I haven't seen a competition for AC, so here you go. This is going to start with preliminary rounds of 6 characters each. These will include both villagers and special characters, like Tom Nook or Isabelle. I'll be including old characters who weren't in New Horizons, like Joan and Tortimer.
In the prelims, the top two from each poll will move on to the next round.
Propaganda is encouraged, but please no death threats or anything super violent. This is supposed to be fun.
I'm in the process of organizing the opening polls and gathering photos, but I don't mind starting this in a few days. Please reblog so we can have a better turn out.
This is gonna be the pinned post where I list all the polls as they go up! So it's gonna change! Give me a minute if im slow to update this post because I'm BUSY. I have THINGS TO DO.
Shitty tournament diagram pls enjoy my terrible handwriting.
Active polls:
Round 2:
Shino v Bruce
Chief v Audie
Amelia v Sunny
Meow v Apollo
Pierre v Walt
Vesta v Bob
Butch v Coco
Bam v Beau
Kabuki v Lolly
Kitty v Ankha
Tangy v Purrl
Willow v Bow
Petri v Molly
Sasha v Shep
Fauna v Lopez
Sherb v Chevre
Skye v Kyle
Marshal v Cheri
Etoile v Pietro
Olivia v Marina
Agnus v Pekoe
Gayle v Roald
Goldie v Whitney
Merengue v Margie
Dotty v Judy
Muffy v Cherry
Sprinkle v Chai
Stitches v Rosie
Punchy v Diana
Cephalobot v Lily
Ketchup v Lucky
Gladys v Maple
Completed polls:
Round 1:
Nindori, Wolfgang, Marshal, Hans, Epona, Frita, Ed, Eugene, Ace
Croque, Drift, Bertha, Ankha, Eunice, Bonbon, Hopkins, Diva, Leopold
Ozzie, Analog, Anicotti, Roscoe, Stitches, Cranston, Kiki, Megan, Boris
Megumi, Pancetti, Drake, Zucker, Etoile, Ione, Gen, W. Link, Deena
My Personal Aesthetic Rankings for All ACNH Villagers
Based on the theme of the character, how clever the design is, and how much they don't hurt my eyes because of my sensitivity to neon and bright colors.
I don't know if anyone has a need for this or if anyone has compiled a list already, but I made a list of ACNH villagers based on their home exterior. This is based on the general SHAPE of the house, NOT the other characteristics like window, porch light, roof, color, etc. The categories I have come up with are as follows:
“Beach Hut”
This is the rounded house with a rectangular porch and exposed bamboo. It should be noted that this is ~*~technically~*~ a version of the pueblo, but the exposed bamboo is a present feature in so many houses that I made it its own category.
This is made mostly for my own reference and convenience as I go island-hopping.
Tiers Explained
S: All-time favorites, godly tier
A: Favorites
B: I would not mind having on my island
C: I don’t want on my island; they are either pretty boring or just unpleasant
Shit: This is an abomination, why did they even make them
Notes
* I dislike the Jock personality so it’s a major point reduction, but if a character’s design is really strong, I might like them despite their Jock personality
* I am extremely picky and dislike a lot of characters; don’t bother yelling at me for hating your favorites
——————————————————————-
S-Tier: All-Time Favorites
Anteater - Anabelle
Cat - Ankha, Raymond
Chicken - Ken
Deer - Erik
Eagle - Amelia
Horse - Roscoe
Lion - Leopold
Ostrich - Flora, Julia, Phoebe
Sheep - Dom
Squirrel - Marshal
Wolf - Skye
A-Tier: Favorites
Deer - Bruce, Lopez, Beau, Zell
Eagle - Avery, Buzz, Apollo
Ostrich - Cranston, Blanche, Gladys, Phil
Wolf - Kyle
Bull - Rodeo
Squirrel - Poppy
Penguin - Hopper
Elephant - Tia
Goat - Kidd, Sherb
B-Tier: Wouldn’t Mind Having
Alligator - Gayle, Drago
Anteater - Pango
Bear - Megan
Bull - Stu
Bird - Sparro, Jacob
Cat - Punchy, Olivia, Tom
Chicken - Becky, Egbert, Knox, Plucky
Cub - Maple, Judy, June
Duck - Molly
Eagle - Celia, Sterling
Elephant - Cyd, Ellie
Hippo - Bertha
Horse - Cleo, Colton, Julian, Papi, Savannah, Victoria
Kangaroo - Walt
Koala - Melba, Yuka
Mouse - Chadder
Octopus - Marina
Penguin - Aurora, Boomer
Pig - Boris, Agnes
Sheep - Wendy
Squirrel - Agent S, Blaire, Pecan, Static, Tasha
Wolf - Chief, Audie, Dobie, Lobo, Vivian, Whitney, Wolfgang