- thinks the discovery pages are Paul's personal notes (they're the website seen on the computer in the garage)
- thinks the disc Paul discussed with Jill in Petscop 14 is the Petscop disc that Paul is playing on when we know Petscop was actively running at that time (that's the whole point of what Paul says after, he's not saying it's impossible to modify a disc he's saying it's impossible to modify a compiled game while it is running)
- Thinks Anna gets back with her abusive, deranged husband 20 years later for no established reason
- thinks Rainer saying "when the injured dog acts happy it's a lie" means Rainer sees all animals as worthless when it's just him going back to the A B NLM stuff (once the dog was hit by the car it is now dog B, which means the dog will never live the same way again)
- fails to even consider that Tiara had to have been a real person before Belle's attempted rebirth (if Lina was a real person they attempted to turn Care/Paul into, then Tiara must have been a real person they attempted to turn Belle into)
- fails to explain why Anna took a second photo of the windmill incident (why would she incriminate Marvin?)
- fails to give Rainer a reason to think Marvin killed his brother other than pure vibes
- thinks Anna runs the Petscop YouTube channel when you haven't even established a reason for her to want Petscop to be played, let alone broadcast it
- instead of the extremely obvious "Paul is a trans dude" take that makes 8x more sense, goes with "Paul was forcibly transitioned into care by his parents" to lump in Rainer's name for another #hype moment
- does not even attempt to explain how the Petscop 14 "magic trick" worked, nor any of the other cases of synchronization events. Which is like. I don't know. HALF of the question of Petscop?
- does not even elaborate on the the pets like he said he was going to
I think this may be the worst Petscop theory ever. It really feels like it was designed to be clipped. Especially the "the scar would look something... like this" and "Even Care" and the fucking Lina jumpscare.
