i always love reading more about your umineko AUs but i saw the tags about the battler&erika exes one this morning and have been thinking about them on and off all day, do you happen to have any other thoughts on it to share?
Two angles would pretty interesting on whether
1)Erika as a piece too has amnesia till end of EP6
It would be extremely mean of Bernkastel but big Tohya-Ikuko parallel. Battler also ends up TWICE in the position in the seat of sby who remembers while his loved ones(platonic) don't remember jack, feat Question Arcs stubborness levels in Erika.
That scenario probably have him grant her an extra foot of forgiviness for the wedding given she didn't remember.
2)Erika as a piece has all her human memories
We critically lack information of how Battler's six year-gap went down. With that said the way in EP1 he says there wasn't much choice in coming back after his grandparents' deaths and in EP4 where he says he didn't even want to come to the conference, I don't think his close friends and possible exes would have a positive oppinion of the Ushiromiya family. (did any Ushiromiya relative beside Rudolf and maybe Kyrie go to the funerals of Asumu's parents?)
So if Erika is roped in as a piece from a meta standpoint and is constantly confronted with how they were much shitter than Battler's stories in school, she would have way more trouble seeing the family with love and understand why Piece+Meta Battler defends them so.
Also always ending up into plots around your ex's life would get super annoying fast.
As for Erika's resurrection in 1998
Now Dawn is extremely weird as a forgery, with Ange's reading not having happened in prime, so it's up in the air whether the Hachijos just stuffed it in a drawer or put it on the web. The latter probably would result on Erika banging on their door and giving Tohya a mini heart attack. Though her being in on that would be a nice parallel to her assisting Ange reaching the truth alongside Evatrice.
If you want to go with the absolute bonkers scenario, Amakusa is Erika the human's post 86 identity and Amakusa stepping out during the EP6 tea party was also to handle the onslaught of memories coming back. The trick ending does feature Amakusa being killed while Erika comes back while EP4 Amakusa has death by gun just like EP6 Erika.
(and if you're a believer in Erika's canon ex being younger Amakusa then I guess she ends up stealing her ex-boyfriend's looks post 86)










