i am working on getting these all on tumblr but it'll be a minute!
Nicest Thing
“You deserve it, though, Wyll. You deserve a fairytale. And you’re too fucking nice, so you’re trying to convince yourself you don’t want it, but you do. And I’m going to keep you from it.”
“I have the fairytale,” he shrugs. “I’m living it. Every second I get to spend with you, every kiss, every time you make me laugh, it’s…perfect.”
Your eyes are stinging now, and you blink furiously, avoiding his gaze. “Those stories, those fairytales, I’m not in them. They’re not about girls like me. Those girls are sweet and pretty and delicate. They’re not insecure, or angry. They don’t have horns and a tail. They’re not fucking turquoise, Wyll.”
“They are when I read them.”
You went to school with Wyll for 12 years, and then he disappeared months before graduation. 10 years later he shows up as The Blade of Frontiers, the celebrity folk hero you've been singing drinking songs about in bars all over Baldur's Gate. You have to work with him to try and bring down the Absolute, but he's got some secrets standing in the way.
Not quite enemies to lovers, but not NOT enemies to lovers. I'm mostly just trying to give Wyll a more fleshed-out story and romance bc there's so much to work with!! He's such an interesting character and I will die on that hill.
Read on AO3
Too Good (formerly Overlooked)
The hope makes you think ridiculous things, like how it would be the easiest thing in the world to just tell him how you feel. And maybe if you did, he’d be receptive. Maybe even tell you he feels the same. That’s completely ridiculous of course, absolutely unthinkable, but then he leans in so attentively and stares into your soul and it really, really starts to feel true.
So the words rise in your throat and move to the tip of your tongue and—hells, it would be so easy to just say it. It would be such a relief.
And then the fear claws at you, pulling the words back before they can escape.
You and Astarion are besties, but he's been really weird the past few weeks and you don't know why... friends to lovers and verrryyy slow burn, just yearning as far as the eye can see, will likely end with some smut
“I think, my love, that if we survive this, I have some work to do.”
Mina/Astarion | 11/11 chapters | Mature (I'll mark the smut chapters!)
This began from the idea that Astarion's friendship ending feels (to me) like his most happy and self-actualized ending, and maybe he needs those 6 months on his own before he can have a romantic happily-ever-after.
But it turns out she was used to being the one in the relationship with her shit together and when that's no longer the case she has some shit to figure out as well...
Read on tumblr: only chapter 5 is posted here so far (because it's my fave and it stands alone decently) but i will update as that changes!
A flip of a switch (formerly At Your Mercy)
Being as beautiful as he was, people wanting him the way they certainly seemed to everywhere they went, it must be impossible for him to feel safe anywhere. To feel whole. To feel like a mind attached to a body rather than floating outside of it. Gods, but he had such a good mind.
… Did he know that? What if he didn’t know that? What if he thought she only wanted his body? Surely he wasn’t that dense?
Oh gods, she realized. He absolutely is.
Mina/Astarion | 6/6 chapters (for now) | Mature
A prequel to Disarmed, picking up a few nights after the tiefling party/the first time they sleep together. Focuses a lot on Astarion working through his shit, the two of them figuring out sexual and non-sexual intimacy, all that good stuff. Also very fluffy. I took destiny into my own hands and changed the title and I don’t hate it anymore!
"I left you alone, and I’m sorry, and it kills me knowing I hurt you, but everyone is going to leave me alone in the end, even you.”
Rielle/Astarion | 4/? chapters | smut-free just sad as hell
Rielle hasn't seen Astarion for two centuries, and then he shows up at her art show (where several of the paintings are of him) for a painful reunion.
This is set 200 years after the events of the game, so the only surviving members of the core party are Rielle (tav), Astarion, Halsin, and Shadowheart, and Halsin and Shadowheart are near the ends of their lifespans. It's about Astarion wrestling with losing the first people he ever allowed himself to care about and the fact that he's an immortal spawn who's just going to keep losing people- is it even worth loving them in the first place?
If you can't tell this is just pure angst lol I am hurting my own feelings by writing this fic
"She wants to destroy you—but with her, for the first time, you think you make sense."
Female Durge/Astarion | 2/2 chapters | smut-free
An exploration of Durge and Astarion's complicated relationships with their sisters. I edited these minimally so they're a little more stream-of-consciousness. Ch 1 is Durge pov (2nd person though, you are Durge and Durge is you) and ch 2 is Astarion pov.
Read on AO3: chapter 1 | chapter 2
Read on tumblr: chapter 1 | chapter 2
We Were
“If the timing had been different, do you think we ever could have been in love?”
“We were, darling.”
You and Gale are happily married, but an old friend's wedding gets you thinking about the past and how things might have been different. Bittersweet and sad in the way life is sad even when it's not.
Rielle/Astarion | 6/7 chapters | no smut just sad | read on AO3
Rielle hasn't seen Astarion for two centuries, and then he shows up at her art show (where several of the paintings are of him) for a painful reunion.
The way people talked, he’d expected all of this to be easier when he had her with him, and in some ways it was. But it was also reminding him of how it felt to watch her suffer. He felt her pain as if it was his own, and in this moment their grief was multiplying, becoming something large and all-consuming. They held tight to each other like it was the only thing that would keep them from disappearing altogether.
Chapter 6: Night's End
Shadowheart died before sunrise. She had requested that it just be her and her father at the end, so when she refused the healing potion that would have kept her going a few more hours, Wilhemina nodded and slipped outside. Rielle and Astarion were still huddled together at the far railing, and Halsin had been preparing for a trance. They all looked up in unison, and she didn’t say anything, but she didn’t need to. For the first time, her eyebrows weren’t raised expectantly, her lips weren’t pursed, her eyes weren’t focused on anything in particular. This tiny paragon of efficiency had done all she could do, and now she was simply resigned. Somehow, out of all the things he’d seen in the past several hours, that struck Astarion as one of the saddest.
He’d never felt more prepared for anything than he had felt for his friend’s death, standing in the soft lantern light, staring into the dark forest, so emotionally drained that he felt it physically. The entire night had felt like a marathon, and it seemed to him if he wasn’t ready after that, he never would be.
