Following the hickey headcanons: first time kissing Pluto???? gn!reader going slow on him and being gentle while they kiss him for the first time, and all the tension before and during the kiss????
I'm glad you liked it! Here's your first kiss with Pluto.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------
You were both on a balcony you found tucked deep in the school at night— was it against the rules? Technically. But hey, it was accidental, you simply wanted some water and Pluto was out because he couldn’t sleep with Montresor banging Ada next door. Or well— he assumed it was Ada, could’ve been anyone. Anyway, here the two of you were in the moonlight, leaning on the railing and smiled at each other. How it ended up romantic, you have no clue. Maybe it;s because you leaned into him for warmth or maybe it’s because he leaned back. But it was definitely when you took his hands and leaned closer and it really is his fault for staring at your lips before looking into your eyes.
So here you were, trying to calm a trembling Pluto. “If you don’t want to, we don't have—” “No! I…I really want to.” He mumbled, “I just don’t know how.” And then you laugh, well it’s more of a giggle but still, rude. He blinks, flustered. “What?” He asked, already thinking he messed up. But you shake your head. “You’re cute when you’re flustered. Just follow my lead.” And he’s even more flustered. He’s shaking but doesn’t pull back as your lips meet. It’s soft and gentle but his mind is anything but.
Duke found out and relentlessly teased him.