happiest, no matter what that is. Even if it means I don't know, joing the cast of Chicago for their tour,” She joked feebly, trying to keep things light as more tears threatened. She dabbed and they were kept at bay by the cotton material, “God,” Maggie smiled with forced brightness, “God I'm talking too much.”
Penelope was glad that they had reached the park, because the only thing she wanted to do now that Maggie had finally finished talking was make her stop for a moment, hold her still and see good sense. Her own eyes were moist as she held Maggie by her shoulders and began wiping away her tears in earnest. She couldn’t hurt her, she couldn’t let her think that she was so horribly unwanted. This mad, pure, beautiful woman that loved her...how could she possibly think that her rejection would be so absolute? Won’t be interested, Maggie had said, small chance, small, small chance that she might--? “Oh, Maggie,” Penelope whispered. To try and imagine how much Maggie wished and hoped for reciprocation made her heart swell nearly to bursting. How cruel it all was, how terribly cruel and complicated that Maggie should wish so much and not know, and then in any acquisition of knowledge...gain nothing. She smoothed out her friend’s hair tenderly, giving her as much affection as she could manage while she tried to find her words and get back to sure footing after that horrifying confession. Never, Penelope thought, never had she heard anyone speak more selflessly about love. Never had she seen such complete sacrifice and care given to a cause that was so bewilderingly lost. Her finger brushed over Maggie’s lips and she shivered. She should be damned for feeling this way, for having fallen into something like this when she had promised, when she had set out to be honourable and good with the only man that had ever truly loved her, for having no proper answers, no sense of direction for what made or would make her happy. And the girls, Gen, Estela, Peyton, Dani, Rory, Freya, and all the rest of them, and her people...should happiness even come into it so closely? They were not put here to be happy, they were put here to help and do good. And Maggie, she lamented, savoring the feeling of Maggie’s mouth against her finger, was so very good, even if everything about this was all horribly wrong. “Maggie, my darling,” she whispered tearfully. “You must understand. You must try, and promise to understand…” She swallowed,trying to drag the words out of her throat, “I can’t...give in. I can’t abandon or desert...I’ve made a promise. And if I break that...Maggie, there may not be much good left in me if I start...I’ve already made compromises, and I don’t even know if they were right, I don’t know if I should have, and it’s unfair to you.” Her voice hardened as she spoke. She would be deliberate. She would be unquestionably sound. She would not be weak, she couldn’t be. Penelope flung her arms around Maggie and held her close. She whispered in her ear, “You must understand that this means that there is something to give into. Something for you. Something that could have been very beautiful if I wasn’t like this.” She leaned back and held the woman away for her. The pain and longing in her eyes was wet and palpable.
Maggie was unable to hold back her emotions as Pen held her, and the tears she had been trying to desperately to hold in, to keep at bay, came pouring down make her cheeks sticky and wet, her nose sniffling, and she gulped heavily trying to reign it in, the effort causing a sore pain at the back of her throat as she refused to let the choking sobs come through. “I know, I do,” She managed to speak through her desperate sobs, still holding onto Pen, “I'm not asking you to break- I would never ask you, never, no matter how much I might-- might want, I would never ask that. I wouldn't do that to you.” Her sobs were hindering her speech and she swallowed, trying to clear her throat, and calm down the heaving coming from her chest in bounds, “And I don't- I want the two of you to be so happy, so happy, I do, I really do. I want you to be happy, alright?” She couldn't bear to say that what Penelope had quietly admitted to, had gently handed her as something to be cherished and appreciated, something that while it could not save her from heartbreak, did save her from rejection or loss, she couldn't bear to say how much that reached and touched her for fear it would cause her to lose even more control of her emotions, “I'm so sorry I did this to you, but I just I had to- I had to tell you. I couldn't keep it secret.” She sniffled, desperately trying to stop crying as the two women continued to hold one another, “As long as you're happy, I'm happy, I do mean that, I really, really do.”
Penelope gasped as Maggie was back in her arms again. Her stomach turned as she tightened her grip and held back her own sobs by some miraculous force of will. Everything about this was wrong, from the ache in her heart to her longing, to her inability to truly comfort or assuage. She was the cry in Maggie’s throat, she was the tremor in her voice, the anguish in her eyes. She was hurting her so completely and yet Maggie insisted that they’d both be happy. You impossible, horrible, beautiful woman, Penelope thought. She kissed Maggie’s temple and rubbed her back, anything to make this a little less worse. “I would make you happier still, Maggie, if I could,” she said solemnly. But I can’t, or at least I won’t. God, she would have to tell Wesley, now, wouldn’t she? When he’d had his way and Angel was back, she would still be startling and disappointing him. What would he say? Was she leaving them all with nothing by doing this? The thought was too terrifying to comprehend just now. She put it away and set herself about wiping Maggie’s face with her handkerchief. She had never been more tender with her, nor more attentive. She worked in silence, the only chink in her stoicism the slight droop of her lip and the wet veil over her eyes, glimmering perfectly in place. “How would you like best to proceed?” she finally asked.