So Astarion expected the relief that was flooding his body. The panic, however, was a surprise.
It wasn’t the first time Shadowheart had been this close to death. Every other time, a couple centuries in their shared past, he and Rielle and Halsin and whoever else had snapped into action, shouting between clashes of blades and spell incantations to coordinate who was closest, who had the best potion, who had an opening to administer one to her. Now, there was nowhere for the adrenaline to go. It felt as if his body was asking him, what do we do?? And he was only able to answer, nothing.
Rielle tightened her grip on his hand, pulling herself closer to him, and somehow, impossibly, he felt a fluttering in his chest. It should have been impossible to feel anything like joy or hope in a moment like this, but he spared a tiny section of his mind to marvel at the fact that after 200 years, she still fit perfectly against him. He felt her take a deep, shuddering breath, and he wrapped his arms fully around her.
The way people talked, he’d expected all of this to be easier when he had her with him, and in some ways it was. But it was also reminding him of how it felt to watch her suffer. He felt her pain as if it was his own, and in this moment their grief was multiplying, becoming something large and all-consuming. They held tight to each other like it was the only thing that would keep them from disappearing altogether.
-
After an hour or so, Arnell opened the door. He didn’t look nearly as changed as Astarion would have expected. It should do something to you, he thought. When your child dies, it should mark you in some way. But the man simply stood there, unblemished as ever, looking exhausted in a way Astarion couldn’t even fathom. He nodded to Wilhemina, who bustled forward to take his place at Shadowheart’s bedside and perform all the prayers and rituals a dedicated Selunite deserved. At least she had something to do now.
Finality seemed to hit all of them then; if Arnell had left her bedside, Shadowheart was well and truly gone. The slow, aching sadness that had been rolling off of Rielle for the last hour suddenly ran cold. She moved away from Astarion very slightly, and he loosened his grip to allow it. Her face, previously etched with grief, was now blank with shock. She squeezed his hand before stepping away, a small reassurance that she would come back to him. Another small piece of his heart broke at the idea that she was promising not to abandon him. He squeezed back and then released her, silently watching her move away and gaze past the railing.
The dark night sky was turning dusty, a signal that dawn was on its way, and the silent forest was slowly stirring again. Astarion hadn’t realized how quiet it had become. Now it almost seemed like Shadowheart had died so the world could come back to life.
He tore his eyes away from Rielle and the forest beyond her, wanting to give her the privacy she deserved. Halsin had put down his carving for what felt like the first time since they’d arrived, and he was collapsing into a chair, rubbing his face with his hands and sniffling. Arnell had closed the door behind him but hadn’t moved any further. As Astarion watched, he took a deep breath of the warm night air, closing his eyes. He swayed on his feet, and Astarion’s body responded before his mind, crossing the balcony in 2 long steps and catching the older man’s elbow to keep him standing. He opened his eyes, smiling sheepishly, and spoke in a soft, hoarse voice. “Perhaps I’m a bit too old to sit in one position that long.”
Astarion guided him over to a bench, where Rielle had gathered the food that was left from visitors onto a small table. “I’ve been neglecting my duties,” he replied as he guided Arnell to a seat and joined him, reaching for a roll and some soft butter. He split the bread in two and spread butter on each side before handing it to Arnell. “She did tell me to keep you fed, I believe.”
Shadowheart’s father accepted the roll and took a small bite, chewing and staring into the distance. Astarion had no idea how to talk to someone whose daughter had just died, so he made no attempt to start a conversation, and neither did the older man. They simply sat, the only sounds Rielle’s shuddering breaths and Arnell’s chewing.
-
After some time and some tea, Arnell seemed more solid, his eyes more alert. There wasn’t much behind them, but they were open as he sipped the tea they’d made for him. Astarion studied him for a moment, debating how selfish he wanted to be.
Selfishness won. He spoke into the silence, quietly enough that only Shadowheart’s father could hear him.
“Was it worth it?”
Arnell took a moment to come back to focusing, but he slowly turned to Astarion. “Sorry?”
“Was it worth it, having her for the time you had her? Was it worth the way you feel right now?” The words could have been angry or challenging, but he was honestly curious. Arnell seemed to understand this, thinking seriously before answering.
Then he frowned, looking at Astarion like he was trying to see him through a foggy window. “I would love to say yes. I’m not sure anything is worth this. If anything could be, though… it would be her.”
Astarion nodded, closing his eyes briefly.
“But then,” the man continued, and his eyes snapped open, “there were so many days I would have said yes. I suppose that would even the scales a bit.” He rubbed a hand over his eyes, and they looked sore from crying. “I’ll tell you one thing, though. It doesn’t matter.”
Astarion frowned. How could it not?
The man kept talking, ignorant to his confusion. “There was never another way this was going to go. The second I met her mother, this is what was going to happen.”
“What do you mean?” He was leaning forward now, trying to understand.
Arnell sighed. “What was the other option, not have her in my life?” He shook his head, closing his eyes. “Unacceptable. And when little Jen came along, I knew this day was coming, but she didn’t give me a choice. I was going to spend every second with her I possibly could, of course I was.” He opened his eyes to look at Astarion, and a tear navigated the lines of his face. He smiled sadly. “I understand why you’re asking. I used to ask myself the same question. But I learned a long time ago that it didn’t really matter; nothing was going to change. I never had a choice. And I didn’t really want one.
“So I learned to stopped asking.”
He paused again before adding, “thank you for asking me, though. It helps, reminding myself how I got here. Not much,” he said with a broken laugh, “but it helps.”
All of Arnell’s words felt like the missing pieces to a puzzle Astarion had been unable to solve for centuries. Heartbreaking clarity washed over him as they lapsed back into silence.
He’d just spent two centuries fighting a battle he’d already lost.
Someone should have warned him, he thought. He hadn’t known what he was signing up for, letting himself fall in love. He hadn’t realized it was all one singular experience, love and loss.
It wouldn’t have changed anything, he knew. He didn’t need Arnell to tell him that. Still, a warning would have been nice.
He looked over to Rielle, who was now resting with her feet out in front of her and her back against a post of the railing, her head tilted back to look at the stars. A single tear rolled down her temple into her hair. She felt eyes on her and brought her head up to meet his gaze. Her eyes steadied him as they always did, even as her expression grew curious.
He couldn’t imagine what his face looked like right now. Heartbreak and revelation and terror and love, all rolled into one. Maybe she’d paint it for him one day, the way he looked when he realized he was never going to run away again.
-
It was close to dawn when Wilhemina’s assistants arrived to prepare Shadowheart’s body. She’d requested to be returned to the land (with Halsin’s assistance), but apparently there was work they needed to do first. Astarion didn’t ask for details.
There had been a brief flurry of activity before the assistants had arrived, the three companions making sure Arnell had a constant supply of tea, making sure the chickens were fed, sending news of their friend’s death to anyone who needed to know. And now, a lull.
Astarion was starting to hate lulls.
He’d need to head indoors soon, he thought as he watched the sky lighten, but he didn’t move. The balcony had become a strange haven over the course of the night that he was reluctant to leave.
He was sitting with Rielle, listening to her talk about Sklada and her child. That was when they heard a soft gasp.
They looked up to see a small butterfly had landed on the rim of Arnell’s teacup. It was pure white, and it alighted for just a few seconds on the cup before moving away. Arnell watched it with his mouth open like he was captivated. Halsin stood and walked to where he was, smiling.
Astarion looked between the men. The moment seemed significant, but he couldn’t figure out why. Halsin leaned down to lay a hand on Arnell’s shoulder. “She certainly didn’t wait to pay you a visit, did she?”
Suddenly he understood. They were saying the butterfly was Shadowheart, or maybe that it was a sign she had sent them? “She is still here, my friend,” Halsin was saying. “She has not left, not truly.”
Whatever they were experiencing, he wasn’t about to interrupt it. When they looked over at him, he smiled and nodded the way Rielle did. However, when the older man collapsed into Halsin’s arms, weeping, Astarion turned away. He knew he should feel empathetic, he should be able to put his own feelings aside and let this man grieve his daughter, but all he felt was cold.
Rielle, of course, noticed his shift in demeanor. She leaned close, making sure to keep her voice low enough that only he would hear. “What’s wrong?”
He shook his head, unsure if he could even put it into words. “She’s not here,” he replied, equally quiet.
She frowned. “I don’t—“
“The point is that she’s not here. She did leave.” Understanding softened her gaze as he kept talking. “And hells, I hope she went far. I hope she’s having grand fucking adventures across the planes right now, not… polymorphing into a butterfly just to come say hi to all of us.”
Mina let out a soft laugh, not unkindly. “You’re not wrong. It certainly doesn’t seem like Shadowheart to embody something so tiny and delicate. Remember when she broke down those doors under the temple? Even Karlach couldn’t manage it.”
“She was so godsdamned strong. I can’t imagine a world where she—“ his throat constricted. They just didn’t understand her the way he did, no one did. She wasn’t sweet and light and friendly. Or rather she was, but she was also acerbic and self-centered and occasionally cruel in the name of honesty, and she wouldn’t send them gentle reminders of how beautiful she was in life. If she was going to send signs, they’d be annoying and brash and funny.
He hated that there was anyone in the world who didn’t see her the way he did. It wasn’t fair. She deserved to be seen in her entirety. Her darkness was just as beautiful as her light.
He swallowed and attempted to continue, battling his frustration to keep his voice low. “She wouldn’t send us a cute butterfly, Ri, she’d send us a fucking pigeon.”
Before he’d even finished his sentence, he felt something warm and wet on the side of his face. Rielle was looking at him like she’d seen a ghost, and as he slowly caught up to what had just happened, he realized she might as well have.
Alighting confidently on the eaves of the cottage above them, having just taken an enormous shit on his head, was the smuggest pigeon he had ever seen. It sat on the roof, staring Astarion down coolly for what felt like an hour before flying off again. He looked back at Rielle in complete shock as the thick white fluid continued its slow journey down his temple.
“She fucking heard you,” Rielle whispered, her voice cracking with the strain of holding in a laugh, and then the two of them lost it. She had just enough presence of mind to open a portal around them and whisk them down to the front porch of the cottage in order to give the older men some privacy, and Astarion was grateful for her quickness. The second they arrived, they both fell into a loveseat, laughing so hard they couldn’t breathe. She tried to wipe the bird shit off his face with her hand, and that sent him further into hysterics, as she only succeeded in moving it around. He wiped at it with his own hand and then wiped his hand on her arm as she squirmed, laughing too hard to put up a fight. They laughed until tears ran down their cheeks.
When they finally caught their breath, the sun was finally beginning to peek over the horizon, and they ducked inside. Rielle led him to the kitchen, still smiling and using her clean hand to wipe tears from her eyes. He followed, falling into step with her like the last 200 years had never happened.
“Sit,” she ordered, walking to the opposite corner where there was a cupboard of dishcloths and a water pump. She pulled out an old, stained cloth and ran it under the water.
“Darling, really, could we not find something cleaner?”
She paused before wringing out the cloth, turning to walk back to him and pull up a chair facing him. She seemed not to have heard his question, but she also seemed to be working something out in her head, and he didn’t want to disrupt the process.
She sat with her knees between his, bringing the wet cloth up to his face and rubbing gently, pausing to fold and refold every couple of strokes to make sure she was using the cleanest bits of the cloth. For a moment they sat in the quiet, early morning kitchen, not saying a word, and for the first time in a long time, Astarion let himself be still. He could hear her heartbeat—he’d know it anywhere, it was as familiar as the sound of his own voice—and feel her soft breath on his face as she worked, pursing her lips like she always did when she was focused.
Soft footsteps came from the door to the dining room, and Astarion looked out of the corner of his eye. It was a small hairless cat, walking over to them and confidently weaving between their legs. His purring added to the peace, and for a moment Astarion let himself forget the death and the pain and the heartbreak.
“I think that’s my cat,” Rielle said softly, glancing down.
“I didn’t know you had a cat.”
“I didn’t, until a couple hours ago. She said he’s mine to take care of. Let me rinse this, I got the majority of it but I’m just smearing it around at this point.” Astarion hummed in understanding, sitting still as she stood.