Maggie just about managed to hold the tears back, to reign in her crying to a gentle sobbing, an occasional hiccuping, something more controllable, she hoped more dignified but she suspected she just looked pathetic. For Penelope to say if the situation was different, she would reciprocate, if not for how everything had fallen in place, she would return her sentiments was something that both gave Maggie something to cling to and take comfort in, but at the same it only served to increase the pain, and to break her heart more. When she had come to speak to Pen, she had known she had loved her, but it was only through speaking through, through talking about it that Maggie came to really know the shocking and frightening depths of her own feelings. She could feel the pain in her heart she hadn't expected, a deep sickening pain she had only once before in her entire life. When she had come home obliviously to news Ben had been killed. Only then had she felt that same sickening pain that seemed to start at the very bottom of her stomach before it burned up through her heart and caught in her throat. Through her sadness and heartache, she was determined to make a point that she felt was important, and she felt there would be no other opportunity to say it, “Stay with Welsey if it's what you want, and no other reason, Pen. I don't mean 'oh so you can come, be with me' that's not it at all- I'm irrelevant- but stay with him because you want to be there, not because you feel obliged or because you won't go back or because you put him first or anything. Do it for you. Trust me. If you do it for you, that's how you two will be happy“ She sniffled and managed to wipe away the remainder of her tears, her breathing returning to normal. She looked at her friend as she thought on her question. How best to proceed? She wasn't even sure she had much of an answer, “I don't want to lose our friendship because of this,” She told her earnestly and almost pleadingly, “I don't want the closeness we have as friends to be sacrificed because all of this. I meant what I said earlier when I said I would always love you- and I mean that in any capacity. And I don't want to lose the friendship we have; I've never had a friend like you before.” She admitted with a shy shrug, and then she let out a little sad laugh as she remembered what she was going to speak about with Pen at home later on, before all this happened, “And I was going to ask you if you minded if I stayed permanently. How highly appropriate that would be.” Maggie commented sarcastically, sniffling again, but thankfully, no longer crying.
Penelope had to laugh along with Maggie, even if the sound sounded curiously close to a sob. “I’ll have to speak to Gen. About staying in the house, I mean. I suppose...it should have made things obvious to me sooner,” she laughed again, wiping deftly at her eyes, “but it isn’t quite home for me without you there, Maggie. Gen needs a say though. Things are difficult enough for her as it is, but if it’s possible for all of us to stay together...we shall.” She squeezed Maggie’s hands in hers as fiercely as she could so as to keep hers from trembling. It was almost frightening to see Maggie sacrifice herself like this, to willingly throw her own heart away...for her. Her happiness, the chance of her smile. Her great comforter and great giver of hope--it should have been obvious that she would be so smiling as she committed this great sacrifice. Penelope wanted to ask whether or not it would hurt, if being so close and yet so far might poison everything they’d had before. But she couldn’t bring herself to make the words. She feared Maggie might think that she was trying to dispose of her kindly, and she couldn’t have that, not for the world. “I’m not keen on losing you either. I….I find myself wondering if you’re the only reason I’ve made it through all this without ruining myself completley.” She bowed her head, blushing. “I haven’t become as selfish as all that, I wouldn’t try to keep you if you didn’t wish to be kept. But the feeling is mutual, my dear. We shan’t be separated. There’s no need for pleading.” She plucked a stray hair away from Maggie’s face and did her best to smile.
Maggie was so grateful for those words, for those reassurances that their friendship wouldn't fail this, would not falter at this hurdle. If she was honest, that was more important to her than anything. That was the thing that needed to last the most. She took Pen's hand and gave it a tight squeeze, “Thank you. I value you so much as a friend and I don't think I could survive losing that, I really don't” She was barely surviving this, and it was ironically only Pen's support as a friend that was getting her through it, that was helping her smile once more. “You know,” She said, in a brighter tone, still dimmed but closer to her usual sunny words, “There's a place down the road, just round the corner which sells old records. And there is one particular one that I used to have when I very little- it was a series of Christmas carols. Do you mind if we stop by on the way home and pick it up? I promise I won't get distracted by the chocolate shop next door to it” She held her hand in the symbol of Scout's Honour, “Promise.”
Penelope was startled by Maggie’s sudden ray of sunshine. How quickly she banished the clouds, how readily she wanted to fill their world with light. You were never meant to live with too many shadows, Penelope thought as she smiled at her, Perhaps this is for the best after all. She took Maggie’s hand and pressed it to her cheek for a brief moment before playing along. “Well,” she said with a bright dramatic sigh, “Only because you promised, you silly thing. Come, we’ve still got to make our way back to work.” There was so much she still wanted to talk to her about, so many things she wanted to ponder and reassure. She understood what Wesley had meant now when he’d said that it was impossible to weigh her and his Winifred against each other. She understood now that there was no happier, that when love suddenly stabbed her twice through, it didn’t make one branch wither or die. Love like this was never merciful. But perhaps it would be alright somehow in the end. Perhaps Maggie would still let her console her at night, that everything would go well. The sun was shining and so many things still seemed possible. She would go with Maggie to the shop and pretend, get her settled and leave her to deal with this all in whatever secret way she had that Penelope still did not know. And Penelope would face the realities of darkness, and brave it boldly as she should have all along.