It seemed safe to assume the house didn’t have multiple hairless cats running around, and therefore that this was the cat named after him. He reached a hand down idly and the cat version of him butted against him. “I don’t know what she was being dramatic about, you’re perfectly friendly,” he murmured, and the cat pulled back to hiss gently before purring and butting against him again. He supposed that clarified things a bit.
Rielle sat down again, pulling the hair at his temple back gently with her free hand as she resumed wiping. He’d forgotten about her hands in his hair. It was indescribable, that feeling. “Did you mean to call me darling?” She asked quietly, looking at her work and not at his eyes.
He thought for a moment. “Earlier, on the balcony, it slipped out. But just now I did.”
She nodded and didn’t respond.
He didn’t want to shatter the peace of this moment, nor the delicate peace that had existed between them during the night. But every night had to end eventually, so he gathered his courage and spoke. “I remember what you said, 10 years ago. I don’t expect you to have forgiven me. But I am sorry, my dear. More than I can ever say.” His eyes were filling again. Hells, he was tired of crying. “Everything that you said had to happen before I could use that word again—everything that is within my power to do, I have done and I will do.”
Her eyes were filling now, too, but she was refusing to look away from the cloth in her hand. He gently grabbed her wrist, stilling her hand and forcing her to look at him. A tear spilled over her already tear-stained cheeks, but she didn’t look away.
“I’m not going anywhere. I will call you whatever you want me to call you. You’re my love. My heart. You always have been. I tried to escape it, and it was impossible. So I’m not running anymore. I want every remaining minute with you that I can have. The good and the bad, I want it all.”
She drew in a ragged breath, looking toward the warm sun peeking through the window as more tears fell. He’d need to move further into the house soon, but it was alright for the moment. He held his breath as she tried to put words to her thoughts. She turned back to him, and there was fear in her eyes like he hadn’t seen in centuries. But there was courage, too, and a love he wasn’t sure he’d ever feel worthy of. But he’d try, because he owed her that, too.
“You can call me darling,” she said softly, and it was a relief like he’d never felt. He closed his eyes, and before he opened them again he felt the warm press of her lips against his. 200 years without her, 200 years of fantasies and daydreams, and he hadn’t done her any justice at all. She was so much sweeter, so much softer, so much stronger, so much kinder, so much funnier, so much cleverer.
He threaded his fingers into her hair and breathed her scent and asked himself, one last time, if this would be worth the inevitable pain.
His entire being answered. With her warmth around him, her hand soft on his knee, her courage, her trust…of course it was.
Rielle/Astarion | 4/? chapters | no smut just sad | read on AO3
Rielle hasn't seen Astarion for two centuries, and then he shows up at her art show (where several of the paintings are of him) for a painful reunion.
“Why did you name them what you did? The paintings of me?”
She shook her head and smiled, looking to the side. “The first time you fed on me, you said ‘This is a gift, you know. I won’t forget it.’ And, I don’t know, I suppose it came to mind as I painted memories of you. Gifts are something you give freely, without expecting anything in return, and if I think of my love for you in those terms it’s a little less… painful. So, the series about how I love you is called The Gift.”
Chapter 1: Opening (next chapter)
“Wow, you’re 300 years old?? You look so young!”
Rielle had been hoping her tight smile would come off as friendly, but not so friendly that it invited more conversation. Either she missed the mark or this girl was too oblivious for her own good.
“That’s incredible, I can’t imagine what that must be like. You must be so smart. I feel like I’d really have my shit together if I could live for 300 years.”
There it is, Rielle thought. “That’s a common misconception, actually. It’s not really linear like that. You learn a lot, but you also outlive a lot of people, and that sort of messes you up all over again. Some of the most messed up people I’ve ever met were centuries old.”
“Wow, that’s wild.” The girl was nodding, but she clearly wasn’t listening. Rielle could say anything right now and this girl would agree.
It wasn’t the first time she’d had this conversation with a human. It wasn’t even the 500th. Most of them ended this way, with her gently trying to correct their assumptions and them ignoring her to continue living in their fantasy versions of the world. She couldn’t blame them. If humans didn’t want to spend time unpacking their preconceived notions about a lifestyle they would never have the chance to live anyway, she could let them have that. It was annoying, but it wasn’t hurting anyone really. Of course, that didn’t mean she needed to indulge this girl indefinitely.
Rielle gently excused herself to keep wandering around the crowded gallery. It was busier than the average opening, definitely. Dozens of conversations blended into a roar as voices echoed off the tiled floor. It was a nice space, but loud, and that made it more overwhelming. She sipped her wine as she walked, hoping it would dull the experience for her a bit.
She recognized a few faces as she wandered, but no one acknowledged her. That was just fine. That was part of the reason she used a pseudonym for her work. One thing centuries of life had taught her was that art and fame were a volatile combination. And so, it was Tav Joren who had painted the many works adorning the walls, not Rielle. Over the last couple decades, Tav had earned herself quite the reclusive and mysterious reputation. All anyone seemed to know about her was that she had been present at the Battle of Baldur’s Gate 200 years ago and had known The Heroes, the group of companions who had taken down an elder brain and saved the city.
The work on display tonight portrayed those very companions, which had not gone unnoticed by the reviewer from the Gazette. “This anonymous artist has evoked the likenesses of some of our city’s most beloved figures, rendered all the more intimate for their abstraction,” they’d written. The reviewer had concluded that this work was her “least obscure and most accessible work yet.” She hadn’t been sure at first, but apparently that was a good thing.
It never failed to amuse her, the way people wrote about her art. All she’d been trying to do was paint her memories. They tended to come in flashes, a crinkle of an eye, a brush of a shoulder, a teardrop sliding down a cheek. So, that’s what she had painted. It really wasn’t that deep.
Regardless, the local history connection combined with the positive review had drawn a crowd, and Rielle wasn’t complaining. She had bills to pay, and abstract portraiture wasn’t always the moneymaker she needed it to be.
She continued around the room, occasionally pausing behind people who were considering one of her paintings to hear their thoughts. It seemed the “Gift” series was everyone’s favorite, which she had to agree with. Those paintings were the ones that had started this entire body of work for her. They were displayed in a side room to keep them together. Rielle passed a group of young adult halflings exiting the room and gushing about how they’d “fallen in love with a bunch of paint on canvas” and how “his eyes are so mysterious and sad??” She smiled to herself. She’d nailed his likeness, then.
Halsin’s portraits were drawing a lot of attention, but he made regular appearances in the city, so people recognized him. He was the only member of their group, actually, who lived publicly as a “Hero.” She and Shadowheart preferred to keep their heads down, and he didn’t seem to mind. The only other person still alive was Astarion, and though he was also recognizable to people (unlike Rielle or Shadowheart, who had aged and changed their hair over the years), he’d never spoken publicly about his experience fighting the Absolute. Since Wyll had died many, many years ago, Halsin had happily worked on his own to preserve their history and make sure no member of their group was forgotten. She passed a portrait of Wyll now, a flash of his stone eye in the firelight the night he’d asked her for a dance, and her heart ached. It never went away, the feeling of missing them. After all these years, it still hurt sometimes.
She cleared her throat and looked away. Maybe it was time for a fresh drink.
As she passed the makeshift bar in the corner opposite the entrance, Rielle swapped her empty glass for a full one, pausing to strategize. She knew the cast of characters who attended art openings in the city fairly well by now, and they all assumed she hung around so much because she worked at some gallery or another and left her alone. She liked most of them well enough, though there were some whose opinions on art she valued over others. Her eyes fell on Oskar’s something-great grandson. He never missed an opening, much to her dismay. As usual, he was looking down his nose at all the work and commenting loudly that “it’s just a bit simplistic, that’s all. A noble attempt, though.” Rielle snorted into her glass. Says the man who exclusively paints nudes of women he’s slept with lounging on beds. Real groundbreaking work, that.
Her eyes fell next on a tall, blue-skinned tiefling in a loose, colorful robe. Sklada, her manager. Sklada had bribed a gallery owner some 10 years ago to tell her the real name of the artist who’d done all the “sad pretty portraits” on display, and from there had tracked Rielle down and forced her way into representing her. Rielle had been resistant at first, but she was quickly forced to admit that it made anonymity easier having someone to contact galleries for her. The only people in the world who knew she was Tav were Sklada, Halsin, and Shadowheart. It was probably their 50th opening together, and her manager had not always been great at subtlety (she stood close to 7 feet tall and seemed to be allergic to flat shoes and neutral colors, so that wasn’t surprising), but she had figured it out eventually. Now, the tiefling calmly excused herself from the group she’d been talking to and made her way over to the bar, greeting Rielle as if she were a casual acquaintance and not a client/friend/godfather to her son. After 300 years of life, Rielle didn’t go out of her way to let new people into her life, but Sklada had stubbornly insisted, and she was glad.
“Hello, sweetheart!” The tiefling leaned an elbow against the bar and smiled down at Rielle. “Quite a turnout, isn’t it?”
Rielle smiled as she looked out over the crowd. “It really is, Sklada. You did a great job promoting it.”
“Please, this work sells itself.”
Rielle rolled her eyes, but smiled at the compliment.
“You know,” Sklada continued, “I hadn’t seen all of this work together until the gallery finished hanging it all this morning. It’s really something, isn’t it?”
“I suppose so.”
Sklada clicked her tongue and shook her head. “No, it is. And the ‘Gift’ series, do you know the story behind that one?”
Rielle sighed. She had avoided getting into it the several other times they’d discussed this body of work, but she’d had a couple drinks now and her tongue was feeling slightly looser.
“I think.. I think the artist said he was the person she was closest to.”
“Mm, interesting. But they’re not together now?”
Rielle laughed bitterly. “No, no, he has made it very clear he wants to leave all that behind and wants nothing to do with her.”
Sklada took a thoughtful sip of her drink, keeping her eyes on Rielle. When it became clear that was all the information she was going to get, she nodded and looked back out at the crowd.
“Well, at least it seems like the artist has made peace with the situation and isn’t still making tragic paintings about it. Oh, wait…”
Rielle gave her a playful shove, and Sklada graciously pretended to be knocked off balance, laughing.
“Listen, the best art humbles the artist, right? And look at all these young people falling in love with this man based on some portraits, you’ve really done something! Not sure what, but it’s definitely something.”
Rielle rolled her eyes. “I have not done anything, have I Sklada?”
“Oh gods, alright, the artist has done something. Either way, after all this mess is over tonight you’re coming home with me and we’re going to eat and toast to the artist’s success and annoy the shit out of my wife who has likely just gotten our baby to sleep, yes?”
Rielle smiled to herself. It was nice, feeling like she was part of a family. It had been a long time. It felt that way still when she visited Shadowheart or Halsin, but Halsin had a few centuries on her and Shadowheart was a half-elf, so neither of them were up for much late night carousing anymore. “Oh, Sklada, I forgot Halsin said he might come tonight. There’s some midsummer event happening this whole week at the inn, but he said he would try and make it afterward.”
The tiefling’s face lit up. “Oh amazing, I haven’t seen him in ages! If you see him tell him he’s invited to the afterparty, will you? If I bring him with me maybe Mir won’t be so mad at me. I keep telling her to just admit she’s in love with him, I mean who isn’t? But she insists I’m imagining things, but I know my wife, Rielle, and…”
As her friend launched into a familiar rant, Rielle saw a flash of white out of the corner of her eye. Her heart stopped as it always did, holding for a beat and then redoubling somewhat painfully. Her stomach flipped. She would have thought after a couple centuries it would get old, this dance of hope and grief that her body did every time she saw someone with white hair, but apparently not. She noted with annoyance that her heart was in her throat now, and she didn’t bother trying to stop her eyes from tracking down whatever non-vampire non-Astarion she’d just seen. Probably just a drow or someone making a fashion statement, but she knew from experience that her mind wouldn’t rest until it proved she’d been mistaken.
However, she realized as her heart fell into her stomach, that might be an issue this time.
Because as her eyes finally landed on white hair, they also landed on someone who was indisputably, unmistakably Astarion. He was drawing stares, magnetic as ever, but his red eyes, red eyes she hadn’t seen in hundreds of years, were fixed on her.
Rielle’s body was reacting before her mind had even processed what was happening. There was a rushing in her ears and sudden tears pricking at her eyes, and she could feel her face flushing. She felt as if the earth had fallen from under her but she was still suspended briefly in midair, waiting to fall. The fall was certainly coming, though.
In her many imagined versions of this moment she had been calm, articulate. She had spoken to him as if he was a stranger, told him exactly what he’d put her through. As she looked at him now, her fantasies fell to pieces. It had been a long two centuries. She wanted to kiss him as badly as she wanted to kill him, and that was no small amount.
She felt a hand on her arm. “Sweetheart, are you okay? What just happened?” Sklada had cut off her rant and was speaking softly now, like she was afraid Rielle was going to pass out. And, well, that wasn’t out of the question. Rielle couldn’t tear her eyes away from Astarion, blinking several times in the hopes that he was some sort of hallucination.
“Shit,” she whispered, and Sklada followed her line of sight, landing on the man with a sharp intake of breath.
“Hells, is that–?” She likely wasn’t the only person recognizing the pointed ears and white hair from the portraits in the side gallery. He was one of Rielle’s paintings, come to life.
Rielle fumbled around behind her to try and put her drink on the bar. “I have to–I’m sorry, Sklada, I just–”
Her friend grabbed the glass from her hand and put a reassuring hand on her back. “It’s fine, sweetheart. Do you want me to come with you?”
“Um…” Rielle couldn’t get her mind to function properly. “No, no, it’s fine. I’ll go see what he wants.” She didn’t like worrying her friend like this, so she tried a joke that ended up feeling a little too real to be funny. “If I’m not back in an hour, send in a rescue team.”
She immediately turned to head… where? She didn’t want to be alone with him, she wasn’t ready for that. But even more than that, she didn’t want to have her first conversation with him in 200 years surrounded by strangers. Not to mention, the pragmatic part of her brain was reminding her, if she wanted to stay anonymous it probably wouldn’t be a good idea to draw a ton of attention to herself arguing with someone who was very clearly the subject of several paintings on display. She had a vague memory of a door off of the permanent collection galleries that led to a garden, and without another thought she headed there, ducking her head to avoid being sucked into a conversation. She didn’t need to look to know he was following her.
She waded through the crowd towards the entrance, into the main hall and then across to the permanent gallery. These rooms were always open, but for events the gallery would often hire a Fist soldier to hang out in the hall and keep people out of them. Luckily, this particular guard had been on duty when Rielle had dropped off some of her work, and he seemed to recognize her, nodding to let her through. As she walked through the dark doorway, she pointed behind her without looking. “You can let him through, too.” Her voice was strangely steady.
The permanent galleries were a series of interconnected rooms with a variety of work from local artists over the years. There were pieces from a couple of Rielle’s former alter egos on the walls, displayed as antiques, which usually amused her. Right now it just made her sad. She was an antique. She was too fucking old to feel this many feelings.
During the day these galleries had a steady flow of visitors, but tonight they were eerily quiet. It was chilly despite the warmth of the night air outside, temperature controlled for the sake of the art. The only light was what filtered through from the lobby, and it cast long shadows in front of pedestals and statues. The chaos of the opening had receded to a dull roar that sounded much farther away than it was. Rielle felt like she’d entered a tomb.
She walked through the first room, weaving between sculptures as her footsteps echoed softly and her head spun. She had known he was alive, but apparently seeing it was a whole other experience altogether. What in all the hells was he doing here? Anger and longing were battling it out in her chest. How dare he, she thought, show up here like he didn’t abandon me for 200 years?
But 200 years was a long time, and she’d be lying to herself if she thought her anger hadn’t faded a bit. There was a not-insignificant part of her that didn’t even care for an apology, that wanted nothing more than to feel his soft, cool fingers in hers, to wrap herself around him and inhale his scent again. He was here. He was back. Surely she deserved, after he’d deprived her all this time, to have that? To feel good again in the way she only ever had with him?
Hells, that was pathetic. He’d probably replaced her dozens of times over while she’d been lonely and pining.
She slipped into the second room. The lobby light didn’t reach here, but the glass paneled door on the back wall that led out to the garden let in beams of moonlight. She walked to the door and tried it, dismayed to find it was locked.
“Allow me.”
Fuck, that voice. She’d had dreams narrated in that voice. It was still the voice she heard when she was puzzling through something difficult and didn’t have a friend to bounce ideas off of. He’d been her person for that. That, and so many other things.
She stepped aside to let Astarion kneel in front of the door, and for a moment Rielle felt like laughing at the familiarity of it. They might have been breaking into a general’s quarters or looting a crypt two centuries ago. It was as if no time had passed at all, when in fact so much time had passed as to separate them almost entirely. She put a hand on the wall to steady herself and tried to breathe.
Within a single cycle of breath the door clicked open, and Astarion smoothly stood and slipped through. Rielle followed, turning to close the door behind her as a way of giving herself one more blissful second of not looking at his face. Of course, one second was about all she could stand, she was so eager to see him again. Gods, this was confusing.
She sighed and turned, taking him in slowly as if he was a bright light in a dark room and she had to let her eyes adjust. He looked good, not that she was surprised. He was wearing an impeccable suit that was tailored to within an inch of its life, which seemed unfair. Of all people, he was one of the few who didn't need the help of a good tailor to look perfect. He’d framed himself well, too, standing in front of an ivy archway that led to a fountain. It was a beautiful night, and he was beautiful.
Rielle had grown, in many years of life, to appreciate the feeling of heartbreak. She didn’t want to become one of those elves who reached 300 and started living self-destructively, doing impulsive and stupid things just to feel something, but she understood how that happened. After a while, it did start to feel like you’d experienced everything already. Existence became boring. So when her heart was sore, it sometimes felt good. Stimulating, like a muscle she was exercising for the first time in a while.
There was an element of that now. Sharing space with him again hurt in an almost exquisite way. Despite everything, she still considered herself just a little lucky to have had her heart broken by him. It was proof he’d held it for a little while.
Slowly, as her eyes adjusted and they stood in silence, Rielle’s mind began to work again, and she finally spoke, her voice unsteady and quieter than she hoped. She sounded younger than she had in years.
“Why… why did you come here?”
He opened his mouth to speak and then closed it again, looking at the ground as if to gather his thoughts. When he looked back up, his face was open and serious and all he said was “Because I missed you.”
Ah, she thought. There’s the anger. It hardened in her chest until she felt brittle with it. She was never one for yelling, and that had become more true with time. When she spoke, it was no less calmly than she had before, but her voice had a hard edge.
“I beg your pardon? You missed me? Astarion, what is this? Why are you here?”
He seemed to flinch slightly at the sound of his name from her lips. As he fucking should, she thought vindictively.
He furrowed his brow at her repeated demand, shaking his head like he was confused.
“Darling, I–”
“Don’t call me that.” Rielle was quietly seething as she stepped towards him. “Don’t you dare, not until you explain what is going on and why you abandoned me and why it took you two godsdamned centuries to find me again, and not until I somehow magically forgive you, which I won’t, and not until you swear to me on my own grave that you will not leave again, then you can call me darling. Not until then.”
She was standing an arm’s length from him now, and she was annoyed to feel hot tears flooding her eyes. I hope they make him feel like shit, she thought to comfort herself.
Astarion held up his hands as if to show he was unarmed.
“Yes, alright. But… you know where I live. I don’t understand why I’m the abandoner here and you’re the abandonee, my dear. My door is always open to you. I never wanted it to be like this.”
Rielle laughed bitterly.
“Tell me, Astarion, when was the last time I saw you?”
He blinked at that and looked to the side as if trying to escape her gaze.
“No no, look at me. Describe to me what was happening the last time I saw you.”
He shifted from one foot to the other. She couldn’t remember ever seeing him look this nervous.
“I–the sun was burning me, so I–”
She grabbed his chin and forced him to look down at her.
“Before. That.”
His eyes went from nervous to downright afraid, but he didn’t pull out of her grasp. He didn’t speak, either. Rielle waited. She’d waited 200 years, she could wait another minute. No problem.
When he finally licked his lips and opened his mouth, his voice came out impossibly faint.
“...Karlach.”
“What happened to her?”
He cleared his throat, but his voice was still barely above a whisper.
“She… she died. In your arms. She died.”
His throat caught on the last word, and Rielle saw his eyes welling up. She felt bad for him, she wanted to hold him and comfort him, but her anger was like a forest fire, eating her up faster than she could think. She tightened her grip on his jaw.
“And at her funeral, the next day? Where were you then? The funeral we held after sunset specifically so you could attend?”
His face hardened now, though his eyes were still close to overflowing.
“I didn’t ask you to do that. I don’t do funerals.”
He had found his voice, and it was cold and certain. Rielle let go of him and stepped back. Now that his anger was igniting, hers was burning out, fading to a deep, aching sadness that was too familiar.
Why couldn’t they talk to each other? They’d always, always been able to talk to each other. She shook her head and sighed heavily, letting sadness quench her anger fully as she looked up at him.
“I know you and Gale had your issues, and Wyll was a jerk to you sometimes. I know that. I didn’t expect you to go to another plane for Lae’zel’s funeral. But… Karlach, she loved you. You should have seen her after we found out about the ascension ritual, I’d never seen her so angry. On your behalf. She… she really loved you.”
His face had not softened, but a single tear fell down his cheek as she spoke. She saw him swallow hard before replying, his voice strangely formal.
“I’m aware. I cared for her as well, which is why I didn’t want to watch her get dumped into a hole while a bunch of people who barely even knew her cried their eyes out. I don't do funerals, my dear. Especially not for her.”
Rielle felt a small wave of relief settle over her. She’d known he was kind, she’d known they had broken through his walls. But there had been a small part of her, after all this time, that had started to wonder if perhaps she’d been wrong about him. If perhaps he had never cared.
It was, at the very least, a comfort to quiet that voice in her head.
But it didn’t soothe the hurt.
“Astarion… I loved her. I loved all of them.”
The mask of his anger was beginning to crack, his eyes becoming rounder as more tears fell.
“I was so, so sad. Even if you weren’t at the funeral I needed… I needed a friend. Every single time, Karlach and Wyll and Gale and Lae’zel, every one of them, I needed you.”
“You had friends. Friends who knew how to be what you needed. I wouldn’t have been of any use, I would have made it all worse.”
His words were certain, but his voice was low and unsure.
“Sure. I had Halsin, and I had Shadowheart, and I’m grateful for them every single day. But you were the one… you know what we were to each other, Astarion. You were the first person I went to when I was feeling… anything. And I thought I was that for you as well. I–”
She was crying too, now. She honestly hadn’t thought these feelings were still so close to the surface, but she was reliving it all now as she looked into his eyes. The days of waiting, the strange, detached tone in his letters as if nothing had changed. The days, the months, of crying so hard she could barely breathe, feeling so alone. Missing him on top of everyone else. She took a shaky breath before continuing.
“I really needed you, and you weren’t there. It was like you didn’t even care. I didn’t need you to be perfect, I just needed you to be there. And instead, you left me so completely alone–”
A sob cut off her last words, constricting her lungs and her throat and making it impossible to speak. Before she knew what was happening, there were cool, firm arms wrapping around her. After two centuries her body still remembered him, and her arms went around his neck without a thought.
They stayed like that for a long time, her sobbing into his shirt and him holding her. Rielle let herself relax into him. It was frightening, actually, how quickly her body seemed to forgive him, even as her mind couldn’t.
She berated herself mentally. She had not intended to cross the line of physical contact at all, because she’d known it would be too easy. She certainly had not forgiven him, and she wasn’t about to act like everything was fine. But as he held her, she felt a tiny rip in her heart begin to knit back together. For the first time in centuries, he was giving her something she needed. It wasn’t okay, it wasn’t over, but she was so tired. She needed a truce, just for now, just while his arms were around her.
When her breath quieted, Astarion moved one hand up to stroke her hair gently. She relaxed into him even further, sighing at the sensation. She remembered when this kind of thing had not come so naturally to him. He’d learned how to hug when they were together. It hadn’t been that much time together, all told, but she still carried so much of him around with her every day. What was she supposed to do with that? She couldn’t just forget. It was who she was now. They were a part of each other, forever.
After another minute, he spoke softly next to her ear.
“The paintings, the ones of me… they’re lovely. I don’t know how you do that, it’s like you paint someone but you paint more than just their appearance. You paint their essence. I’ve always admired that.”
She pulled back to look up at him, wiping her tears, and he let his arms fall.
“What do you mean ‘always?’”
He smiled sadly. “My dear, you can use any name you want, but I’d know your work anywhere. I’ve got quite a collection back home, spanning your whole career.”
Rielle’s heart constricted painfully. It was so wonderful to be loved by him. It was so cruel of him to love her only from afar. She swallowed and looked down.
“Thank you, that’s… thank you, Astarion.”
“May I ask you a question?”
She laughed humorlessly as she looked back up at him. “Sure, why not?”
“Why did you name them what you did? The paintings of me?”
She shook her head and smiled, looking to the side. “The first time you fed on me, you said ‘This is a gift, you know. I won’t forget it.’ And, I don’t know, I suppose it came to mind as I painted memories of you. Gifts are something you give freely, without expecting anything in return, and if I think of my love for you in those terms it’s a little less… painful. So, the series about how I love you is called The Gift.”
She spoke matter-of-factly. She’d become more prone to doing that over the last couple of centuries, having grown tired of trying to couch things or be tactful.
Astarion blinked, his eyes becoming round once more as his brow furrowed into sad disbelief. He didn’t say anything else, and neither did she.
He still hadn’t been there when she needed him. He still hadn’t apologized for not being there. There was nothing more to say, for now. After a moment of silence, she turned and walked back into the darkened gallery, and he did not follow.
tw for references to orin/bhaal shit | Read on AO3 | part 2
"She wants to destroy you—but with her, for the first time, you think you make sense."
Sooo I think this is part 1 of a two-parter about Durge and Astarion having… complicated relationships with their families? I am *trying some stuff* here and idk if I like all of it but I am forcing myself to post it and not overthink it, pls enjoy and be nice
You knew before you knew, the sight of Orin up there with her—formerly your—co-conspirators, the way her braided hair moved when she turned, the way she stood. The shape of her. You knew.
But you needed her to give you the word for it. Sister, she calls you, and time stops.
It’s almost funny, really. For weeks now, you’d been hoping to find family once you reached the city. Family could give you something to anchor yourself to, something to orient yourself around. They would tell you who you were, though admittedly you had started to get the feeling that you didn’t want to know.
Still, even if you’d been made into a monster, you couldn’t have started that way.
Except, apparently, you could.
Now you’re standing in the street on a beautiful afternoon in front of your sister. Passersby should notice her, but they don’t, going about their days as usual. The smell of rotting flesh wafting off her scraps of clothing should be noticeable, if nothing else, but surely the chosen of Bhaal has her ways of staying hidden.
It’s not a smell that bothers you, though you wish it was. To you, it smells like home.
You’re staring at her white eyes and you remember the way you tried to see your reflection in them as a child, but they were too light and you were just a faint silhouette. Your eyes, solid black, reflect everything around them. People–and, perhaps, gods–always saw themselves in you, reflected back, and it drew them to you when Orin only ever unnerved them. So she was left behind, and now you remember, and you blame yourself for not seeing it until it was too late, but it was never personal. You were cold where Orin burned hot, calculated where Orin was passionate. You were better suited. That’s all it was.
But for your sister, everything is personal.
Astarion is next to you, and there’s disgust in every line of his face as he looks at her. You look back at Orin, and yes, you suppose you understand. It’s hard to see her objectively, though. An hour ago, she was just a distant enemy. Now, you know her too well to know what she looks like. She’s not a body, she’s a manic laugh, a vicious smile, a tongue cleaning a blade. She’s dark entity that followed you like a shadow, trying to cut your feet out from under you since the day she was born. She’s your little sister.
Her form shifts in your memory, but you know the smell of her blood. You know exactly how much pressure it takes to break her skin with a dull knife. And you know, above all, that you tried to help.
You tried so hard to explain to Orin that she was doing too much, that she was too eager. She loved Bhaal so much that it made him hate her. She hadn’t even waited for her grandfather to call her to his bed, offering herself up the moment he gave her a second glance, and he’d grown sick of her so quickly. She just needed, and needed, and needed, and she had given you no choice. You had no choice but to pull away. You and the other adults had conversations she didn’t understand, lost in her twisted fantasy land. She didn’t understand.
But it was never for lack of intelligence. You see her now, looking between you and Astarion, and you know she sees the threads that connect you. It’s her gift, one of many. Given half a chance, she will stretch them tight and play them like a harp before slicing through them—no, not slicing. Gnawing them one by one, letting them fray and unravel to a single fiber before they snap on their own. Making it last. She knows at a glance that he’s the most important thing in your life, and you’ve barely even realized it for yourself.
As she calculates how to hurt you most, you remember teaching her how to braid her hair with small fingers. She still wears it like that, down her back. Your heart is tender, horrible, and you wish, now you’ve had a chance at a new start, that you had shown her anything else, anything other than the world you were born into. But how could you have shown her what you yourself didn’t know existed?
In another life, she’d have been an artist.
She smiles and tilts her head, and time starts again, the sounds of the city gate crashing over you, a cool hand at your back, holding you steady.
Steady is something she’ll never know. She doesn’t know enough to want it, and she knows too much.
Your sister is disappearing in front of your eyes, and you’re relieved, but panic rises in your belly. You hadn’t realized what it would mean, having someone who knew the darkness you grew in. She wants to destroy you—but with her, for the first time, you think you make sense.
A cool hand is at your back, and you let her slip away.
Perhaps it’s enough to be understood from the outside. Perhaps a family you build from scratch is enough.
You let the hand pull you close, and you turn away.
An Archive of Our Own, a project of the
Organization for Transformative Works
final chapter of the gift is posteddddd 😭😭😭😭😭
if you're just joining us, this is a real romp of a read all about immortality, the relativity of time, the process of grieving, love, painting, cats... also i killed shadowheart oops
and like everyone else
halsin's still kicking for now though
and in this last chapter astarion refers to a cat as his "son" because apparently I work that into all my fics lol
